3 ms·
I appreciate the analysis of the cocaine detection, and the torts, but the question was about the evidential legality of touching your rear tail light. That wa
by SilasX 8y ago
I appreciate the analysis of the cocaine detection, and the torts, but the question was about the evidential legality of touching your rear tail light. That was not necessary to conduct the stop and (by supposition) there is insufficient evidence for a search (beyond what he can ordinarily see), etc.
Are you saying that e.g. the cop's fingerprint on the tail light could not be used as evidence, because it was an illegal trespass?
- tptacek 8y agoI'm trying to follow this discussion (because it is interesting) and I am a little lost about this fingerprint thing. What does leaving a fingerprint on a taillight accomplish for the officer?
- SilasX 8y agoFrom the link: >Before cameras were installed on the dashboards of most police cars, tapping the taillight was an inconspicuous way for officers to leave behind evidence of the encounter, according to The Law Dictionary. If something were to happen to the officer during the traffic stop, their interaction with the driver could be traced back to the fingerprints left on the vehicle. This would help other police officers track down a missing member of the force even without video proof of a crime.
- tptacek 8y agoAh, now I understand. Yeah, that's an interesting question.
- rayiner 8y agoAh, okay, I get it now. In that case, I think the cop’s fingerprint could be used as evidence if the cop went missing. Say the cop opened your bag and dug through it without a warrant. That’s clearly a 4th amendment violation. That would result in exclusion of evidence obtained from the search of the bag. But if the cop went missing, fingerprints from the bag would be admissible as evidence of the fact that he had searched the bag and interacted with you. Whether the later search is legal would depend on the specifics of that search.