4 ms·
I'm very much on his side. (1) Inherited dynastic wealth creates a plutocracy. I believe people of each generation should rise to the level of their abilities
by arcticbull 8y ago
I'm very much on his side.
(1) Inherited dynastic wealth creates a plutocracy. I believe people of each generation should rise to the level of their abilities and not to the level of largesse of their families. Allowing people to hand down massive wealth is like playing monopoly where every square already has a hotel on it.
(2) The children didn't earn it, so they deserve it as much as anyone else. Inheriting it may adversely affect who they turn into as humans.
(3) I believe in a large social safety net so that those who cannot succeed don't have to die, but rather can live out their lives comfortably. Basic income, socialized medicine, education, etc.
This strikes a fair balance IMO. You earned the money, you created the value, you have to spend it in your lifetime. If you can't, the state will decide where it goes. The next generation will be looked after, and if they too are successful they can also enjoy the spoils. If not, they can live out their lives in comfort.
- Dig1t 8y agoI think this doesn't quite jive with human nature. People have a naturally strong drive to build something and give to their kids. If there's no legitimate way to do that, then people will find other ways (whether illegal or just less honest means) to pass the things they've built to their children.
- arcticbull 8y agoLots of things don’t jive with human nature, like not murdering/stealing/etc, and yet we create systems to change that in ourselves rather than surrendering to our base instincts. If it's better that way, then we can always use a similar approach. All I'm saying is that 'human nature' isn't always good, and I'd rather keep it out of the decisioning process.
- gnat 8y agoSounds like you'd really enjoy reading Francis Fukuyama's "The Origins of Political Order" <https://www.amazon.com/dp/B00457X7VI/> https://www.amazon.com/dp/B00457X7VI/>. He analyses how different cultures came to wrangle large states, showing how they all had to deal with the same issues although they dealt with them in different ways. The base issue is that the state has to replace the family as the strongest allegiance: a person holding office can't use that office to enrich their family, else eventually the state has nothing and warlord dynastic families result. So you get Janissaries (kidnapped Christian boys) as the elite fighting force in the Ottoman Empire, and the 11C (?) change in the Church that prevented priests from marrying (because they'd been enriching their families). Since I read the book, I can see that fundamental tension between state and family playing out everywhere. Highly recommended!
- NTDF9 8y ago>> I think this doesn't quite jive with human nature. People have a naturally strong drive to build something and give to their kids. Sure. Give something. But let a huge percentage of it be returned back to the society you got it from in the first place.
- hnaccy 8y ago>If you can't, the state will decide where it goes. Presumably to the state I suppose.
- stanfordkid 8y agoI disagree with this viewpoint. At the end of the day wealth needs to be distributed to people in proportion with their ability to allocate it effectively towards the growth in the knowledge and capabilities of a society. In other words -- we want smart people that want to improve society to have lots of money. Dynastic wealth needs to be paired with a code of ethics and training ... nothing inherently wrong with it.
- baragiola 8y agoThis type of policy is proven to be regressive because: 1) The really wealthy find loop holes. 2) It discourages saving and investment. 3) It encourages consumption and spending on frivolities. Imagine if everybody would have to start from the ground up, we would rarely see any progress at all. I like Bill Gates' approach, he gave his children some fortune and allegedly will donate the rest of it
- chmod775 8y ago> The really wealthy find loop holes. Even the kid of this Tycoon ended up becoming the CEO of his father's company. What a coincidence! He won't inherit wealth, but he already did inherit the means to become wealthy himself. Probably is by now. > It discourages saving and investment. It won't do so significantly for your average Joe. Rich people not hoarding their money can also arguably be good for the economy. Though I'm undecided on that issue.
- lucideer 8y ago> 1) The really wealthy find loop holes. The really wealthy will always find loopholes in any system: that's not an excuse to do away with all societal structure or rule of law. No system can be perfect, but the idea is to strive to close such loopholes (even if this may be somewhat of an arms race—many things in life are) > 2) It discourages saving and investment. It discourages saving, but not investment (and only the latter has intrinsic societal benefit). One could argue it might skew investments more toward short term return, but I doubt this. > 3) It encourages consumption and spending on frivolities. Spending is generally framed as societal good and the definition of a "frivolity" is highly subjective. However, if we do run with the subjective, I would argue that the biggest driver of frivolous spending is having a lot of (/too much) disposable income, which often stems from inheritance. It's also often argued that inheriting does little to teach the "value" of money and as such encourages frivolity (though tbh I don't know how much I believe this). > Imagine if everybody would have to start from the ground up, we would rarely see any progress at all. Wow. Are you seriously proposing that only those who inherit riches can improve the world??? Or, worse yet, only those should have that opportunity??? > This type of policy is proven to be regressive Define "proven" here. Where/when has this policy been implemented? What were the environmental factors?
- winter_blue 8y ago> (2) The children didn't earn it, so they deserve it as much as anyone else. Inheriting it may adversely affect who they turn into as humans. This goes against the idea that I should have the freedom to do whatever I want with my post-tax money. What if I decided I want to give my money to a bunch of random strangers on the street? Would you insist "they deserve it as much as anyone else"? It's an essential matter of freedom. Where do you draw the line? Would you say I can't donate too much to X charity, and must donate equally to all registered 501(c)(3) orgs? What about me just going out and buying stuff? What if a super-rich person decided screw my kids, and chose to splurge everything they earned on incredibly-expensive vacations, cruises, food, hotels, etc. Are you going to attempt to use the force/violence of the state to prevent them from giving their money to whomever they want to give it to? Reductio ad absurdum. The ultimate consequence of carrying your line of thought would be the appropriation of all income and wealth, a.k.a. communism -- which we know doesn't work very weell. > (3) I believe in a large social safety net so that those who cannot succeed don't have to die, but rather can live out their lives comfortably. Basic income, socialized medicine, education, etc. Ignoring the fact that every European country that does this has an absurd and shocking tax-as-a-percentage-of-GDP (it's nearly 50% in France) -- your "large social safety net" is only going to work in very wealthy countries (with high per-capita income). This wouldn't work in most middle/low-income countries, where annual incomes 30 to 40 times to lower than very-high-income countries. And my point being -- I think we should aspire to develop universal political principles -- not ones that break in certain economies, while barely-working (with extremely high taxes) in others. > (1) ... Allowing people to hand down massive wealth I don't really know what the solution is to this. I'd have to reflect more. What I can say it's unfair to completely take away something that someone truly worked to build/earn. Perhaps we could frame things to say that there is a moral limit to how much someone can "fairly"/"ethically" earn in their life, and anything above that limit, is society's to plunder. I don't know. I haven't found an idea that I find comfortable or confident supporting.
- yladiz 8y ago> absurd and shocking tax-as-a-percentage-of-GDP Define absurd and shocking. Is it shocking to an American with a seemingly lower tax rate or to a European who has to pay these taxes every month?
- tomsun 8y agoI like the spirit of the ideas, but yeah I gotta say it's a little extreme to me. Forcing people to spend money in their life time is going to incentivize consumerism. So I was super rich, and you want me to be forced to spend rather than invest and pass down to the next generation, I'm either going to try to pass it down illegally, or spend on things like sports cars and yachts and watches and fine wines and michelin star restaurants. None of them is as valuable as keeping it invested. On top of that, I'd divest all my holdings (which, if I didn't diversify well, means asset value in general will drop whenever someone super rich dies, which also opens up the opportunity for speculation, but that's beside the point). This also doesn't take in the account of sudden death. What if you suddenly died at 45, with a $1.5 million estate? So you never had the opportunity to enjoy it. This will incentivize people to be a lot more near-sighted and again reinforces consumerism. You mentioned having it being taxed at 90%. I'd say that's probably good, but I'd go a step to the right and say 90% on anything that's over $2mil, since your argument is contingent on a very very strong social safety net, which I do not think the United States has, and I would say it's also debatable on how strong you want the social safety net to be. Just my two cents.