2 ms·
I don't think he's claiming that the study is outright fraudulent, but rather that the data in it cannot be summarized simply as "male and female brains cannot
by int_19h 8y ago
I don't think he's claiming that the study is outright fraudulent, but rather that the data in it cannot be summarized simply as "male and female brains cannot be easily distinguished" without using faulty methodology to analyse it. The accuracy of the data itself is not disputed, so the study is still valuable for that reason alone.
Indeed, one of the other studies that he cites in support of his claims used that same data to deconstruct the model. And it really does seem to be as blatantly fudged as he claims:
"Via simulations, we systematically varied sample characteristics such as the magnitude of sex differences and correlations among variables. Some of the simulated scenarios were intentionally unrealistic, involving uniformly strong sexual dimorphism and/or extremely high correlations between variables (up to r = 0.90). Despite this, the proportion of “internally consistent” profiles remained low in all conditions. ... To further reinforce this point, we applied Joel et al.’s methods to facial morphology features in three species of monkeys (crab-eating macaques, grivets, and tufted capuchins). Our goal was to see what percent of individual monkeys would display internally consistent species-typical profiles of features. Across comparisons, only 1.1–5.1% of the monkeys showed consistent “species-typical” profiles ..."
https://www.pnas.org/content/113/14/E1965.full https://www.pnas.org/content/113/14/E1965.full