4 ms·
>You will jeopardize the anonymity of family members Too late for me. I have 7 siblings and 4 half siblings. I have 10 aunts and uncles who are blood relations
by irrational 8y ago
>You will jeopardize the anonymity of family members
Too late for me. I have 7 siblings and 4 half siblings. I have 10 aunts and uncles who are blood relations (I'm not including their spouses) and about 70 first cousins. Plus my parents and grand parents. To the best of my knowledge, almost all of them have had their DNA work done by ancestry and 23andme. The family has a lot of doctors (some of whom are boarded in genetic medicine) that think everyone (not just in the family, but literally everyone) should get their DNA tested to help answer questions about family history, migrations, diseases, etc. I'm considered odd because I don't want to get mine done, though it's probably pointless since so many people that share my DNA have already done it.
- astura 8y agoYou have 70 (seventy) first cousins from only 10 aunts and uncles? That seems unusual because I have 15 blood aunts and uncles yet slightly less than 30 first cousins.
- irrational 8y agoWell, 20 aunts and uncles (I was only including the ones I share DNA with). But yeah, most had 7+ children. My paternal grandmother, who is still living, has 100+ great-grandchildren and counting (the most recent great-grandchild was born just 2 weeks ago and quite a few other grandchildren are expecting). The leading edge of the great-grandchildren are just now reaching their early 20s and one of them has a great-great-grandchild on the way.
- mafuy 8y agoI don't know your background, but in rural Vietnam (my partner's origin), that situation would not be unusual, too.
- zmmmmm 8y agoThis is unfortunately the same boat everyone is in. If any 2nd or even 3rd degree relative has their DNA information banked with any of these services then you are effectively identifiable. Police or anybody who can get a sample of your DNA left behind anywhere will be able to immediately identify your family, then rapidly rule out most of the other family members through orthogonal information and in most cases you will be the only candidate remaining. So the real question is, if you already lost your anonymity, is there anything left to lose by buying in? You might as well get the benefits if you are having your privacy destroyed anyway.
- asdff 8y agoIs it not a good thing to catch a criminal in your family? I've yet to see a compelling argument that explains all the tinfoil. Replace DNA with fingerprint and it's the same piece.
- zmmmmm 8y agoThat's sort of an extension of the "if you've nothing to hide then you've nothing to fear" type argument. One can counter with "what if you're a journalist who published leaks of damaging government information and you're trying to protect a source" or various other scenarios where keeping your identity anonymous is legitimate and legal.
- a3n 8y agoThis is similar to people who avoid Gmail for privacy reasons. Even if you don't use Gmail, your correspondents do, so Gmail has a sizable chunk of your personal data to analyze and monetize.
- asdff 8y agoIt's useful clinically, and it would be ignorant to deny it in that setting where it's secured by HIPAA. If someone in your family develops a cancer and you already have everyone sequenced, that makes it a lot easier to inform on therapy options. Having this data is also useful for future researchers on the disease (the best discoveries are made in museum drawers, not the fossil find on the hillside; you never know what you might stumble upon with a new tech or even just fresh eyes so it's important to have the data collected). What 23&me offers is kinda useless IMO. We are too much of mutts to accurately trace your history with high confidence. Why do I care if I'm 14% swedish and 8% turkish and 3% kazakh? SNPs are mostly annotated by correlation, and rarely are causative to disease, so even if you had that 'bad' allele it means nothing devoid of any context or more downstream analysis. It's a $200 curiosity more than anything. My only worry is insurance companies being deliberately obtuse about the data and jacking up premiums or denying coverage (if the Rs get their way). 'You have this allele that's in 5% of leukemia patients vs. in 3% of the healthy population, we will bill accordingly.' Doesn't mean you will ever get leukemia, but it's another potential excuse to gouge the consumer. If you are concerned about you leaving DNA around or somehow big bad government spying on your boring life, I'm assuming you've never sneezed, and have already burned off your fingerprints?