3 ms·
Copyright enforcement "wisdom" is that if they don't stop this they lose some of their power at stopping the next copyright infringement. It does circle back t
by WorldMaker 8y ago
Copyright enforcement "wisdom" is that if they don't stop this they lose some of their power at stopping the next copyright infringement.
It does circle back though that Copyright was (constitutionally, in the US) meant to only be a temporary reprieve from the public domain/public access with the express purpose to make it likelier to entre the public domain/public access afterwards, but at this point we've pushed "temporary" beyond the span of a human lifetime for the benefits of inhuman entities (corporations).
Why should 30+ year old things remain in copyright? Corporations collect nice rents on even 30 year old properties. I'm sure Nintendo appreciates how many people need to (re-)buy Super Mario Brothers every couple of years on a new console's "Virtual Console" store every few years to play it legally. Recent game Super Mario Maker even provides a legal way to remix Super Mario content in Nintendo-approved ways. But what is our culture missing out on that public domain won't see access to Super Mario until sometime nearing the end of this century (under current laws, who knows if someone might fight to expand them again), and subsequently outside the lifetimes of many of the folks that played Super Mario Brothers around its original release? Would people even remember Super Mario Brothers? Would what is left to turn back over to the public domain be archived well enough to even be useful to the public domain at that point?
- tinus_hn 8y agoTrademarks work that way. Copyrights do not.
- iforgotpassword 8y agoAnd even then, that's more or less just so you can claim unused trademarks. Just because you decidede not to act on one such infringement doesn't immediately revoke your trademark, especially if there is no financial gain for the infringing party.
- WorldMaker 8y agoYou are technically correct ("the best kind of correct"). The DMCA has noticeably muddied the waters. Copyright shouldn't legally work that way [in that selective enforcement weakens further enforcement], but among other parts of the DMCA over-reach, it's the increasing gray area confusion between trademark law and copyright law that the DMCA seems particularly to exacerbate. That's partly because providers (such as YouTube) often handle DMCA takedowns as all or nothing, and technically do not allow selective takedowns or make exceptions hard to handle. That's also partly because the courts seem to have allowed corporations themselves to confuse and comingle copyright and trademark laws. Recent arguments that Disney has not bothered to extend the copyright term again because they think they've bulwarked Mickey Mouse trademarks enough at this point to continue to control the properties when they expire from copyright, and that idea seems to stem from this increasingly muddy water. The laws seem clear that the water shouldn't be this muddy and trademark is not some magically stronger copyright (and copyright is not just some subtly weaker trademark) in an ouroboros of self-correlation fed by DMCA logic and corporate rent seeking. It may take some serious casework in the next few decades to fix such problems, however.
- jammygit 8y agoJust to play devils advocate: Hollywood and the games industry pump out a lot of shovelware. If there are millions or billions in profits available for making worthwhile IP of lasting value, they might fund riskier, more worthwhile 'art' projects (taking video games to be an art form in this context). It encourages thinking longer time horizons than 'opening weekend' or 'initial Xmas sales', even if just to have an opportunity to make a series of sequels. That said, 100 years is a bit crazy. Nobody actually plans on that scale, and nobody's bonus depends on projected sales 87 years from today. I think 20-40 years would be equally effective in practice.
- 0815test 8y ago> If there are millions or billions in profits available for making worthwhile IP of lasting value There aren't - not through increased copyright length, anyway. The value of proprietary IP decays very quickly over time, until the vast majority of works entirely falls hostage to transaction costs of all kinds (see the whole issue with "orphan works", which may or may not be copyrighted but no one knows for sure, and thus no one can effectively make use of them) and their value is entirely destroyed as long as copyright protection persists. The Mario Bros game is actually a very rare exception, and even then its value is really only as a representation of Nintendo's best known franchise, i.e. nobody really cares about the game itself, and there are comparable-quality games that are totally free these days.
- aasasd 8y agoWaiting for Marvel and EA to fund riskier projects.
- WorldMaker 8y agoThat is the point of copyright, yes, that a limited monopoly on an intellectual property provides benefits to the creator to tackle other risks. It's definitely the question of how limited that monopoly is that is at hand. Scale is exactly the question. The current copyright terms are outside of human scale in that they extend past a human lifecycle (explicitly in the case of single, clear authored works as the current copyright is author life plus it's number of years). The original US copyright allowed for 7 years with one possible extension for an additional 7 (for a total of 14 years). That's relatively a lot more human of a scale. (That scale still covers the current 10 year scale of the Marvel Cinematic Universe to date, for example. That's 3 MCU planning "Phases" of 3-5 year planning horizons. Imagine if it were only roughly four more years before, say, Iron Man 1 might expire from copyright.) It doesn't seem likely that we will see copyright terms reduced back down to human scale, but it's a shame.