4 ms·
> The human eye has FAR better dynamic range than any camera built to date, at any price point. Not at all true. All you need to do is take your camera into a
by ajross 8y ago
> The human eye has FAR better dynamic range than any camera built to date, at any price point.
Not at all true. All you need to do is take your camera into a dark room for proof. It can take useful pictures in environments you can't see. And with some manual control and safety precautions (seriously, don't actually do this) you'll note you can shoot useful photos of things that are very near bright sources like the sun where your eyes would be completely useless (and irrevocably damaged, again do not try this).
What you're complaining about isn't dynamic range, it's exposure control. A human brain, again, makes much better decisions about what parts of the environment are "important" when setting the aperture (iris). So the stuff you want to see is visible, where the camera is mostly just going to guess that the center of the frame is what you want and will routinely leave stuff over or underexposed.
Your last paragraph has the correct analysis but the wrong conclusion. It's the vision processing that makes the difference. The optical systems of a semiconductor camera absolutely are better, so a control system based on optics can absolutely be better.
- naikrovek 8y agoDynamic range is the ability to see things in both direct sunlight AND in dark shadows at the same time. You need to be able to see pedestrians that are both directly lit by the sun and in the darkest shadows in the same frame of video. No long exposures, no multiple exposures with varying exposure -- a single frame. I don't know of any 24-32-bit per channel sensors, and that's what you'd need. We agree on vision processing. I thought I made it clear that it's a strong "backend" to vision (the brain or compute behind it) that makes it work so well, and that will be the case with good self-driving cars as well. I must have misstated something.
- ajross 8y agoYou're fooling yourself if you think your eyes can do that. They can't. More to the point, your brain is fooling you, by synthesizing a perception of a reality, the same way it does to make you think the stuff in your peripheral vision is as sharp as the things in the middle. Vertebrate eyes don't have 24 bits of sensitivity, that's just insane. Rod cells are neurons, they either fire or they don't, can fire at most at about 10 Hz, and you have about a million of them at most across your whole field of vision. Do the math. What you say isn't even physically possible.
- naikrovek 8y agoYou're correct that the brain fills in a lot that isn't there, making you think your vision is a lot better than it is. It doesn't change much, though, mostly it fills in gaps. 10Hz? Simply not true. Fighter pilots can identify aircraft shown on a screen for 1/250th of one second. Regular schmoes can see the difference between 30Hz and 60Hz video easily. I am not arguing about pixel count of a camera vs the center of vision of human eyes. I'm saying that... Nevermind. I've already said it several times and apparently you have a PhD in all things vision.
- Robotbeat 8y agoBeing able to recognize aircraft on a screen for 1/250th of a second just means the human eye/brain has persistence, not actual useful 250Hz bandwidth.
- pedrocr 8y ago> I don't know of any 24-32-bit per channel sensors, and that's what you'd need. Dynamic range doesn't require bit depth. You can have an 8 bit sensor with 20 stops of dynamic range. You'll lose color/luminance resolution of course but as long as 255 is capturing a light that's 2^20 times stronger than 0 that's 20 stops of dynamic range. But more than that theoretical point there are already sensors pushing well beyond what humans can do in terms of dynamic range. Apparently humans have a respectable 10 stops and sensors are already in the 15 to 20 stop range and pushing beyond it: https://www.eoshd.com/2014/11/new-sony-sensor-21-stops-dynamic-range-5120-native-iso-destined-high-speed-cinema-camera-smartphone/ https://www.eoshd.com/2014/11/new-sony-sensor-21-stops-dynam... To map it into 16bit values you can just use a curve to distribute the bit depth unevenly across the dynamic range. Older DSLRs did that to get perfectly usable images with just 10 bits per channel.
- pedrocr 8y agoYou're swapping dynamic range and exposure control. Your examples of dark rooms and bright light sources are examples of great exposure control, not dynamic range. Dynamic range is the difference in light intensity from pure black to pure white in your sensor. Modern sensors are also extremely good at dynamic range though, much better than film and apparently much better than our eyes as well. From a quick search our eyes are at 10 stops of range (2^10 ratio from white to black) and modern sensors have gone past 15 stops and are pushing on 20 apparently, which is just amazing.