2 ms·
You are technically correct ("the best kind of correct"). The DMCA has noticeably muddied the waters. Copyright shouldn't legally work that way [in that select
by WorldMaker 8y ago
You are technically correct ("the best kind of correct").
The DMCA has noticeably muddied the waters. Copyright shouldn't legally work that way [in that selective enforcement weakens further enforcement], but among other parts of the DMCA over-reach, it's the increasing gray area confusion between trademark law and copyright law that the DMCA seems particularly to exacerbate. That's partly because providers (such as YouTube) often handle DMCA takedowns as all or nothing, and technically do not allow selective takedowns or make exceptions hard to handle.
That's also partly because the courts seem to have allowed corporations themselves to confuse and comingle copyright and trademark laws. Recent arguments that Disney has not bothered to extend the copyright term again because they think they've bulwarked Mickey Mouse trademarks enough at this point to continue to control the properties when they expire from copyright, and that idea seems to stem from this increasingly muddy water.
The laws seem clear that the water shouldn't be this muddy and trademark is not some magically stronger copyright (and copyright is not just some subtly weaker trademark) in an ouroboros of self-correlation fed by DMCA logic and corporate rent seeking. It may take some serious casework in the next few decades to fix such problems, however.