3 ms·
Can we stop making this comparison? At best it is naive at worst you're purposefully misrepresenting the argument. When people say "social credit score" they d
by godelski 8y ago
Can we stop making this comparison? At best it is naive at worst you're purposefully misrepresenting the argument.
When people say "social credit score" they distinctly mean something different than "credit score" (you may get this hint by the extra word, "social").
A social credit system not only includes your finances, but as well as much about your behavior. Such as "do you buy cigarettes? How often?" FICO doesn't care about this, they just care about if you're likely to pay back debt (based on your track record of doing exactly that). FICO doesn't care if you're Muslim, black, white, Christian, etc. But a social credit system DOES.
Rather than putting a score on your likelihood of paying back debt, a social credit score scores you on how "good of a citizen" you are. Not just legally, but morally. And that's the danger. Morals shift and vary a lot (more so in the US than most countries). There's a general belief in most first world countries that your skin color, religion, gender, etc should not play a role in how the government of businesses treat you. Social credit systems (even if they don't explicitly add those factors: ie implicit) will use these factors to rate you.
- edmundsauto 8y agoDo you not see any parallels between the two? FICO scores are borderline discriminatory because it turns out that social behaviors and group membership is correlated with those scores. FICO doesn't "care" if you're Muslim or black, but FICO scores can be absolutely used to discriminate against those groups.
- godelski 8y agoThis is a fair argument. But there were other factors in my argument. That social credit scores are used to determine more than "can you pay back your credit?" It isn't hard to argue that FICO can be abused. But what's being argued here is that we don't need, nor want, a system that is more imposing than FICO. One that affects much more of your life, such as "can I use an airplane?"
- mdorazio 8y agoFICO can be and is used to discriminate in job applications. You also seem to be missing the point that debt financing is a huge part of the ability to live a standard American life, much more so than in a country like China. For example, if you can't buy a car, there are many places in America where you simply won't be able to get around. This social-financial reliance system makes credit scores in America a lot closer to a social credit system than you seem to think. If a score prevents you from using transportation (a needed car), living in decent housing, and getting a decent job, I'd say that score is pretty tightly tied to your social well-being.
- godelski 8y agoYou realize I'm trying to distinguish a "social credit system" from a "credit system", right? I will agree that there's problems with a credit system. No argument there. But I'm (we're?) arguing that these problems are exacerbated when adding the social element.
- novok 8y agoI think in the past, credit reporting agencies did want to make things equivalent to social credit, or make social credit type things apply to your financial credit score, but were stopped by legislation.
- xster 8y agoThe US justice scores like COMPAS absolutely cares about your skin color and your sentencing depends on it. It just doesn't have a sexy Chyna-BAAAD label next to it to attract your eyeball. https://epic.org/algorithmic-transparency/crim-justice/ https://epic.org/algorithmic-transparency/crim-justice/
- godelski 8y agoCOMPAS is only used for those already suspected of/have committed crimes. A social credit system affects ALL citizens. Yes, there's controversy with COMPAS and I think you'll find that those that don't want social credit systems likely don't like COMPAS. But bringing up COMPAS is off topic. Especially when you compare it to China. Let's reiterate and make this easy: Does <government program> dictate if you and use an airplane? Does it also dictate if you can get a loan? If you answer yes to (exclusively) BOTH of these questions, then the program might be a social credit system. If you answered no to one or more, then the program is likely not a social credit system. Note: The China system answers yes to both of those questions. FICO fails on the airplane question. COMPAS fails on both.
- resters 8y agoMaybe the average social credit score in the US is higher than the average in China. Being added to the no fly list could be the result of an equivalently low score under both regimes.
- godelski 8y agoPlease do not take this conversation off topic. It is against the rules. We are distinguishing "social credit scores" from "credit scores". If you would like to argue why they are in fact the same, then that is on topic. But if you are going to assert that they are different and continue off on a tangent then you are going off topic. I'm giving you the benefit of the doubt that you are not trolling, but there's plenty of evidence to suggest that you are.
- 8y ago