4 ms·
>"Hey, they're fixing it, quit complaining." One of, if not the biggest problem with many of those Apple fanatic is that Apple could do no wrong. And this is s
by ksec 8y ago
>"Hey, they're fixing it, quit complaining."
One of, if not the biggest problem with many of those Apple fanatic is that Apple could do no wrong. And this is speaking as someone who like Apple but increasingly irritated by their action.
- mey 8y agoThe fundamental issue with zealotry. When ever this comes up, I think of this small (200 person) study on brand identity and self identity. https://arstechnica.com/science/2011/08/users-treat-criticism-of-favorite-brands-as-threat-to-self-image/ https://arstechnica.com/science/2011/08/users-treat-criticis...
- cptskippy 8y agoI have a lot of admiration for what Apple has done but in the post Jobsian Era they're focus seems to have shifted from elevating the personal computing experience to reducing over costs and it's disappointing to say the least.
- Veen 8y agoIf they were focused on reducing costs, they’d be producing hardware of the same quality as most Windows laptops.
- cptskippy 8y agoYou can reduce costs without sacrificing quality by identifying inefficiencies within your organization and streamlining them. Tim Cook made a name for himself by optimizing the logistical side of Apple. The cost reductions Apple has done have less impact on material finish and quality of the solution, and more impact reliability, repair-ability, and maintainability. As a cost reduction technique, they rivet the keyboard to the upper chassis of the Macbook rather than the comparatively expensive process of tapping holes and using screws. This has no impact on product performance and quality, but if you happen to use an inferior keyboard then it makes repairs exceptionally difficult. As a result Apple is averse to performing repairs because what could have been an inexpensive keyboard swap now requires replacing the entire uni-body chassis which is an expensive machined part. Another example is where the Macbook display FRC is soldered directly to the panel to avoid a connector that costs a penny in volume. This reduces manufacturing costs and part counts but introduces the risk that any issues with the FRC require the entire display to be replaced. That's exactly what happened because they made the FRC a few millimeters too short. Apple said that display failures were isolated and not a manufacturing defect however this year's model features an FRC that's a few millimeters longer. These types of optimizations to the product might save a dollar or two in the BOM but they completely fail to take into consideration support requirements they introduce. Riveting a $ keyboard to a $$$$ machined aluminum chassis makes you adverse to even acknowledging an issue with the keyboard because you'll then have to replace the entire assembly. Forgoing a connector and soldering a $ FRC directly to the $$$$ display means that when the FRC fails due to stress from an engineering fault, you pretend it's an isolated issue to avoid having to replaced entire display assemblies on thousands of devices.
- Veen 8y agoI appreciate the informative response to my facetious comment. And, as someone whose MacBook Pro suffered from the FRC issue, I agree.
- sleepybrett 8y agothey aren't fixing it though, just kicking the can down the road. I have two coworkers that have had the replacement to the new model butterfly a few months back. Their keyboards are already failing again. There is a good reason I stick with my mid-2014 macbook.
- cmurf 8y agoIt's an interesting dilemma for the consumer when subsequent failure happens so soon after repair. If the product is under warranty, original or extended, I think the equivalent of automobile Lemon Law should apply: consumer is entitled to a permanent fix, manufacturer is entitled to three attempts to do so within 90 days; if it's still not working or subsequently fails, the consumer is entitled to a 100% refund. I'm not aware of that being the case in any U.S. state. How does a consumer protect whatever rights they have? 50% off an external keyboard isn't good enough but people have work to do. Why bother getting yet another "fix" when it too likely fails in a few months? I'd want to make sure that if my warranty is about to expire that I've got documentation that Apple agrees the defect exists and that I'm entitled to a better permanent fix. Consumer protection laws are important. This finders keepers nonsense makes people angry and they aren't just going to reduce their trust in Apple, their trust in the industry and society is diminished as well.
- tomwilson 8y agoIn my experience apple usually refunds you after the same issue occurs 3x on a machine. I had this happen for the keyboard on my 2016 15” mbp.
- rolleiflex 8y ago> I think the equivalent of automobile Lemon Law should apply: consumer is entitled to a permanent fix, manufacturer is entitled to three attempts to do so within 90 days; if it's still not working or subsequently fails, the consumer is entitled to a 100% refund. This is indeed the law in many European countries, at least it is in Turkey, which sources its jurisprudence largely from there. I have successfully used this in TR against a Toshiba laptop (motherboard issue) circa 2004 as barely a high-school kid, much to the chagrin of the distributor's legal team lead. In the end they paid the retail amount in full, though it took a bit of time.