3 ms·
"Did you get '1 in 3' by attributing all iatrogenic deaths to doctor error?" Yes, because despite the fact that there is a category called medical errors, almo
by Alex3917 16y ago
"Did you get '1 in 3' by attributing all iatrogenic deaths to doctor error?"
Yes, because despite the fact that there is a category called medical errors, almost all of the other deaths listed are medical errors as well. It's not like there is really any legitimate reason for more than a trivial amount of people to get MRSA in a hospital seeing as when best practices are followed the rate of line infections goes from 4% to 0%.
"How do you figure, even assuming these figures are (still) accurate (many of them are 10-20 years old)?"
The NY Times just published an article a week ago saying the rate of medical errors hasn't gotten any better, which I linked to below.
- sparky 16y agoPatients getting infected because somebody didn't wash their hands is an abomination, we can agree on that. This thread was originally about decision-making power being shifted from doctors (M.D.s) to insurance companies, administrators, regulators, laywers, and even patients themselves. Your first comment suggested that this is a good thing because those same M.D.s kill 1/3 of all Americans (and as a corollary, the other parties involved plus the other healthcare providers that outnumber M.D.s many-to-one kill nobody). I think it's pretty suspect that the linked page cherry-picks its numbers, rather than trying to assemble them all from a single source which has taken some care not to double-count. Granted, such a source may not exist, but essentially the death toll for each cause X is taken from a paper which is trying to make a big deal out of X. The fact that those numbers sound fishy is orthogonal to the fact that I don't think they would be any better if the power to make treatment decisions is taken from those best equipped to make it. And all of that is orthogonal to the fact that the linked page does not even attempt to show this, so it doesn't really seem to support the point you were making with that citation.