3 ms·
How would you improve the ranking system?
by mike-cardwell 16y ago
How would you improve the ranking system?
- chroma 16y agoI don't know of a complete fix, but a start would be to rank based on upvotes in the past hour (or 2 hours, or whatever works best) instead of since submission. This would allow links submitted days ago to end up on the front page if they were recently upvoted a lot. The new algorithm could be put on an alternate front page (similar to http://news.ycombinator.com/classic http://news.ycombinator.com/classic) until it was tweaked to get the desired result. Since detection of duplicates and content mirrors is currently done best by humans, I think another aspect of the solution is cultural. If we want to stop this sort of thing, people need to point out mirroring/linking and flag submissions. If we do it enough, the incentives will change to discourage this behavior.
- eru 16y agoSounds like a good solution that would also decrease the asymmetry between first submission, new submission and up-voting. (There's one asymmetry that we'd like to keep: Who gets the karma, but the asymmetry of those actions on ranking aren't as interesting.)
- tibbon 16y agoI would final duplicate content and automatically merge likely submissions together. Spread the karma between the first 3 submitters in a 50/35/15 manner, so that the latter two still have incentive to spread the link outside of HN.
- mike-cardwell 16y agoThat sounds easily abusable to me. People would just submit a duplicate article when they see an article gaining upvotes.
- blahedo 16y agoIf there were a "dup" button that let you actually mark what's a duplicate of what, you can try all sorts of things to shift karma and points around. EDIT: I fleshed this idea out a bit and submitted it as an Ask HN: http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=1975950 http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=1975950