3 ms·
Yes, that's the argument. The challenge was to reconcile that with e.g. the practice of leaving a fingerprint on the tail light when a search would have been i
by SilasX 8y ago
Yes, that's the argument. The challenge was to reconcile that with e.g. the practice of leaving a fingerprint on the tail light when a search would have been illegal.
Edit: toned down.
- rayiner 8y agoI'm responding to this point: > Is there actual case law about someone being prosecuted for the trespass of putting chalk at the bottom of someone's tire? How about sneezing? > What about leaving a fingerprint on someone's car ... which ordinary people do all the time? The Court relies on the part of the Restatement that says a trespass has occurred when you intentionally touch someone else's chattel property. That doesn't answer your point, which is why I referred you to Section 218, which explains that a trespass, though it has occurred, is not actionable standing alone absent damages or dispossession. So even though touching someone's car is technically a trespass, it's not an actionable trespass so you wouldn't see lawsuits involving mere touching. (As to your point about police leaving fingerprints--I've never heard of the practice. But my assessment would be that even though it's trespass, it's not actionable (no damages), and it's not a Fourth Amendment violation because it's not actually part of the search, but merely incidental to it.)
- SilasX 8y ago>As to your point about police leaving fingerprints--I've never heard of the practice Hence the link in the comment I referred to: http://mentalfloss.com/article/502605/reason-police-officers-tap-your-taillight-when-they-pull-you-over http://mentalfloss.com/article/502605/reason-police-officers... >But my assessment would be that even though it's trespass, it's not actionable (no damages), and it's not a Fourth Amendment violation because it's not actually part of the search, but merely incidental to it But it's done when the officer isn't allowed to (otherwise) search -- before he's had any contact with the driver or even looked inside the car.
- rayiner 8y agoYou have to think of the causal chain that leads to recovery of evidence. Marking your tire with chalk is part of the causal chain--if the police didn't do it, they wouldn't know you had broken the law. Touching your car during a stop is not part of any causal chain--it's a separate tort that happens to be non-actionable because there is no damages. Say a police officer stops you for running a red light. At that point, he has no suspicion that would justify a search. I tries to tap on your door to get you to roll down your window, and his ring scratches your car. That is a trespass to chattels, and it's actionable because it has resulted in damage to your car. After you roll down the window, he sees someone snorting cocaine in the back seat. He then searches your car, and recovers tens of kgs of drugs. Was there an illegal search? No. Even though scratching your car was a trespass, and even though you can still sue for the cost of fixing the scratch, that trespass had nothing to do with recovering the evidence of drug crimes.
- SilasX 8y agoI appreciate the analysis of the cocaine detection, and the torts, but the question was about the evidential legality of touching your rear tail light. That was not necessary to conduct the stop and (by supposition) there is insufficient evidence for a search (beyond what he can ordinarily see), etc. Are you saying that e.g. the cop's fingerprint on the tail light could not be used as evidence, because it was an illegal trespass?
- tptacek 8y agoI'm trying to follow this discussion (because it is interesting) and I am a little lost about this fingerprint thing. What does leaving a fingerprint on a taillight accomplish for the officer?
- SilasX 8y agoFrom the link: >Before cameras were installed on the dashboards of most police cars, tapping the taillight was an inconspicuous way for officers to leave behind evidence of the encounter, according to The Law Dictionary. If something were to happen to the officer during the traffic stop, their interaction with the driver could be traced back to the fingerprints left on the vehicle. This would help other police officers track down a missing member of the force even without video proof of a crime.