4 ms·
> rhetoric in general is significantly less effective if you spend all your time carving out exceptions for differing opinions HN is aimed at an engineering au
by otterley 8y ago
> rhetoric in general is significantly less effective if you spend all your time carving out exceptions for differing opinions
HN is aimed at an engineering audience, not a political one. I, and others like me (at least used to) come here for enlightenment, not rhetoric.
Moreover, the article itself is not argumentative. It didn’t need to be spiced up with a provocative title to be valuable.
- da_chicken 8y agoRhetoric is not just writing persuasively. Rhetoric is about communicating effectively. Saying you don't need rhetoric because you're an engineer is like saying you don't care if people think you're telling the truth because you're an engineer. It's absurd. It doesn't matter if you're writing an opinion piece, a political piece, or a technical piece, if you want to structure your writing in a way that can be easily read, understood, and followed, you want to obey the principles of rhetoric.
- otterley 8y agoI'd like you to subject your theory to the most popular (i.e., most frequently cited) engineering writings in the past 30 years. How do they exemplify such rhetoric? And how does the reader benefit from whatever rhetoric you find in them?
- erichocean 8y agoGoto consider harmful
- otterley 8y agoOK, that one is pretty good. :)
- kekebo 8y agoDeliberately withholding details from a title to create more engagement based on a false impression of the content doesn't equal good rhetoric. If anything it hinges on clickbait. Calling it effective communication is the absurdity here.
- caprese 8y ago> It didn’t need to be spiced up with a provocative title to be valuable. Yes it did. HN title-fu is the same appeal to emotion as any political blog and is just as effective at surfacing stories, thanks to people just like you. You came to this thread and made your noise for pedantic reasons and helped surface it higher so the correct audience could actually see it
- jacobolus 8y ago> HN is aimed at an engineering audience i.e. strict pedants with no comprehension of/tolerance for ambiguity or emotion?