8 ms·
The irony is that Tesla was supposed to bankroll SpaceX, but SpaceX is killing it on profits and Tesla is floundering. If anything it looks like SpaceX will en
by nostrademons 8y ago
The irony is that Tesla was supposed to bankroll SpaceX, but SpaceX is killing it on profits and Tesla is floundering. If anything it looks like SpaceX will end up bankrolling Tesla.
Musk should forget about trying to save this planet and focus on getting to the red one.
- toomuchtodo 8y agoIt’s a shame people condemn Tesla’s for its troubles when internal combustion gets a ridiculous amount of subsided despite it causing irreparable harm to the planet. Musk plays on Boss Mode (along with others) while everyone enjoys bread and circus and laughs at people trying to accelerate progress with regards to climate change. I hope those quarterly profits, trucks, and SUVs are worth it when climate change hits its stride. Humans can be irrational, ignorant animals.
- mamon 8y agoWe are definitely living in different universes. ICEs do not get any subsidies, quite the opposite: in many countries, e.g. the whole EU gas is so heavily taxed that more than half of the retail price is tax. Also, Tesla is an easy target to make fun of, because of its narcistic, arrogant CEO that seems to think that he can outsmart everyone, when in fact his business is a total mess.
- toomuchtodo 8y agoGas is about $3/gallon in the US. Ford is moving towards only making SUVs, pickup trucks, and the Mustang. Different countries, not different universes. I like that Musk is narcissistic and arrogant in public. He doesn’t hide it like the execs at every automaker who was part of Dieselgate. Be an asshole, by all means, just deliver faster. (Credit to BYD and their electric bus fleet efforts, and China’s renewables push in general; I would be remiss if I made it sound like Musk alone was working towards these goals).
- golfer 8y agoDo you also love it when Musk calls people pedos? What about when he lies about taking the company private on Twitter? This is the narcissism you enjoy?
- toomuchtodo 8y agoI don’t love it, but I don’t care about it either. It’s noise. I’ve seen far better people take far worse actions. No one’s perfect. Stress is unpleasant and will cause you to lash out. I do love someone who doesn’t cultivate an image. I think this is 100% who Musk has become, for better and worse, and I respect someone who is genuine about who they are, warts and all.
- jwr 8y agoOf course ICEs get subsidies. The subsidy is in the form of a carbon tax that we do not collect, even though we should. Every ICE produces emissions which will soon make most of our planet uninhabitable. There should be a carbon tax, so that we can offset this destruction: by building nuclear plants, or figuring out how to re-capture the carbon emitted into the atmosphere. And yet we do not collect that tax, hence heavily subsidizing ICEs. This is credited by our children and grandchildren, who will end up with a massively changed (for the worse) planet.
- gwright 8y agoYou have a point about the negative externalities, but insisting on using the word "subsidy" for that concept is just going to confuse people. That isn't the accepted meaning of "subsidy", in casual conversation at least.
- jwr 8y agoHmm — how else would you call it? As I understand it, future generations are subsidizing the price of our fossil fuels and internal combustion engines, making ICEs artificially cheap by not considering their environmental impact. Subsidies do not have to be in the form of cash: many come in the form of tax breaks and I would consider this to be one such case.
- gwright 8y agoIt is just confusing to use the same word to suggest explicit assistance (cash, tax breaks, etc) and "failure to penalize". I guess mathematically they both represent a reduction in cost when compared to an alternative scenario (no subsidy and some sort of tax/fee for the externality) but they are different mechanisms and so it makes sense for them to have different words to describe them if you want to communicate clearly.
- Consultant32452 8y agoIt gets far worse when you consider the total cost of wars to protect the flow of oil.
- ajmurmann 8y agoThe oil industry, at least in the US, receives huge tax breaks. This indirectly subsidized the ICEs that burn them.
- maxerickson 8y agoYuh, electricity production totally doesn't overlap with the subsidies that petroleum drilling gets, not one little bit, not at all. Of course moving to electric vehicles is a necessary step towards getting off of the petrocarbons, but it isn't sufficient, production of electricity also has to move off of them.
- toomuchtodo 8y agoYou’re being disingenuous. You want to argue drilling subsidies for fracking cheap natgas for power generation? I won’t argue against that. But it’s all going renewables on economics alone (renewables and batteries are already cheaper than natural gas and coal), just not fast enough. We need to get off of combustion vehicles and power generation as soon as possible, full stop.
- maxerickson 8y agoI'm being sarcastic, not disingenuous. The "just not fast enough" happens to be an important factor.
- mwfunk 8y agoGenerally when people are down on Tesla or Elon Musk, it's because they want them to succeed at displacing internal combustion engines. They're not rooting for internal combustion engines, they're rooting for electric cars and annoyed when the company (or Musk) flounders from self-inflicted damage. At least, that seems like most of the criticism here. No one is going to respond well to an advocate of a technology they want to succeed saying and doing stuff that actively harms the cause (prime examples: George Hotz with autonomous vehicles, RMS with basically everything that RMS has ever advocated, or Julian Assange allowing Wikileaks to become a tool of corrupt governments rather than a force against them). It's great to give credit where credit is due, but even more important to hold people and companies accountable when they screw up, especially people and companies that you want to succeed.
- bduerst 8y agoExactly. Making Tesla criticism about criticizing alternative energy is a false equivocation. There are strong arguments that Tesla is being ran very poorly by Musk (solar city acq, VW cash denied, SEC fines, etc.) despite the company being one of the champions for electric vehicles.
- agumonkey 8y agoI fail to see what Tesla can do to be a more solid company, care to give hints ?
- danso 8y agoI’ve been most bothered by the exaggerated claims and projected deadlines for AP functionality and FSD. But not being able to raise money through presales, as well as banking on the premium image that leading in autonomy confers, would make Tesla even less solid of a company, at least financially. Tesla basically creating a market for EAV is very cool, and no matter what, I think Musk deserves a place in the history books for it.
- empath75 8y agoGive up on self driving cars for one thing.
- philwelch 8y agoTesla is one way to reduce carbon emissions from automobiles. It is not the only way. There is also: * Battery-electric vehicles manufactured by other companies * Plugin hybrid-electric vehicles manufactured by other companies * Reducing automobile usage in general * Developing energy-efficient processes to synthesize carbon-neutral liquid fuels using carbon-neutral energy sources * Developing new and more efficient carbon-neutral energy sources and using them to synthesize carbon-neutral liquid fuels * Developing the technology to trap or sequester carbon emissions * Some combination of the above
- kylecordes 8y agoTesla is actually working against the "reduce" in the short term. Facebook groups of Tesla owners frequently include words along the lines of: I like this car so much that I drive much more than I used to. Oops.
- mikeklaas 8y agoJevon's paradox, somewhat.
- brer 8y agohttp://brusselstimes.com/business/technology/15050/electric-vehicles-emit-more-co2-than-diesel-ones,-german-study-shows http://brusselstimes.com/business/technology/15050/electric-...
- sliken 8y agoI rarely see it broken out, but in various markets (not just the USA) Tesla is making money on selling carbon credits from other car companies that aren't meeting the carbon goals. I've seen mention of $100M CARB credits in 2014, mentions of Fiat Chrysler avoiding $billions in fines by paying Tesla for their credits. The Tesla earnings call mentioned the income, but not the broken out line item totals. So while it not be completely fair, at least Tesla is getting substantial financial contributions from the carbon producing ICE competitors.
- lowdose 8y agoWasn't the Mars exploration the ideal smoke and mirror for the actual goal of SpaceX launching Starlink?
- cjhopman 8y ago> SpaceX is killing it on profits SpaceX isn't open about their financials, but all indications are that they are losing money.
- pooya13 8y agoWhat indications?
- onlyrealcuzzo 8y agoFair. But it's hard for me to imagine a future in which Tesla grows at a better rate than SpaceX.
- newnewpdro 8y agoWhat are you smoking? The market for automobiles is basically the entire world's adult population. Space rockets not so much.
- eafkuor 8y agoYou're not entirely wrong, but entire world? I'm not sure. The _vast_ majority of people in the planet can't afford to spend even 10kUSD on a car.
- leadingthenet 8y agoAnd there's some who simply don't want to. I could afford to buy a car, but I have an amazing electric bike, and live in a city with fantastic public transport. The 5 days a year I actually NEED a car, I can just rent one. So why buy?
- newnewpdro 8y agoDo you think that's some kind of permanent condition? On a long enough timeline the world normalizes. These classifications of "first world" vs. "third world" countries can be viewed as an ordering of arrival to the modern high-energy high-tech life. Third-world countries don't stay in mud huts indefinitely. China is the fastest growing automotive market in the world, it wasn't too long ago they were riding bicycles in droves. Now we're hearing about manufacturing migrating from China to India where it's still cheap, the cycle repeats. I don't think we can say that everyone in the world will ever be in the market for SpaceX products and services. But we can definitely say that's possible about electric vehicles. They are already often owned and operated by individuals, and the common utility is incredibly obvious. All I'm hearing in your comment is that they're currently too expensive for most people. The price will decrease as the economies of scale take over, the buying power and interest across the world population will increase in spurts, it's only a matter of time. Once EV-capable batteries are as commonplace as propane tanks, this picture is going to change dramatically. Eliminating a transmission and ICE from a vehicle design substantially lowers the cost to manufacture it. There's very little precision machining left in an EV, it's basically the steering rack, and myriad ball/roller bearings, wheel hubs, brake rotors and calipers, what else? It's a big difference.
- RivieraKid 8y agoYou mean Musk selling his share and putting it into SpaceX? SpaceX laid off 10% this year and their recent attempt to raise money didn't go well.
- mdorazio 8y agoTo be fair, they tried to raise money mostly to fund BFR development, which is a questionable economic investment for people expecting a decent ROI (although it's a fantastic overall future investment for humanity as a whole). If they tried to raise money specifically for micro satellite internet, on the other hand, I think investors would be more favorable.
- Denvercoder9 8y agoMicro satellite internet isn't really viable without BFR though.
- philwelch 8y agoI used to think the same, but I’m increasingly of the opinion that he needs Tesla to distract him from unduly interfering in SpaceX.
- sliken 8y agoTesla has no strong 2nd in command to delegate things to. SpaceX does and Elon seems to trust her enough to avoid micro-managing.
- danso 8y agoI haven’t seen anything to say that SpaceX is solidly profitable. They’ve said that they’ve had several profitable quarters but no further details. Analysis of their SEC filings suggest that they are not yet profitable (though not in danger either): https://www.teslarati.com/spacex-10-percent-workforce-fired-bfr-starlink-launches/ https://www.teslarati.com/spacex-10-percent-workforce-fired-...