4 ms·
VW Group’s recent Audi e-tron has to 30-40% lower range than a Tesla 3 (~200 miles vs ~325 miles) and as such I would totally see them putting forward the money
by paganel 8y ago
VW Group’s recent Audi e-tron has to 30-40% lower range than a Tesla 3 (~200 miles vs ~325 miles) and as such I would totally see them putting forward the money to buy Tesla in order to bridge this big technological gap.
- cjhopman 8y agoIf you think that's a $10 billion gap, you're delusional.
- sliken 8y agoAccess to the Panasonic battery supply is likely worth a pretty penny. I've been hearing about battery supply problems from Jaguar and Audi already.
- dragonwriter 8y ago> Access to the Panasonic battery supply is likely worth a pretty penny. Licensing/partnership contracts are often written so that they don't automatically survive changes of ownership, which makes buying into such a partnership by acquisition less than reliable.
- paganel 8y agoI may be delusional but I actually own a VW Group car, I know of people who make their living on mostly repairing VW's past mishaps (stuff like this [1]), I have no stake whatsoever in Tesla's future financial success, and as such I can tell you that VW (and the Germans generally speaking) are way, way behind in terms of EV technology compared to Tesla because stuff like this it's not in their engineering DNA. $10 billions is a pittance, it gives you two thirds of Whatsapp or the entire Skype before it was acquired by MS (adjusted for inflation), so I don't think I'm delusional when I'm saying that it is not a great sum to pay when the future of your entire industry depends on you being best at building EVs (and Tesla now is the best). I've had the same discussion on places like /r/cars, i.e. that Tesla doesn't sell cars, it sells batteries and the accompanying software (with some wheels attached to the whole thing), while companies like VW, MB or BMW have almost no clue on how to build the best batteries, never mind the best software, they're only good at building cars (and lately not so good even at that), which is an industry on its way out. [1] https://mybroadband.co.za/forum/threads/tsi-engine-problems.999564/ https://mybroadband.co.za/forum/threads/tsi-engine-problems....
- Gustomaximus 8y agoAlso other companies might be willing to go in on at this price to be a top compeitor for self driving or batteries. Apple must have considered it. Uber. Tencent. Facebook. Alibaba. Walmart. Outside car manufacturers there's a lot of cashed up companies that would like to take a punt in this space.
- drewg123 8y agoI could not have said it better. I own a Model X, and I always tell my friends "Tesla is a tech company, but they have no idea how to build cars". I think I'm going to expand that into what you said.
- emptyfile 8y agoGotta love HN comments about Tesla.
- Gudoguru 8y agoAgreed
- navigatesol 8y agoIt's not just HN, it's everywhere. Anything that comes out of the mouth of Elon is an instant fact, and is repeated as fact until it's proven false. Then it was merely a prediction or plan. He just went on stage and told investors that their non-existent, full self-driving robot taxi fleet will cut the cost of personal transport by 90% over Uber, and will make the car owners $10-$30k+ ("in some cases more!") in annual income. It's a pipe dream, but now it's talked about like it's already happening. Remember Solar City and the solar shingles? Their solar deployment is 25% of what it was the quarter he made that announcement. "Synergies!". Meanwhile, they are winding down the company. In a year people will forget it was ever a thing.
- loceng 8y agoDid you watch the presentation relating to the Tesla chip release - along with watching the fully self-driving vehicle video? They had the lead chip engineer explain their improvements, and they had their AI lead explain why they're at the lead for this - both very experienced and articulate people in their fields. I don't understand how you say it's a pipe dream unless you don't comprehend what they're sharing. If they're outright lying about the operations per second speeds (TOPS) they announced then that's one thing, however I doubt they would. Another thing to realize is Tesla will be self-interested, as they should be to some degree, so how much profit they will allow non-Tesla owned vehicles to operate in the Tesla Network could heavily be dictated by them - so I wouldn't necessarily go out and buy 20 vehicles to inject them for full-time Tesla Network usage, however some people may take that gamble and then it also fronts money to Tesla. Even if the improvements are 1/4 of what they announced, it is significant. Re: Solar City - they've had to redirect battery and other resources to focus on the vehicles. You're making a lot of assumptions. It might help to balance that out with they're working very hard, have very intelligent people on board, their work and effort has already lead them to this level of success, they're working on creating a whole ecosystem on limited resources that they have to manage, and they have the semi and other vehicles lined up for next year - which they already have pre-orders in for as well. I'd say you're a bit too hyper-focused on certain things, and no, I'm not suggesting to not be skeptical and understand they may not meet their goals and on time the 100% that gamblers-as-investors are betting on them to have.
- vonmoltke 8y agoThe first e-tron model to go into production is a 5-door SUV equivalent to the Model X. Why are you comparing it to the Model 3?
- paganel 8y agoBecause I find them pretty similar in terms of size, the e-tron is 4.9 m long while the model 3 is slightly shorter, at 4.6 m, but it’s in the same ballpark. For comparison my hatch-back is 1 meter shorter, it has a length of 3.6 meters. In the end the market will be the one to decide.
- rdtfjgykh 8y agoIf there is a technology gap, the company that has the know-how is Panasonic, not Tesla.