5 ms·
Just in general America has a severe issue with CYOAism, liability sale, liability insurance and responsibility - we need a serious reform to get rid of excuses
by munk-a 8y ago
Just in general America has a severe issue with CYOAism, liability sale, liability insurance and responsibility - we need a serious reform to get rid of excuses be it "just following my boss's orders" to "I was just responding to market pressures - I'm an innocent capitalist fulfilling what the market demands".
- seem_2211 8y agoAgreed. That's one thing I really hate as an excuse. You can't make that excuse and respect yourself.
- learc83 8y ago>I'm an innocent capitalist fulfilling what the market demands I agree. We've been using that excuse for too long. In the 50's William Levitt, the country's largest home builder and the originator of the modern suburb, said exactly that when asked why he built white only communities. "If we sell one house to a Negro family, 90 to 95 percent of our white customers will not buy into the community." "As a Jew, I have no room in my heart for racial prejudice. But the plain fact is that most whites prefer not to live in mixed communities. This attitude may be wrong morally, and someday it may change. I hope it will." In other words: I know it's wrong, but I'm just doing what my customers want.
- kazinator 8y agoWow. He did more than just use that excuse, he played the "I can't be racist because I'm a Jew" card. His reference to "white customers" doesn't even exclude Jews, to begin with. Like, in 1950's America, did Jews eagerly move into communities with large numbers of blacks, in stark contrast to "whites"?
- jrochkind1 8y agoIn 1950's America, actually, many white communities wouldn't allow Jews to buy or rent. But I agree with you that "I can't be racist because I'm a Jew" is ridiculous, and that real estate profiteering off of racism is abhorent regardless of who is doing it.
- infinite8s 8y agoAnd that's why we have regulations.
- apostacy 8y agoThe regulations are worse than the problem though. Thankfully the HUD under this administration has been trying to slow it down. In my friend's home town, the federal government has deemed it to be "too white", and is trying to build a 500 unit housing complex, and bus in people from 80 miles away to live there. And to anyone who loves talking about how enlightened they are, ask yourself if YOU would choose to live next to government housing for 500+ low income people. Of course you wouldn't.
- learc83 8y agoSo some people living next to 500 low income people is better than not allowing black people to live anywhere but slums? Because that's the problem in the scenario I mentioned. Also low income people need to live somewhere, and how exactly are they "busing" in people to live there? I'm pretty sure your story is missing some details. Can you link us to a local article on it so we can find out more for ourselves?
- apostacy 8y agoSo, you would be ok with transplanting a chunk of Detroit into your neighborhood? Unless the answer to that question is an enthusiastic yes, then you would be called a racist. Actually, forget who the people are. Would you be ok with the federal government forcibly disrupting your community and bypassing local governance, to build buildings that nobody asked for, and inviting displaced strangers into your community? And their rationale for this is punitive. They target communities that are deemed to be too homogenous.
- infinite8s 8y agoAgain, you have any citation for that? Surely a story as disruptive as you paint it has been covered somewhere.
- siruncledrew 8y ago"I know it's wrong, but that's what the money is telling me to do, and money is never wrong." It's another way of saying "All I care about is the money I get". If the price is high enough, his conscious could be bought. Sure, maybe he feels bad for hurting a group of people, and his Jewish ancestry shows he knows what that's like to be the short end of the stick. But this is the opposite of taking the high road. It's about as impactful as saying "Thoughts and prayers to those people I displaced, buuuttt... it turns out it's way more beneficial for me if I just roll with this, so.. sorrryyyy." The "You can't blame me for selling out because you would do the same thing" argument is an overrated defense.
- Chris_Chambers 8y agoYou may have heard of a rather large Jews-only suburb called Israel. I suppose you’d also like to see it diversified against their will. How not antisemitic of you.
- btrettel 8y agoI recently wrote the following in response to a different comment here on HN: > "I was just following incentives" is becoming the new Nuremberg defense. https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=19709730 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=19709730 I'm clearly not the only one who has had this thought... Blog post on this sort of issue in academia: http://www.talyarkoni.org/blog/2018/10/02/no-its-not-the-incentives-its-you/ http://www.talyarkoni.org/blog/2018/10/02/no-its-not-the-inc...
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]