4 ms·
>does it even make sense to trust a for-profit corporation with the world's supply of JS? No. Javascript, despite its flaws, was already one of the freest, eas
by krapp 8y ago
>does it even make sense to trust a for-profit corporation with the world's supply of JS?
No. Javascript, despite its flaws, was already one of the freest, easily accessible and deployable programming languages in existence. It flourished throughout the web without any gatekeepers or centralized authority, and it never needed the ecosystem of overwrought complexity and BS that it has.
Not only does it not make sense for NPM to have de facto control over that language through a single, proprietary registry and a single package manager, it further makes no sense that in the intervening years, with all of the issues NPM has had, no serious attempt at competition or re-decentralization of the JS community has even been attempted.
Unfortunately, I feel like the baby has long ago been thrown out with the bathwater, and NPM's ubiquity and network effect has made it "too big to fail," despite failing constantly. Maybe we can just start over once NPM has finally burned to the ground and taken the web with it.
- mattmanser 8y agoI feel this is proved false by history, if npm wasn't needed because everything was fine, it wouldn't have flourished.
- krapp 8y agoYou seem to assume that all successful projects succeed on their own merit in a fair market, but that's not always the case. NPM's success is due in large part to enterprise investment and hype. Part of the reason for enterprise investment is controlling costs by not having to train or recruit developers for another language besides Javascript, which was already commonplace. And even if NPM did solve a needed problem, better solutions cannot be considered due to those entrenched business interests and the extreme centralization of the javascript community, not because NPM is already the best possible solution to whatever problems it claims to solve. JQuery was revolutionary in its own time, but you didn't see a JQuery Foundation serving all JQuery plugins from a closed repository through a buggy package manager that everyone was expected to use. It is possible to innovate and not monopolize, but what NPM has done, at best, is monopolize innovation and stop it dead in its tracks.
- nacs 8y agoIt flourished because it is installed by default and thus became the defacto standard. There is a talk from Nodejs' creator where he mentions one of his biggest regrets about Node is that he made NPM the default.