4 ms·
Calling this suit a publicity stunt trivializes it and makes it sounds like there's no value beyond getting some publicity. I don't think that's true. This is u
by onion2k 8y ago
Calling this suit a publicity stunt trivializes it and makes it sounds like there's no value beyond getting some publicity. I don't think that's true. This is using the legal system for privacy activism in a positive way. Making corporations understand that there's potentially a very real cost to acting on false positives could be a good thing that actually moves the needle on our right to privacy.
Just imagine if stores knew a false accusation based on nothing more than facial recognition could cost them millions. They'd have to put in more effort than "The computer said you're a criminal". That would be great.
- ezoe 8y agoTrue. The apple's false accusation resulted wrong arrest. Apple is responsible for it.
- zimpenfish 8y ago> The apple's false accusation resulted wrong arrest. But it was only false in hindsight - someone came in, used his ID, and their face was associated with it - that's perfectly sensible and normal behaviour from their systems. > The arrest warrant included a photo that didn’t resemble Bah That part is definitely on the police, not Apple.
- logfromblammo 8y agoIt is not perfectly sensible and normal behavior to demand ID from customers and then set up a secret tracking profile, based on facial recognition and linked to that ID, that is apparently linked across all the stores for your company. The buried lede is that everyone who has ever walked into any Apple store is being tracked by Apple in all Apple stores, and possibly also anywhere else in public. The false arrest allowed that info to leak to the public.
- zimpenfish 8y ago> everyone who has ever walked into any Apple store is being tracked by Apple in all Apple stores That hasn't been confirmed yet, has it? I might have missed some extra info but the original story only mentioned they were tracking that ID because of the thefts. > based on facial recognition Has that been confirmed yet? I may also have missed that but again the original articles only had that as a claim from the man suing them, nothing concrete (and I believe Apple also denied it?)
- logfromblammo 8y agoApple can keep all the surveillance footage from all their stores. Apple can run FaceID on any image they have. In this instance, Apple must have run FaceID from images from the recordings that show the thefts. It is not necessary that they did this on-site or in real time. A statement by Apple claims that they do not run facial recognition software in their stores. But the wording was very specific; they did not deny uploading the in-store video to an offsite server to detect faces and identify them. They certainly did it for one person. They could do it for more, limited only by their computing power. And they are a computing hardware company.
- zimpenfish 8y ago> In this instance, Apple must have run FaceID from images from the recordings that show the thefts. But again - we have zero proof of that. > They certainly did it for one person. They might well have done but nothing in the reporting of this story has any kind of evidence that this happened!
- ezoe 8y agoIf you read the article. The real thief use his stolen ID which doesn't have face photo. The police claimed Apple use face recognition to identify the thief. So what Apple face-recognize it for? Or Police is lying.
- lotsofpulp 8y agoApple is not tasked with arresting people, the police are the ones with the power and the police should be the ones liable for not doing proper due diligence (if they didn’t).
- saagarjha 8y agoThis only makes sense if he can prove that he was “damaged” to the tune of millions of dollars, which I think we agree he likely wasn’t. I’m all for privacy and restrictions on the use of blanket facial recognition but trying to scare companies with out-of-proportion fines seems like it’s do more harm than good.
- mirimir 8y agoGetting arrested has a nonzero risk of death. What Apple did was insane, and they ought to be punished.
- saagarjha 8y ago…this is a reductio ad absurdum. You have no idea what happened during this arrest.
- mirimir 8y agoOK, sure. But consider how reckless Apple was. Reportedly they had some store video showing thefts by someone with a particular facial feature hash. And I'm guessing that they also linked that hash to a non-photo ID. Which are easily counterfeited. So say they had stopped there, and called the police when someone with that hash walked into a store. That would be bad enough, given how unreliable facial recognition is. But they went further. They had this kid arrested, relying on doubly unreliable information. That's what's reckless, and why they should be punished. If for no other reason, to set a precedent. So in a way, the actual risk that the kid faced is irrelevant. What matters is what might have happened.
- lotsofpulp 8y agoYou can’t “have” someone arrested. The police chose to arrest someone, and it is their duty to determine if the information given to them constitutes a reason to arrest someone. Unless it was given to them in with the intent to arrest someone under false pretenses, I don’t see how anyone other than police are responsible.