3 ms·
> a novel form of DNA testing being used in criminal cases I feel like any "novel form of" really shouldn't be evidence until it's proven. Granted I also reco
by duxup 8y ago
> a novel form of DNA testing being used in criminal cases
I feel like any "novel form of" really shouldn't be evidence until it's proven.
Granted I also recognize how courts really struggle understanding the magical world of what science is proven and what isn't.
I do worry that it's up to each defendant to effectively fight these fights that are big topics and would be crazy expensive to "disprove" something the government says is proven, but isn't.
- sametmax 8y ago> Granted I also recognize how courts really struggle understanding the magical world of what science is proven and what isn't. I don't understand how. Aren't you suppose to study logic to be a a judge ? Surely laws and argumentation are a central topic, and they all require a brain. How somebody unable to understand simple concept like probabilities can be judge ?
- testvox 8y agoJudges in many parts of the United States are elected, so there is no particular guarantee they have studied anything.
- sametmax 8y agoOh, wow. That explains a lot of things I couldn't understand from news I read.
- cm2012 8y agoOnes that aren't elected are appointed. Typically they're appointed because they're related or friends with the elected officials doing the appointing (My dad is a court officer in NY state - he's seen over and over again that nepotism is absolutely the norm and not the exception for all appointed positions). Any merit judges have compared to a baseline lawyer is basically accidental.
- duxup 8y agoI feel like citing that it's just nepotism is not entirely accurate. Judges are lawyers, but the approval process and performance of judges who are willing to follow the rule of law and rule in ways that aren't simply in line with "nepotism" is significant. Even existing supreme court justices appointed have not taken actions that the folks who appointed / approved them might wish... that's a good thing.
- JackFr 8y ago> Typically they're appointed because they're related or friends with the elected officials doing the appointing I don't think that's completely accurate. It's very much party politics at the local level. Party hacks are rewarded. (Which may look like friends and family, but party discipline is highly enforced AFAIK)
- JudgeWapner 8y agoyou still need to have at least a JD from an ABA-accredited school and admission to the state bar. There are some corner cases where this isn't true, but they're for misdemeanors and defendants have the right to have a Real Judge review their case.
- driverdan 8y agoThis varies between municipalities. Many don't have any requirements.
- duxup 8y agoLogic isn't the hard part, it's knowing what to weigh and how. I think like diving into an actual scientific paper, it's actually quite hard to take issue with various things and understand them if you're not familiar with the science itself. I feel like I can logic out some stuff reasonably well as say some doctor studying DNA (speaking very generally) but as far as DNA goes i'm straight ignorant as to what to weight and conclude.... the doctor presumably better, but I'd have no clue if he was wrong.
- HeWhoLurksLate 8y ago> I don't understand how. Aren't you suppose to study logic to be a a judge ? Surely laws and argumentation are a central topic, and they all require a brain. How somebody unable to understand simple concept like probabilities can be judge ? Some of this gets solved via the use of expert witnesses- people who weren't at the scene of the crime that have expertise in a related topic, and their job is, basically, to explain some part of what happened, or how something works, under oath- for instance, a computer forensics expert, who investigated the computer of a hacker, can, during testimony, explain how something works and why that's important. Because experts are under oath, and assumed to have a knowledge of the field they're representing, the judges (and jury, too) generally place trust in them. In this case, the defendant scientist was concerned because of a lack of data: Ms. Stajic, 69, said she felt vindicated. “As a forensic scientist, I am fully aware of the importance of validating each study,” she said in an interview. “My concern was if that study was not done, there could be wrongful convictions. And if the wrong people were convicted, that would mean the wrong person would be walking free.” This is especially important considering the following lines: Low Copy Number testing involves very minute amounts of DNA — often lifted from crime scene surfaces, such as weapon handles or bicycle handlebars, that multiple people have touched. The city first adopted this technique in 2006, and it is estimated to have been used in thousands of cases before it was phased out in January 2017. New York was the only crime lab in the country believed to have used the method. This sounds a little fishy to me- like a computer forensics expert testifying in court that the only reason to use Tor is for bad-guy activities, shortcutting the process of finding what else they might need it for- for instance, I personally use Tor in a VM for looking at the occasional site that I just don't trust. In conclusion- yes, logic is an important part of being a judge, and a part that you more or less have to have in order to get very far. Judges also trust expert witnesses to fill them in on what they don't know (such as how this exact model of car works, or what a particular weapon's spray is like, or if shells from bullets match the defendant's gun) and generally trust them. The problem in the article is that the NYC's science department was more or less in bed with its prosecutors, which is not fair, and that the science department was using less data than it ought to to produce often-damning evidence. It's not really the fault of the judge for not understanding that the shortcuts that the science department were using weren't good, especially when they're under oath, which is a HUGE psychological part of law. Also, if it helps, here's a good overview of how a court case works, in the form of a movie scene critique (legitimately the best primer on how a court with a jury generally functions, or at least ought to): https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=a1I7QBCHqng https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=a1I7QBCHqng
- jcranmer 8y ago> How somebody unable to understand simple concept like probabilities can be judge? How many smart people struggle with the Monty Hall problem? It's a fairly simple probability problem, overall, but it is very much unintuitive (mostly a matter of the difficulty of setting up the problem in the first place). Most people aren't very strong in mathematics, and even most scientists struggle to apply statistics correctly (see the commentary around the fMRI of a dead fish for an example). It's not surprising that judges and juries are going to have these same struggles.
- lenticular 8y agoA huge amount of "forensic science" is complete bunk. Scientific validity doesn't matter, you just have to be able to sell it to a jury.
- duxup 8y agoSadly that is where judges should be stepping in but the barn doors were left open so who gets to be the first to say "you can't use fingerprints that 'match' because your noob deputy thinks they kinda look alike..."?
- c3534l 8y agoIn my experience at least with lawyers (don't know any judges), I wouldn't trust them with that sort of thing any more than anyone else. They're hyper concerned with convincing arguments, to the point where they often fail to make the distinction between something that is actually true and something that seems like it should be true. They know plenty about law and the sort of reasoning that makes the interpretation of law consistent. But it doesn't seem like they're in a position to understand scientific evidence better than your average joe. Like, programmers and folks on hacker news are great at computers and sometimes math and engineering. But I'm not sure I want hacker news giving me dating advice or gardening advice. That's not really in their wheelhouse. Unless you had specialty judges who only did something like determine the validity of certain kinds of evidence who didn't have to have the same skill set as other judges, I don't see it as being much of an improvement.