9 ms·
It still comes down to a race between Tesla figuring out the complete automotive supply chain and competitors figuring out EVs. Tesla had, and I would assume s
by hef19898 8y ago
It still comes down to a race between Tesla figuring out the complete automotive supply chain and competitors figuring out EVs.
Tesla had, and I would assume still has, production hell. Now it's delivery hell. Both are solved, controlled and executed constantly by other car companies (VW has an exception with the new Golf 8 that proves the rule).
The competition is still struggling to solve EVs, some like Jaguar and Audi and BMW and others seem to be ahead of others.
Advantage Tesla: EV brand, EV dedicated basis for their cars, software and experience with batteries
Advantage competition: scaling production and delivery, economies of scale
I would argue that the window of opportunity for Tesla is closing now. Which might not be good news for them. And given the ever shorter life cycles in the automotive sector the window ever was max. one facelift / model replacement. Which again is something the competition is doing constantly for decades now. Tesla never did it once.
So I see the advantage on the competition but not by a big margin. Had Tesla solved their production and supply chain earlier the margin wouldn't be there at all or Tesla even be a head of others. The biggest risks for Tesla are a) to miss the window of opportunity they have and be b) to run out of cash before their issues are solved. Both are related and I suspect Elon is much a help regarding the cash side as he is a hindrance regarding the rest.
- kmonsen 8y agoSure Tesla can make good cars, but not if it has to sell them at a profit. Over the lifetime of Tesla, each car has been subsidized by like 10k from shareholders and 7.5k from government. Both subsidies are going away as we speak.
- jsight 8y agoThat is really not true. Each individual car is sold for more than the cost of manufacturer. Statistics like this tend to take fixed costs and historical costs into account in a way that shouldn't be divided by unit volume. I caution you to read more about this, as you see statistics like this quoted often in the press. It is almost always an indicator of issues with article quality.
- lonnyk 8y agoI read earlier that model 3s had. 20% gross margin. I’m happy to find the source again if you’re interested, but I'd also love to see your source.
- sokoloff 8y agoWhen considering whether a fleet of cars has been profitable, you can’t consider only the gross margin (which excludes certain company fixed costs to arrive at an answer to “was that last car we made profitable?”) but must also consider overall profitability (“did we make money doing all of the things we did?”) Tesla’s answer to the second is “no” for substantially all of the company history.
- sliken 8y agoAgreed. The are using gross margin to fuel crazy growth. Much like Amazon. Tesla went from 0 2012 to #1 in 2018 in the premium segment. Certainly looks like if they stopped expanding at a crazy rate that they would collect profits at a very healthy rate. I'm sure just about everyone in the premium segment would love to "fail" by selling 63,000 cars costing over $50k each with gross margin of 20%.
- dsfyu404ed 8y agoTesla doesn't make good cars. They make unremarkable cars with good drive-trains. It's like the EV version of FCA's ~700hp offerings. Sure the interior and build quality are kind of crap for what you pay but with 700 ponies on tap you don't care.
- leesec 8y agoThis is a joke right? They make some of the most highly regarded cars of all time. Recently buying one and showing it off almost every single person (30~) was blown away at how much better it was then their car and wanted one in the future. Tesla has many problems but making bad cars isn't one of them, these things are awesome.
- dsfyu404ed 8y agoNo it's not a joke. The Model 3 and Model S have relatively high NVH and a relatively cheap feeling interior compared to vehicles of the same class and price point. You're paying German car money but it goes to the drive-train instead of the "luxury German driving machine" experience. There's nothing wrong with that but to talk up Tesla's vehicles as though they're luxury cars is foolish.
- leesec 8y agoYeah thanks for explaining it to me, I own one. I personally couldn't care less about the interior but I understand some people do. The driving/overall experience to me is night and day when compared to ICE vehicles or even other EV competitors.
- jsight 8y agoI just can't agree with that on the model 3. The model 3 is basically BM 3 series money, and there is nothing particularly phenomenal about the BMW 3 series from a luxury standpoint.
- spamizbad 8y ago
- Radzell 8y agoSandy Munroe A guy who rip appart cars proved this wrong a while ago. The Tesla M3 only takes 25k to build with parts and labors.
- imglorp 8y agoTesla has one more advantage over all the fossils: they're all in. The old guys are still challenged on mission, twisted up and fighting internally, bringing out weak token products designed to not hurt their ICE lines.
- dagw 8y agoI think this is probably more important than people give it credit for. I have an acquaintance who works R&D at a traditional car company (but on self driving features) he says the internal 'fights' between ICE and electric are very real and damaging.
- imglorp 8y agoYou can experience it first hand if you go try to test drive a Chevy Bolt - Motor Trend car of the year in 2017. I spoke to dealers who (pretended?) unawareness of the model and didn't want to help me find one. Another tried to talk me out of it. Finally one dealer was well informed about its pros and cons, and had several for sale. Another example: bmw i3. 114 mile range on the 2017 model, really? And that's up from less than 100 miles before that. Painfully token.
- rcxdude 8y agoThe big problem the big auto manufacturers are having is the battery and cost. A mass-market electric car cannot cost as much as Tesla's offerings, and a huge part of that cost is the battery. Even with the most optimistic cost projections of battery costs in the near future, it's hard to see how to offer an electric car which is competitive on both cost and range with an ICE car.
- imglorp 8y agoTrue, if they're going to price under Tesla, they'll need the courage to be unprofitable until they have the volume to get positive. Another issue is subsidies. Carmakers have enjoyed billions from the states... https://www.reuters.com/article/us-toyota-mazda-jobs-factbox-idUSKBN1AK2BI https://www.reuters.com/article/us-toyota-mazda-jobs-factbox... That's not counting an $80b bailout... https://www.thebalance.com/auto-industry-bailout-gm-ford-chrysler-3305670 https://www.thebalance.com/auto-industry-bailout-gm-ford-chr... And what about gas prices being artificially kept low with subsidies... https://www.nrdc.org/experts/danielle-droitsch/time-us-end-fossil-fuel-subsidies https://www.nrdc.org/experts/danielle-droitsch/time-us-end-f... So the true cost and TCO of an ICE car is not at all obvious to compute compared to an electric.
- mtgx 8y agoTesla is wasting time, money and focus by investing too much in self-driving tech (they're even having their own chip division now! - is Tesla really in financial a position to compete with Intel/Nvidia now?). Not to mention they made all of their Model 3's thousands of dollars more expensive by including the "full self-driving hardware-that-wasn't" in every unit to the point where it didn't even make sense for Tesla to sell the base model anymore. Keep it simple stupid - focus on making great high-value EVs, and keep dropping their prices in a profitable manner. Stop throwing billions of dollars on "full self-driving tech" that will never work well enough.
- c0vfefe 8y ago> Keep it simple stupid - focus on making great high-value EVs, and keep dropping their prices in a profitable manner. Problem is, self-driving is an essential part of their image of high-tech luxury. Their marketing strategy depends on being the opposote of KISS. Making the best cars they can while also being electric is the only way to get the volume necessary to make electric affordable.
- cagenut 8y agothere is a line of reasoning, rarely articulated, that EVs will never reach the price points it would take to fully 100% replace ICE cars in the private/personal market. li-ion batteries have done an excellent job walking down the learning/cost curve, but we can all see the way it bends and how much headroom is left in the chemistry. we'll likely hit $100/kwh in the next few years, but even just $80/kwh is likely 5+ years away after that. the model 3 will never start with a $2. so if you're going to bottom out at around 3x the price it would take to fully replace the existing market... then you have to figure out a way to get 3x+ the value out of the asset you're delivering. that means some combination of lasting 3x longer (~500k miles) and/or being in use 3x more (~600hrs/year). the former is viably unlocked by the EV engineering advantages, but w/r/t the latter, individual drivers have no intention of tripling their car usage. so it simply has to be turned into some kind of shared asset. imho self driving makes this a nirvanna, so I'm glad they're pursuing it, but its not actually required. tesla could add a basic uber/lyft feature set to their existing app and then when the last 0.01% of self driving winds up taking years longer than elon said it would he can blame the regulators and just make it a regular human-driver ride sharing app. remember the mission is the end of carbon emissions, so any plan for "lets just get good market share and margins in the luxury segment" is a plan to fail.
- LeifCarrotson 8y ago> Both are solved, controlled and executed constantly by other car companies. Executed for ICE cars and their components. They don't have the supply chains for batteries, inverters, or electric motors.
- angstrom 8y agoIf only it was so clean cut. Tesla isn't even operating in all 50 states due to specific laws in 1/2 which prohibit direct sales. This is part of the reason for switching to service centers and transitioning sales completely to app based purchasing. Tesla is driving the biggest wedge of change through the world economy in the 21st century. The impact these changes have will affect everyone who uses, sells, services and advertises automobiles. It's no wonder the amount of outright vitriol the press propagates given the lack of advertising Tesla does.
- rayiner 8y ago> Tesla is driving the biggest wedge of change through the world economy in the 21st century. I suspect the press vitriol is because Musk actually believes crap like this. Nobody likes someone who is high on their own kool-aid.
- hef19898 8y agoTrue. Couple of things on that. Yes, the existing supply chain is not geared towards EVs (which is serious problem in terms of chanel masters and such). Still the knowledge and tools and processes and people are there. Combine that with the fact that an EV is actually less complex an ICE powered car incumbents, I assume, should be able to switch easily (biggest issues being internal struggles keeping them from executing as a lot of powerful people in these companies have to loose a lot). Still, the basis is there as is the purchasing power and the aftermarket activities and such. As far as Tesla is concerned, they have production hell and delivery hell. On top of that I suspect they have a kind of procurement hell as well with Panasonic as one the most important suppliers. Together that results in Supply Chain hell. So while Tesla's SC is geared towards EVs im not sure on the execution side. But this is just my outside point of view.
- benj111 8y ago"And given the ever shorter life cycles in the automotive sector the window ever was max. one facelift / model replacement" That assumes that Tesla's competitors actually have the expertise to compete. Its been mentioned elsewhere I believe, that Audi's Etron has less range per kwh of battery, compared to a Tesla. Tesla also has a charging network. I'm tempted to turn your statement around and say there's a rapidly closing window for the other car makers to start taking EVs seriously. I suspect theres going to be a tipping point situation where the market for EVs is going to rapidly increase, and the established car makers better hope they have something they can sell, and at scale, because theres the Chinese as well as Tesla all ready to go. My crystal ball doesn't tell me what car companies are going to go bust, but I predict there'll be some big names, and Tesla could be one of them, I doubt it would disappear as a car making entity though.
- bryanlarsen 8y ago> Advantage competition: scaling production and delivery, economies of scale Really? Evidence suggests otherwise. Hyundai Kona Electric: huge backorders, yet they only made 2000 of them in February. https://insideevs.com/news/343420/hyundai-kona-electric-production-down-but-why/ https://insideevs.com/news/343420/hyundai-kona-electric-prod... Audi eTron: 2019 production targets lowered 20% to 45K/year. https://www.electrive.com/2019/04/23/audi-revises-production-numbers-of-the-e-tron-downwards/ https://www.electrive.com/2019/04/23/audi-revises-production... Jaguar seems to be doing OK with the iPace, but they only sold 1400 of them in February, and of course Jaguar as a car company is a similar size to Tesla.
- rad_gruchalski 8y ago> Advantage competition: scaling production and delivery, economies of scale And service, and spares. This is where Tesla is really struggling. Especially spare parts.
- SEJeff 8y agoThat said, their "Tesla Ranger" program where the mechanic comes to you is the future. It is easily one of the coolest things Tesla does and is a sensible way to scale out their service centers which are (admittedly) overbooked.
- elAhmo 8y agoWould you mind sharing more info about VW Golf 8 you mentioned?