4 ms·
No; this a band-aid, not a solution. A solution is changing laws and allowing or encouraging development to happen and allow all kinds of development, from mix
by mc32 8y ago
No; this a band-aid, not a solution. A solution is changing laws and allowing or encouraging development to happen and allow all kinds of development, from mixed use, luxury, middle class and subsidized, not necessarily in the same place. Allow gentrification to happen, but also build housing for the poor.
- lighthazard 8y agoSo allow for everything but also have rules for everything?
- Zenbit_UX 8y agoNo? No you're against a good idea that helps because it doesn't outright solve the problem? Band-Aid or not, it's solid and well thought through. Don't be so quick to dismiss something because it doesn't solve all the world's problem immediately.
- mc32 8y agoLook, what’s going to happen? Garages prove to be a safety valve, it’ll become a new normal that allows this “can” of housing issues to get kicked down the road. I don’t see how this helps. It’s not all that different from saying allow six to a room or something. Sure, it increases “density” but it’s not a solution. One of their examples is garages in the mission (SF). Those things are low ceiling, dingy, etc. Students might be okay. Not grown adults. Like I said, it’d become a new normal, an accepted solution. But it’s not a solution. It just postpones things and makes sub-par acceptable.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- Zenbit_UX 8y agoTackling a solution from multiple angles isn't a con. If I had the choice of a garage in SF or a 2h commute to my barrista job for a something more in my price range it would be a no brainer. You're dismissing a good idea because it doesn't help you personally... I expert more from HN commenters than "no because this doesn't benefit me or conform to my world view".
- tiew9Vii 8y agoNot the US or SF. Been to a few converted garages in Sydney AU advertised as “Duplex’s” or “Granny flats”. Small, dingy, cheaply done so the owner can earn as much money as possible renting it out. Garages are designed mainly as a storage room or just big enough to squeeze an average sized car in, newer builds you would struggle fitting a car in. Fitting a bathroom, bed, kitchen in? Not a nice place to live.
- nautilus12 8y agoAgreed, we need to solve the issue of houses sitting empty due to money laundering and foreign investment. Why try to encourage people to convert their garages when they are hundreds of thousands of living units sitting completely empty for people's portfolios?
- srcmap 8y ago10% "vacancy" tax / year can solve this problem and drive property speculations out of the housing market.
- twiceaday 8y ago1978 California Proposition 13: Section 1. (a) The maximum amount of any ad valorem tax (a tax whose amount is based on the value of a property) on real property shall not exceed one percent (1%) of the full cash value of such property.
- whenchamenia 8y agoThen there is the law to change. Simple.