4 ms·
NPM Inc. last raised a Series A round in April 2015. Now, 4 years later, they still have no business model, no revenue and no more funding. Even in their very l
by paxys 8y ago
NPM Inc. last raised a Series A round in April 2015. Now, 4 years later, they still have no business model, no revenue and no more funding. Even in their very limited space there are competitors that perform better (Yarn).
At this point it's clear that a union isn't going to save NPM. The company is really in no position to guarantee anyone anything.
- VonGuard 8y agoI was shocked to see CJ was terminated. When I heard that, I knew NPM was over. She's brilliant, and the idea of them throwing her overboard is a sure indication that they're doomed. It's like the Angels firing Mike Trout, the Warriors laying off Steph Curry, or someone firing Tiger Woods. It's a total sign of NPM giving up.
- the_duke 8y agoIt's noteworthy though that they were able to operate for 4 years with a small 8 million series A round. Since NPM is so essential to the Javascript ecosystem, it's interesting to consider a hypothetical bankruptcy. I'm sure someone big would buy them, or they could pivot to a non profit with a crowd funding/donation based model.
- paxys 8y agoThe ideal scenario would be NPM existing as a foundation rather than a for-profit company. The more likely one is them folding and Facebook taking over as the source of truth for JS packages, which is bad for everyone.
- the_duke 8y agoAgreed. Any kind of fork/split led by a company like Facebook would be highly controversial and come with lot's of drama. This would inevitably spark a non-profit community driven alternative and cause chaos. All outcomes would be very damaging to the JS ecosystem though. (also, I don't see FB having any interest in running the Javascript package registry. Yarn and it's proxy are really just a result of limitations and slowness of the official implementations)
- hnzix 8y agoIt would be darkly hilarious if NPM gets bought out by a state actor, although Facebook would be nearly as bad.
- TeMPOraL 8y agoDoubly hilarious if that state actor wasn't the US or one of its close allies.
- larkeith 8y agoAs evv brought up [1], it's rather concerning that the cornerstone of the JS ecosystem is a for-profit organization (especially one lacking in a source of aforementioned profit). I wonder if their bankruptcy might not be the worst thing for the community, in the long term - it would certainly discourage relying on a single fallible repository in the future. [1] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=19725139 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=19725139
- the_duke 8y agoThe only alternatives to a single source of truth repository are A) multiple large, competing repositories B) a distributed system like Go which relies on just a path to the source repository Both of those suck. A) is messy and confusing, B) has a whole host of problems (no immutability, no reliability and assurance that the code will be here tomorrow, mandatory vendoring, ....). Sure, a community driven non profit foundation in charge would be ideal, but a single source of truth, even if for profit, is much better than the alternatives.
- 13rac1 8y agoI strongly prefer Go's "option B" over node_modules. Your concerns (immutability, reliability, and general code existence) are handled by vendoring. Vendoring has the added benefit of enabling project builds without additional HTTP dependencies; entirely avoiding the "left-pad" problem class. I wish my NPM projects were so easy.
- _jal 8y agoThere are other models. CPAN, for instance, has worked incredibly well for its audience for 25 years and counting. https://www.cpan.org https://www.cpan.org
- the_duke 8y agoBut, unless I'm missing something, CPAN is a centralized registry, just like npm?
- pryce 8y agoWe already know that maintainers of widely-used NPM packages are being approached and offered money by people with dubious intentions. I may not agree with many of NPM's decisions, but NPM does fall over and a malicious party takes it over its functions, web development is looking at a security catastrophe. If the financial incentive for malicious actors is already represents an issue today in that there are attempts to gain control of numerous packages, imagine what the combined financial incentive would be to take over the whole index.
- chongli 8y agoweb development is looking at a security catastrophe Which in the long run should highlight the dangers of centralization with a single point of failure. We need to move back toward a decentralized web!
- acct1771 8y agoCouldn't hear you over my gig of Google Fonts downloading, one more time?
- larkeith 8y agoA union might not save NPM, but mistreating their employees is a surefire way to guarantee failure.
- gridlockd 8y agoThat's something you want to believe, but it's not true. Lots of companies that have abusive practices are trucking along just fine. Selectively firing people may actually improve morale for the obedient types. Think about it, you follow all the written and unwritten rules, you always step back, you don't cause dissent - what do you get in return? Well, you don't get fired. But if nobody ever gets fired for these reasons, you're going to feel like a sucker. In the US there's still this myth of the "disruptive innovator" who naturally breaks all the rules and yet redeems himself as a worker unit, despite all the issues they're causing. In Japan or Korea by contrast, none of this would fly. Obedience is a must. There's no space for disruption. Would you deny the success of Korean or Japanese businesses?
- TeMPOraL 8y ago> That's something you want to believe, but it's not true. Lots of companies that have abusive practices are trucking along just fine. Indeed. And it's much worse outside our industry. Hearing stories from friends and family who work regular jobs (i.e. not specialized, well-paid, in high demand) is what makes me convinced unions are a must.
- javagram 8y agoI thought their business model was supposed to be private repository hosting. That said, with the existence of Verdaccio allowing companies to run private repositories within the firewall and at no cost beyond infrastructure, who is paying for private npm?
- krainboltgreene 8y agoTwo things: It's npm Inc and yarn isn't a competitor to npm Inc. It's at best an alternative to the npm cli client.