3 ms·
Is 'skateboard' another name for body-on-frame? It seems like people are saying it's a big new idea, but it's how things used to be done before uni-bodies. Are
by chrisseaton 8y ago
Is 'skateboard' another name for body-on-frame?
It seems like people are saying it's a big new idea, but it's how things used to be done before uni-bodies. Are uni-bodies not as suited to electric with their large low-slung power packs?
- dsfyu404ed 8y agoYeah, basically. But now the frame is solidly mounted to the body because in 2019 we want the chassis rigidity and can reduce NVH in other ways. People have been hard mounting the body to the frame of BoF vehicles to increase rigidity for a long time though so that's not new either. There's no hard line. It's like how at one point we had wagons, minivans and SUVs but now we have crossovers that blur the lines. Vehicle construction is the same. You can have a ladder frame and then shove a bunch of batteries in it. Is that a skateboard? What if it's a perimeter frame? What if the batteries contribute to the rigidity of the frame?
- oliveshell 8y agoIt sounds like it’s a regular truck frame, but with the gaps filled with batteries. Seems straightforward to me. Modern full-size trucks are still essentially body-on-frame.
- stetrain 8y agoI think it's the combination of integrating the battery pack into the lower frame structure of the vehicle, and also integrating all of the drivetrain components into that flat frame. In a body on frame vehicle the engine still sticks way up above the frame and has to be accounted for in the body design. Everything built on the F-150 frame looks like an F-150 (F-150, Expedition, Navigator), but something like VW's MEB platform can have a lot more vehicle shape variety (ID 3, ID Crozz, ID Buzz, etc.)
- rconti 8y ago"Skateboard" is a term that's been thrown around since the 90s to describe how EV platforms can be fully modular. I remember reading Popular Mechanics magazines back in the day, touting how EVs would let us drive our sports car to the dealer, have them remove the roadster body, and replace it with an SUV body for that long family Thanksgiving trip to Grandma's house (for example). It's a lot like body-on-frame, I suppose, but the idea is all of the powertrain is in a more-or-less flat device, and the seating area is completely disambiguated from the drivetrain.
- deftnerd 8y agoI think I remember that same article, or a similar one from around the time frame. It also suggested some radical improvements. Once a car is based on a "skateboard" design, the front window can extend a lot further down allowing for some amazing views. It didn't seem to think about the danger of removing a crumple zone, but it was definitely eye-catching.
- rconti 8y agoActually, our model 3 has an amazingly low dashboard, it's one of my favorite things about it. Side windows on modern cars, not so much. Crash standards have made our cars cocoons you can't see out of. But owning the 3 has definitely made me think a lot of the skateboard model: * Flat floor, no transmission/exhaust tunnel. * User interface (screen) is indepenent from body control modules and drivetrain. You can reboot the tablet while you're driving. Your turn signals stop making noise, but still flash! You can walk up to the car and it unlocks even if the tablet isn't working. IT's interesting ,you can really feel how discrete certain components are, how they can be rearranged and put into a different model. I'm sure there are more dependencies than I realize, though.
- organsnyder 8y agoI think your second point is true for lots of (all?) vehicles today, which have an architecture of multiple modules communicating over a CAN (car-area network) bus. I did a firmware update on my Pacifica PHEV while I was driving it, and though I lost the ability to listen to the radio and change settings on safety and convenience features (rain-sensing wipers, blind spot detection, etc.), the car still ran fine (and all of the safety features still functioned).
- DaiPlusPlus 8y agoI understand in EVs, “skateboard” refers to the chassis of the car using the battery pack itself as the base/floor of the car and then building everything in top of it. So-called because the battery pack with frame and wheels resembles a skateboard. It’s used in comparison to “conventional” EV sedans from Ford, GM, and older lead-acid/bulky battery tech where carmakers would take an existing car design (that’s meant for an ICE engine and drivetrain) and merely replace the engine with a motor and put the batteries somewhere where they would fit, usually in a tall box shape under the rear cargo area, under the rear passenger seats, and in the front engine compartment as doing so means not having to drastically reengineer the car to put the batteries in the floor - but it means there’s less space for batteries and they consume car volume that would otherwise be free for use by the passengers. I imagine if the Ford Focus Electric was skateboard then they could get 200-250 miles of range and and a fully open frunk and trunk - whereas instead you lose more than half the trunk space (no spare tire either!) and the engine compartment is still full of legacy components with no passenger storage area - for only 150 miles of range. This contributes towards the perception that the legacy automakers aren’t taking BEVs seriously enough because none of them have developed and shipped a true battery-first (I.e. skateboard) car design.
- bonestamp2 8y agoWhen the term was first used (GM Autonomy 2002) it was a concept for a complete powertrain below the hubline. Ya, it's pretty similar to body-on-frame, although it suggests much more freedom in body design since nearly all of the power train is below the hubs.