6 ms·
Wonder who their target demographic is. People balk at paying for email from a known provider, let alone buy a box to run it out of their own home for $100. You
by azinman2 8y ago
Wonder who their target demographic is. People balk at paying for email from a known provider, let alone buy a box to run it out of their own home for $100. You’d have to have a lot of motivation to do so, and it feels like the Venn diagram of people who are savvy and motivated enough to care about digital privacy, intersected with those with technical skills feels like nearly 90% overlap. And I’m not so sure the privacy group is so sizable. I’d probably be in this camp but I really don’t want to have to worry about spam filters, triggering them in others by sending from my home ISP, nor dealing with backup or corrupted databases. Wonder what their plan is there...
The average person who wants this without being their own sysadmin should probably just use Apple products. I work for Apple and can attest that privacy isn’t just marketing — it permeates all decision making in every discussion I’ve been a part of... sometimes making it harder or impossible to create the things we’d like to have (privacy wins). I know many on HN will want their “freedom” as in “freedom box,” but the average user massively benefits from an ecosystem designed to make things as easy, desirable, and supported as possible.
- galonk 8y agoIt doesn't even do email, so you'd still be paying a known provider :)
- kelnos 8y agoI assume you're getting downvoted due to the Apple advocacy in your second paragraph, and hopefully not for your first paragraph. I entirely agree with that. I wish I didn't have to be cynical about things like this, but I just don't see the market for this device, and when it comes to social-network-like things, you need a large market for network effects to kick in.
- belorn 8y agoThe initial idea was a device similar to a answering machine in size, price and interface. That is, a $10-$20 price range and a simple configure-once-and-forget interface. Pioneer Edition FreedomBox Home Server Kit is clearly not there yet, but I would hazard a guess that their target demographic is currently on developers and tech savvy privacy advocates who can afford a bit steeper price for a "server kit".
- kelnos 8y agoBut still, who would buy that $10-$20 device? If it doesn't replicate their Facebook/Instagram/whatever experience, and they don't know how to get their friends on it (the majority of whom probably aren't too privacy-conscious), it's just a paperweight
- ibeckermayer 8y agoYou can get the same network effects of these cloud services through federated networks. Imagine "Federate-book" I run and host my own "Facebook wall" on my local box (or wherever I choose to host), friends can request access to view my content ("friend requests") which I can then control and manage myself, "Facebook groups" are hosted by wherever their creator decides, and moderation is the right/responsibility of the creator of the group. If some host-er of the federate-book wants to aggregate my data and sell it to third parties, they can make that clear in their terms and I can opt-in/out of that arrangement. If my host-er wants to use machine learning and other methods to wipe my feed of their definition of "abuse" or "fake news", they can try that and I can determine if I trust their judgement. I'll choose whether I want to hear what Alex Jones has to say for myself, thank you very much. If somebody is illicitly calling for violence and should be forcefully banned and punished, then this can be dealt with by the (admittedly imperfect,) relatively transparent and principled system of laws that include foundational principles of justice like innocence until proven guilty, and the rights of the accused to defend themselves. The status quo cloud-silos governed by a small group of executives opining about what censorship-policies will garner them the greatest profits next quarter are dangerous single points of failure for user privacy, and inherently at risk for becoming tools of tyrannical control and manipulation. Yes there is much work to be done in building good protocols for federated social networks that even grandma can make use of, but guess whose fault that is? "The cloud" didn't exist 20 years ago either, and its ubiquity and ease of use should be attributed to the literal billions (if not trillions) of dollars of R&D that has been thrown at it. We really can "have our cake and eat it too" in this domain, if the engineers and venture capitalists that build/fund these tools directed R&D appropriately. As the (predictable but unfortunately unmitigated) true cost of a generation of "cloud" mania slowly becomes apparent to the general public, we will likely see a greater groundswell of market demand "fediverse" products and services. Undoubtedly the rent-seeking cloud providers will try and prevent this through propaganda and by force -- we're already seeing this in the "fake news" hysteria and Zuckerberg's call for regulation of social media. But if America's legal institutions and popular support can hold the barbarians at bay, we will hopefully be living with a very different internet 20 years from now. (Didn't really know where I would end up with this comment and it sort of turned into a rallying cry so I'll go with it. Yeah HN, let's do it!)
- frenchy 8y agoI think the target market is a little larger than you think. The problem with Apple products is that they're a walled garden, and an expensive one to boot. My privacy isn't worth $4000 for a set of new computers, but it might be worth $100. I'd still probably end up using Linux for my day-to-day programming needs, because I find it easier to use. While I suspect most of the target market could set up their own server (it's not rocket science-a smart 12 year-old could), a lot of us couldn't be bothered. A lot of people who buy hammers at the store probably could make their own hammer in their shop, but why would they? Also, speaking of 12-year olds, I think this would be a great thing for kids to tinker with .. set up their own website and whatnot.