5 ms·
> In other words: C++ is the new Fortran. Which makes Rust the new... APL? I think the analogy is pretty apt as far as it goes. Fortran by the 70's was a cru
by ajross 8y ago
> In other words: C++ is the new Fortran.
Which makes Rust the new... APL?
I think the analogy is pretty apt as far as it goes. Fortran by the 70's was a crufty language with a bunch of legacy mistakes that remained very popular and very useful and would continue to see active use for decades to come.
And everyone knew that. And everyone had their own idea about the great new language that was "clearly" going to replace Fortran. And pretty much everyone was wrong. The language that did (C) was one no one saw coming and frankly one that didn't even try to fix a lot of the stuff that everyone was sure was broken.
For myself, I despair that Rust has already jumped the proverbial shark. It's complexity is just too severe, the only people who really love Rust are the people writing Rust libraries and toolchains, and not the workaday hackers who are needed to turn it into a truly successful platform.
- arcticbull 8y agoIt’s definitely easier to reason about than C++ because it errs on the side of safety and explicitness. You can use things you don’t understand without fear which straddles the boundary in a good way IMO. To your point that doesn’t make it simple. As a work-a-day hacker it’s completely become my go to language when I’m writing tools, libraries or just want to knock out a simple algorithm to prove myself right or wrong.
- ajross 8y ago> It’s definitely easier to reason about than C++ See... I don't think that's true, and argue the huge body of C++ code and talent in the ecosystem is an existence proof to the contrary. I mean, sure, C++ has its crazy edge cases and its odd notions. But you don't need to understand the vagaries of undefined behavior, or the RVO, or move semantics to write and deploy perfectly sensible code. Literally hundreds of thousands of people are doing this every day. Now, that may not be a convincing argument about the value of that code. But it's absolutely an argument about the utility of the language in aggregate. I'll be frank: probably 40% of professional C++ programmers aren't going to be able to pick up Rust and be productive in it, at all. And at the end of the day a language for The Elite isn't really going to mean much. We've had plenty of those. Rust is the new APL, like I said.
- estebank 8y agoI'm curious, what has given you the impression that Rust is a language "for the elite"? It certainly has some rough edges around learnability, but I don't think anyone is actively trying to discourage people from picking it up. Rust is certainly hard for experienced programmers because some common patterns in other languages are not allowed by Rust's rules, but that's no different than trying to apply OOP in a functional language.
- Inityx 8y ago> the huge body of C++ code and talent in the ecosystem is an existence proof to the contrary Looks to me more like proof that C++ has been around a long time
- ncmncm 8y agoLots of languages have been around a long time without attracting billions of lines of code. To get that, the language must be unusually useful.
- dragonwriter 8y agoThat's a powerful endorsement of COBOL, but a lot of language success is “when did it become common”, “who was sponsoring it or what libraries did it come bundled with”, and path dependence that makes momentarily (due to transient conditions) sensible choices into standards that are mandatory for decades.
- int_19h 8y agoI don't think anybody is denying that C++ was (and is) unusually useful, simply by virtue of being the only serious game in town when you need that whole "don't pay for what you don't use" thing, and general performance stemming from that. And devising a better replacement that retains that feature is hard, which is why C++ had so much time to entrench. But it doesn't mean that we can't do it better these days.
- arcticbull 8y agoI'm not really arguing about the value of that code either, just that it's probably wrong, probably trivially breakable due to the sheer mountain of complexity underlying it. The compiler just happened to let it through because it can't help you. The language doesn't give it enough information to do so effectively. Just off the top of my head, std::move doesn't... move [1]. It just returns an, I kid you not "static_cast<typename remove_reference<T>::type&&>(t)" without doing... anything. You can keep on using the old value probably, silently, until out of the blue, it stops working one day. Then you're super, duper sad. Even modern language features are, I don't want to say lies, but "hopes and dreams" the compiler can't enforce. It's like if you really wished C++ had Rust's features, but you can't without breaking things, so you give it your best shot, which ends up just creating yet more complexity. Rust's answer is... let x = Value::new(); let y = x; let z = x; (COMPILER ERROR: X GOT MOVED INTO Y) C++'s modern features are to Rust's equivalents what the ruined fresco [2] was to the original. If you stand far enough back, it's basically right. If you get up close it's hilariously and trivially broken. It takes a lot of gymnastics to call this language approachable or understandable. It's basically a coal powered car made of foot-guns. That doesn't mean it's not a car, or that it won't get you where you're trying to go, I'm just saying it's an open question how many pieces you'll arrive in. [1] http://yacoder.guru/blog/2015/03/14/cpp-curiosities-std-move-that-doesnt-move/ http://yacoder.guru/blog/2015/03/14/cpp-curiosities-std-move... [2] https://www.npr.org/sections/thetwo-way/2012/09/20/161466361/woman-who-ruined-fresco-of-jesus-now-wants-to-be-paid https://www.npr.org/sections/thetwo-way/2012/09/20/161466361...
- nunjee 8y agohappy workaday Rust hacker here. Coming from higher level languages, the semantics make much more sense to me, after a quite harsh learning curve and some un-learning. Non lexical lifetimes is a game changer for rust learnability I think, and I more and more fail to see usecases where I can't just use it.