33 ms·
Terrorist don't give a damn about ports and cable stations, they go after office workers and schoolchildren. The government's and terrorist's idea of vulnerabl
by varjag 16y ago
Terrorist don't give a damn about ports and cable stations, they go after office workers and schoolchildren.
The government's and terrorist's idea of vulnerable is fundamentally different. In Russia they were securing gas pipes, nuclear stations, cabbage sorting plants and whatnot, but terrorist hit apartment buildings, theaters, hospitals and schools.
- regularfry 16y agoTraditionally, yes. With al Qaeda (inasmuch as there is a single body with unified aims), not so much. One of bin Laden's videos spelt it out: their aim is to economically cripple the US and the West by forcing them to spend a vastly disproportionate amount of money on security measures through performing relatively cheap acts of violence. It just so happens that attacks involving large numbers of civilians are particularly effective for this, because the political pressure to protect the public is high. In the case of targets on this list, there is a similar pressure to protect them, but in general they won't be as expensive to guard because their nature makes it easier to restrict access. If I were on the Chinese politburo, though, this leak would read like a literal shopping list.
- varjag 16y agoWell, it does not happen like that accidentally. The whole point of terrorist attack is terrorizing the population to achieve one's political objectives. To terrorize population you hit where it hurts the people. People are less emotional about shut down plants than they are about dead children. > If I were on the Chinese politburo, though, this leak would read like a literal shopping list. You bring a point here. This list makes sense (and is obvious) if you have a strategic bomber command in your disposal. Otherwise a few of those isolated attacks will fail to shatter the economy. Remember how many bombs were unleashed on German industry in WW2 before it started showing any effect. Attacking population on the other hand is accessible and effective, that's the whole idea behind the terror. So a proper, realistic list should be "dense urban areas of the United States". Of course it's not what the embassies were assigned to find out, so they really did an honest, if mostly useless, job.
- regularfry 16y agoPossibly you misunderstand me. I don't mean that the Chinese (for instance) might want to bomb what's on the list (although that would certainly be one approach). I mean that they might literally wish to (and be capable of) buying what's on the list. We all know they've been cornering African mineral exploitation for the last decade or so, I'm sure they wouldn't object to another cobalt mine or two on their acquisition list, even if they had to pay an absurd premium.
- varjag 16y agoOh, I see. Either way, the list could be just as easily compiled by Chinese self as it was by the U.S. missions, most of it is based on public knowledge and open sources. It's not that I suggest leaking it made any practical sense, but IMO the dangers of it are greatly exaggerated.
- Jach 16y agoThis is a very important point. It seems that for the past decade it's only become increasingly clearer that we've had these terrorists' motivations and desires all wrong or we're dealing with very stupid people. I consider it a mix of both; does anyone still believe they're out to destroy "our freedom"? And I also would bet that for many individuals on HN, were they not good people, they could trivially cause some major damage.
- grandalf 16y agoSuperb point. It would be trivial to create attacks sufficient to grind public transit to a halt in a major city for weeks and result in a crackdown on civil liberties,... among other things. That nobody has done this stuff underscores just how much of a non-threat terrorism is.
- lionhearted 16y ago> It would be trivial to create attacks sufficient to grind public transit to a halt in a major city for weeks and result in a crackdown on civil liberties,... among other things. You mean like the train and bus bombings in Israel, Spain, England? That have slowed down and largely stopped after the military campaigns in Afghanistan, Iraq, Pakistan, and other parts of the Middle East?
- grandalf 16y agoNo, far simpler bombings. Ones that would require less than $50 in supplies. There has been nothing in the US. Are you seriously telling me that of all the tens of thousands of angry, disaffected people in the US, those who have contemplated doing such attacks decided not to because they realized that the act would cause more destruction in Afghanistan? Similarly, there have not even been any machine gun attacks at malls or airports -- imagine what even a few dozen shots fired at the crowds on black friday would have done to holiday retail numbers. Surely someone thought of this in the past 9 years. So you are arguing that of the tens of thousands of people in the US who ostensibly want to commit such acts, a) none have thought of it, b) they are working on some far more diabolical plot, or c) they have been dissuaded by the US bombing of the middle east? On the contrary, I think the truth is that life is good, people are friendly, etc., but most importantly, people care far more about their next meal than they do about abstract concepts, political struggles, etc.
- krschultz 16y agoWell, they did kill a few dozen US sailors by blowing a hole in the side of a destroyer with 2" thick steel plating and a few hundred people by attacking two embassies guarded by US marines prior to 9/11. So I'm not sure they wouldn't considering hitting military or economic targets today. They also got a few cruise missiles in response to the first two attacks, and they got a massive war in response to 9/11. That kind of speaks to how much more effective hitting big civilian targets is for the terrorists than the military and economic ones, but I don't think we can just shrug this off because they've changed course a bit. (I don't personally believe that hitting Iraq was a good response to 9/11, but you can't argue that if 9/11 hadn't happened Bush would have had any public support to invade Iraq. Without 9/11 there is no Iraq war. With 9/11 and a different president, I doubt there is an Iraq war then either)