5 ms·
Before pulling out the pitchforks, I'd encourage you to investigate with more than just one article. It may very well be everything you recommend is warranted,
by hn_throwaway_99 8y ago
Before pulling out the pitchforks, I'd encourage you to investigate with more than just one article. It may very well be everything you recommend is warranted, but be aware that once reporters decide on the narrative for a story, they pull out quotes and data in a manner that specifically supports that narrative.
I know I've been burned in the past by just reading one side of the story and getting angry before understanding the entirety of what happened.
- Razengan 8y agoThe above comment was gray, within 5 minutes of being posted. Perhaps the karma threshold for downvoting needs to be raised to balance the Redditization of HN.
- dsfyu404ed 8y agoOr just subtract one karma from the person doing the down-voting as well so people only down-vote when it's "really" worth it. Prolific down-voters would float around the down-vote karma threshold and basically be rate limited by the number of upvotes they get.
- fouc 8y agoThere's no way to detect the down voters unless they leave a comment indicating that?
- dsfyu404ed 8y agoI assume it's tracked in a DB (inb4 blockchain) somewhere so you can't downvote the same comment twice.
- _0ffh 8y agoThat rate limiting idea sounds very good in principle. Unfortunately it would make the part about karma that's already slightly broken IMO into a major breakage: You have to write scores of reasonably popular comments to collect as much good karma as a single successful submission tends to give. That's on top of commenting tending to be more work than submitting. I've spent as much as half an hour of research on some comments, just to make sure I've got the details straight.
- sctb 8y agoIt's not anywhere near gray, and 5 minutes is no amount of time to draw conclusions. > Please don't comment about the voting on comments. It never does any good, and it makes boring reading. > Please don't submit comments saying that HN is turning into Reddit. https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html
- fuck-sctb 8y agoUh huh.
- mannykannot 8y agoI have been following this case for some time in various sources, and there is essentially no way to spin this as other than a determined and long-running attempt to pervert justice. Deliberately falsely imprisoning someone is the moral equivalent of kidnapping in my book.
- mattigames 8y agoPrison is worse than kidnapping, when you are kidnapped you can grab to the hope someone (the cops?) will rescue you soon, when the state does it that hope is non-existent.
- Mirioron 8y agoYou're also allowed to defend yourself when kidnapped. No such thing when the state does it.
- chronogram 8y agoWhich should be the other way around... :-(
- tareqak 8y agoAre you saying you should not be allowed to defend yourself if you are kidnapped by an entity that is not the state?
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- hn_throwaway_99 8y agoDo you have any other sources you can post? In particular, the article mentions how the OCME claimed they had done studies on the reliability of this DNA technique, but in fact hadn't. If that turned out to be a complete, bald-faced lie, I would expect that there would be an independent investigation and, if those statements were made in an official capacity, that someone would be in legal jeopardy.
- alexandercrohde 8y agoOkay, great, but if it is found to be a cut and dry case, you agree a firing and bar from public office are the correct course of action?
- hn_throwaway_99 8y agoI think very few things are "cut and dry", but if it was indeed true that the claimed study was never done, and if the superiors knew this and lied about it, and then retaliated against this scientist for attempting to bring this fact to light, then yes, I absolutely think they should be fired. Note that "bar from public office" is not even a potential sanction in this case - the superiors are not publicly elected officials, and saying "no public government is allowed to hire you" is not a punishment that exists or is legal in the US. Depending on the level of knowledge, I'm guessing there are some criminal punishments available, but that would obviously be a very high bar in terms of determining culpability (IANAL).
- heyyyouu 8y agoIANAL, but not that high, actually, esp. if the feds want to get involved and can find a legit way. Any attorney general could be a serious problem but if the feds involved, I'd not want to be their legal rep.
- jrockway 8y agoI typically read both the NYT and the WSJ, and they very often agree on news stories. When I subscribed to the WSJ, I was expecting to be blown away at how the NYT was sticking me in some sort of liberal media bubble. But it turns out, they both pick the same topics and both relay the same facts. Even the opinion columns are the same -- "I support the position of the political party to which I am aligned, no matter what. NO MATTER WHAT."
- michaelbuckbee 8y agoWith respect to the NYT/WSJ having a similar point of view, I've heard it described as a "cosmopolitan bias". That the professional journalists are mostly college educated, live in a large city, have a sense of professional ethics, are exposed to people from a variety of backgrounds and ethnicities and all sorts of other markers of class and socio-economic background. I grew up in a tiny rural town in Ohio where that certainly isn't the case and currently live in the suburbs of Virginia where that urban lifestyle feels very far removed. This is less a political description and more of the urban/rural divide in viewpoint. Case in point: I've had multiple conversations with people locally who reacted with horror at the idea of taking a Lyft/Uber ("Don't do that you'll get killed.")
- DavidAdams 8y agoYet they will ride an ATV for fun, which actually will get them killed.
- newswriter99 8y ago"mostly college educated, live in a large city, have a sense of professional ethics, are exposed to people from a variety of backgrounds and ethnicities" You're making "cosmopolitan bias" look good, when it's not. It's still bias. Having a better education and being exposed to more cultures than the average person does not guarantee that you won't be a closed-minded, fundamentalist, holier-than-thou jerk. Source: country-raised metropolitan-educated journalist
- crushcrashcrush 8y ago
- magashna 8y agoThey stated they had proven this controversial technique worked, then it came out it was never tested. That seems pretty clear cut to me.
- stale2002 8y agoPeople always make claims like "oh, innocent until proven guilty!", "Let's just wait for the evidence!'. But apparently we are here right now, where the state was proven guilty, and they paid a million dollars to someone for their crimes, and the evidence does show that something bad happened, and yet people are still ignoring the evidence. Yeah, no. They paid a million dollars to someone. That is good enough evidence for me to condemn them.
- hn_throwaway_99 8y ago> But apparently we are here right now, where the state was proven guilty You just posted something that is completely false. The state settled a lawsuit. Large organizations settle lawsuits all the time because the cost of litigation can be huge even if the organization wins. Even your leading statement that "People always make claims like "Let's just wait for the evidence!"??? Please, we should only be so lucky.
- stale2002 8y agoA million dollars is a million dollars. In the court of public opinion, I can judge them guilty. It is impossible to hold people accountable otherwise, because they will always just settle and escape the political consequences.
- drugme 8y agoBefore pulling out the pitchforks, And yet -- Occam's Razor, and lengthy enough observation about how things operate in various city agencies in NYC prudently suggests: At the very least, do keep those pitchforks ready at your side - and freshly sharpened.