4 ms·
What do you mean by clogging up the legal system? It doesn't matter how much he asks for really. This should be a valid case and it should cost Apple enough to
by viraptor 8y ago
What do you mean by clogging up the legal system? It doesn't matter how much he asks for really. This should be a valid case and it should cost Apple enough to hurt them.
We can't tell what the arrest was worth to the teenager. Depending on timing and results on his life, that could be anything between mild inconvenience and 1bn.
- saagarjha 8y ago> This should be a valid case Agree. > it should cost Apple enough to hurt them Don’t. I think it should cost them proportional to the amount of “suffering”: this is a lawsuit after all, not a criminal trial. > We can't tell what the arrest was worth to the teenager. Depending on timing and results on his life, that could be anything between mild inconvenience and 1bn. Agree as well, but I hope you can forgive me for leaning towards “mild inconvenience” rather than “one billion dollars”.
- NickNameNick 8y agoThere are two seperate parts to a financial judgement. Reparations - which are paid to the victim to make them whole and Punitive damages - which are paid to the court to discourage the behaviour of the defendant. Both parts need to be considered.
- saagarjha 8y agoAs far as I understand, the quoted figure was meant to be reparations.
- danaris 8y ago> This should be a valid case Why? All Apple did was provide the police with the information they had, in good faith: that is, the information on the ID the thief had. It's not Apple's fault the ID was stolen and the information was false. It's also not Apple's fault that the police didn't do basic due diligence to determine if it was physically possible for this guy to have committed the crimes before arresting him. What, exactly, is Apple to blame for here that "this should be a valid case and it should cost Apple enough to hurt them"?
- sigzero 8y agoThe answer is nothing. Apple did exactly what they should have done. The police failed to follow up properly.
- logfromblammo 8y agoThe police follow different procedures based on who is making the report. If you are an individual, and someone steals your iPhone, then you use the locator feature to pinpoint the exact address where it is, look up the name of the person living there, have a plausible story for why that person had opportunity to steal it, dig up the serial number from your records, and hand all that info over to the police, they will give you a report that you can give to your insurance company, caution you against approaching the thief yourself, and do literally nothing else. You did all the investigative work. All they'd have to do is show up with a search warrant. Aaaand nothing happens. If you are Apple, and someone steals your iPhone, then you use facial recognition tech to link the thief to the name and address of a stolen identity, then the cops will raid that address and arrest the person, without even bothering to investigate, or even validate Apple's info, first. Perhaps they call a VIP number rather than 911 or the public number for the main automated phone tree, that bypasses all the layers of "we're busy with important work, so piss off"? This is the same problem as SWATting attacks. Police procedure is hackable, by saying the right words to the right people, to turn it into a guided weapon against a target, who is occasionally killed by a cop made too twitchy by the "everyone wants to kill you" training. Apple provided false information to the police. This resulted in an arrest, which is potentially traumatic and violent. They could have given just the video footage of the thefts. But instead, they became part of a system that hacks police procedure to launch attacks against innocents. Someone was arrested on the basis of the output of a facial recognition program, without any consideration to the fact that it had been hacked, using the very simple and very easy attack of linking the face to someone else's name.
- danaris 8y agoWhy would giving the the video footage, and not the ID information they had on file, have been better? Consider it from the perspective of not having the information that the ID was false. Why would you give the police less than all the information you had? Why would you want the police to have to do all the work to figure out who that face on the video is, when you have their ID? Furthermore, even if you knew the ID was false (or even suspect), giving the ID information to the police, along with your assessment of its validity, would still be better. They would have an extra data point to use to try and trace the real thief. And, again, the facial recognition program did not perform the identification of the thief. It merely linked his presence in multiple stores at the times of theft. The identification information came solely from the stolen ID the thief gave when he purchased something legitimately in one of the stores.