4 ms·
Is there some kind of decorative value to random hexadecimal strings that I’m not aware of?
by pavlov 8y ago
Is there some kind of decorative value to random hexadecimal strings that I’m not aware of?
- mcbits 8y agoNo, the nature of the value that people see in them is not identical to flowers.
- pavlov 8y agoWhat other (legal) use is there for Bitcoin than speculation? The original Bitcoin whitepaper calls it an “electronic cash system”, but it’s obviously a total failure at that.
- Karunamon 8y ago...I mean, you can exchange it for goods and services, so “failure” is rather premature.
- Nursie 8y agoNot easily, and almost all situations where you can do so involve one or more intermediaries. It's 10 years in, I think we can call it a failure now.
- Karunamon 8y agoYes, easily. And the existence of an intermediary isn't a disqualifier. You're still sending USD when you send someone USD over Paypal, you're still sending Bitcoin when you send someone Bitcoin over Coinbase. Bitcoin is responsible for moving hundreds of millions of dollars every single day[1]. That is not a reasonable definition of "failure". Similarly, your gran using it is not a singular definition of success. [1]: https://data.bitcoinity.org/markets/price_volume/30d/USD?t=lb&vu=curr https://data.bitcoinity.org/markets/price_volume/30d/USD?t=l...
- pavlov 8y agoPenny stocks have market volume too. The only difference is that penny stocks don’t pretend their trading volume is an indicator of some inherent utility because of a whitepaper ten years ago.
- Karunamon 8y agoCurrencies are not equivalent to securities in their definitions of success or nearly any other way I can conceive of. We just had a legal fight about this definition.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- draugadrotten 8y agoFunny but not clever. As any lottery or casino can show you, there's a lot of value in the right random numbers, it all depends on what you use them for. If bitcoin has value it is only because the randomness is one of the methods used to make the bitcoin useful. Some usefulness appears to be there as is demonstrated by the real life usage of the bitcoin.
- belorn 8y agoThe point is that even a small 1-2% of all transactions would still be a huge amount. The question that we should ask is if bitcoin serves to a market need. From what I have seen, yes it does, though banks did react back when bitcoin started to gain traction and for example here in Sweden a free service to send and receive money instantaneously through a mobile app became extremely popular. Now the banks are trying to introduce fees into that service, and time will tell if the market will tolerate it, or if it will slowly fall in popularity until another free alternative (like bitcoin) replaces it.
- Nursie 8y ago> The point is that even a small 1-2% of all transactions would still be a huge amount. The real point is that there's no reason to think that this is achievable.
- eli 8y agoThis is in fact a trap so common it has a name: The 1% Fallacy. https://successfulsoftware.net/2013/03/11/the-1-percent-fallacy/ https://successfulsoftware.net/2013/03/11/the-1-percent-fall...
- notahacker 8y agoDid banks introduce money sending services via mobile apps in the last decade because a handful of people acquired a speculative digital asset that isn't actually capable of free, instant transactions, or because the average person acquired a smartphone?
- belorn 8y agoWhat does "handful of people acquired a speculative digital asset" have to do with the market need of "send and receive money digitally"? There reason people want to send and receive money digitally has many sources. The cashless society change that Swedish governments and bank started a while back created a need for digital alternatives for activities that previously used physical cash. Transactions between individuals, flea markets, collections at church services, fees for clubs, sale of drinks/food at events. Credit cards are costly, includes minimum fees and use systems that tend to be slow and hard to use. A church collection does not work if a 1$ donation cost 1$ in credit card fees. Even donation services today like patreon currently looks down at such low donations as all the money get eaten by the credit card fees. The benefits that people who advocated for Bitcoin in the early days talked about was mostly those. Ease of use. Cheap. Physical cash alternative. It was a time where paypall was the only alternative to credit cards and for many places the only way to pay unless you used direct bank transfer that take a minimum of 1 weekday transaction time. Smartphone penetration is a relevant factor, but it was not the only one. The new bank service fulfilled a need which credit cards and paypall both did a poor job with. The question is if banks/government are willing to continue support what the market needs, or if systems like bitcoin will utilize the hole that remains when physical money is phased out.