3 ms·
> I don't know what quantum supremacy is https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Quantum_supremacy https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Quantum_supremacy > whether or not its
by lisper 8y ago
> I don't know what quantum supremacy is
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Quantum_supremacy https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Quantum_supremacy
> whether or not its better than quantum computing, I couldn't say
It doesn't have to be better, merely as good as would already be a major revolution in both math and physics.
> I would wager that if you did more than 3 responses to him being a bit more clear on what you thought was wrong with the theory
This was my last message to Rod:
> I think you should try to run Shor’s algorithm, because if you succeed that will be a slam-dunk proof that your claims are correct. You will win a Fields medal, a Nobel prize in Physics, and become fabulously wealthy beyond the wildest dreams of Croesus. I think it’s much more likely that the attempt will reveal some flaw in your scheme, but either way, it seems like a worthwhile endeavor. Worst case, you will learn something.
I really don't know how I could have been any clearer.
This was his response:
> Well, I don't really understand Shor's algorithm (from wikipedia). I'd have to study it. I never really have so far. But, I'm confident that my conjecture that QC reduces to the two properties I mentioned in last email is true.
In other words: he doesn't understand one of the most basic and fundamental results in quantum computing, but he's confident that he has made a discovery that will revolutionize the field. If it quacks like a quack...
- roddyrink 8y agoRon, you're hung up on Shor's algorithm. But you continue to avoid addressing my claim (above). Perhaps that's because you don't understand the fundamental difference between localist and distributed representations. In any case, your continued use of "quack" while you also continue to admit you don't understand the thing you're criticizing,...well, it's just pathetic. Anyway, let's stop. I don't really see any value in communicating with you further.
- lisper 8y ago> you don't understand the fundamental difference between localist and distributed representations That's true, I don't, and I've never said otherwise. I do, however, understand information theory, quantum computation and quantum supremacy. So I don't know if you're a quack or not. What I do know is that your claim of having achieved quantum supremacy on a classical computer is almost certainly false. I don't need to understand the details of your algorithm to know this, I only have to understand what "quantum supremacy" means and why it matters. I also know that I have looked at your site and read some of your papers and I can't make heads nor tails of them. It's possible that this is because I'm an idiot and I'm simply not capable of grasping the brilliant idea embodied in Sparsey, or that I just haven't put enough effort into it. Or it's possible that this is because it's all bullshit. I honestly don't know. But I do know one more thing, and that is that you're getting awfully defensive about all this. Why would you do that if you were confident in the merits of your position? What threat could a lazy idiot like me possibly pose in that situation?
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- CodiePetersen 8y ago"I think you should try to run Shor’s algorithm, because if you succeed that will be a slam-dunk proof that your claims are correct. You will win a Fields medal, a Nobel prize in Physics, and become fabulously wealthy beyond the wildest dreams of Croesus. I think it’s much more likely that the attempt will reveal some flaw in your scheme, but either way, it seems like a worthwhile endeavor. Worst case, you will learn something." That's a decidedly non answer from a non expert and provides no insight to the person being critiqued. That would be like if Alcubierre came to you with some ideas for his warp drive and you said, well if it can travel faster than the speed of light then you've cracked it, but I think its more likely that you will fail. All of that being said without any knowledge or attempt to run the mental exercise you purport to be fond of. It's still a theory and the math is what I said it was, its clear in the papers, its clear in the classification experiments, its clear in the raw math of it. What's also clear from your comments is that you won't and can't actually say anything about the algorithm because you don't know anything about it. From my experience, people like you who can only see things and explain things from a high level and never actually critique the problem head on, don't actually know what they are talking about, thinking Theranos level. If it weren't the case, you'd understand that a quick glance, which I already did when you mentioned it, at wikipedia isn't going to make me understand anything if I don't have the fundamentals under my belt. Which, believe me if it was possible, I'd be glued to this computer on wikipedia becoming an expert on everything as fast as I could read. I've tried to be a bit civil with this but it's clear you don't care and you'll probably never care. If it trolls like a troll...