5 ms·
I haven't figured out a good opinion on the controversies of trigger warnings and safe spaces. It might be a brief pendulum swing. I think that we all could s
by neilv 8y ago
I haven't figured out a good opinion on the controversies of trigger warnings and safe spaces. It might be a brief pendulum swing. I think that we all could stand to show more sensitivity to everyone else, and I don't know whether that would be enough.
But I've never met any 12th-grader who is so knowledgeable and wise that frosh year at a proper college shouldn't shake up their developing mind, and challenge much of what they thought they knew -- about the world, themselves, and even thinking itself.
(College is not a place to party and practice your whiteboarding theatre until you can get a FAANG job, knowing not much more than you did in high school.)
Whether it's in the humanities, social sciences, quantum physics, or even functional programming: if students are not surprised and uncomfortable at times, I'd think they're not learning enough.
- labster 8y agoPart of the thing about the safe space movement at universities is that it's happening at just about the same time that universities have just about completed their transition from educational institutions into corporations. If you think about them as any other corporation, they are just doing their best to keep the customers coming. Would you want to pay money to faculty who challenges the consumer's assumptions, or do you want to build a strong lifestyle brand, which in turn drives future "donations", sports income. Every other corporation is giving us information tailored to our desires, so why would a university want to risk the corporate enterprise on antagonistic professors with differing opinions? That just devalues the brand. Note that the OP has been a "professor" at Duke for 20 years, but has essentially no job security. He's basically an independent contractor in the gig economy. That's kinda common in the community college level, but it looks like it's finally made its way to the elite schools too. We used to have secretaries for professors, but now the colleges have secretaries for the deputy assistant administrators. So to me the trigger warning, safe space culture wars are only a symptom of the problem that our universities have become mirrors of the large corporations.
- neilv 8y agoI don't know about the particular case in the article, but I thought the tradition of tenure was partly to permit professors to pursue currently-unpopular ideas, like perhaps this person was doing at Duke. I didn't know a prominent university would have a non-tenure-track professor teaching for 20 years. What is that hefty tuition paying for? I've talked with some tenured professors who hire adjuncts, and they feel bad about the situation, but those individual professors had no say over it. Perhaps if entire faculties came together and petitioned, at least at the wealthier places, universities might spring for all instructors being tenure-track professors (assisted by grad students).
- qazpot 8y agoVery astute observation.
- Animats 8y agoI haven't figured out a good opinion on the controversies of trigger warnings and safe spaces. It might be a brief pendulum swing. Not sure. But we're seeing more pushback on fat acceptance.[1] [1] https://www.military.com/daily-news/2018/01/16/army-recruits-southern-states-most-unfit-prone-injury-study.html https://www.military.com/daily-news/2018/01/16/army-recruits...
- chippy 8y agoHigher education has changed as students are now consumers who are investing large amounts of money in the form of debt. No one would want to be uncomfortable for that exchange, students these days ask for more value for money. They want a good exchange with little risk.