6 ms·
The solution is the same as every other time this comes up. Upzone the city. They tried this at the state level with SB827. That bill was flawed but the idea
by jedberg 8y ago
The solution is the same as every other time this comes up. Upzone the city. They tried this at the state level with SB827. That bill was flawed but the idea was good.
The city could fix this for itself if they could get the political will to do so. Follow the lead of Minneapolis, and make R1 zoning good for up to four units, instead of single family. That one change alone would make a huge difference.
People are afraid whole city blocks would be converted, but that wouldn't happen. Single family homes with good transit would slowly be sold to developers who would replace them with quads, bringing in increased taxes so that transit could be expanded, leading to more SFHs near transit, and so on.
It's just that the people who have SFHs don't want to ruin the "character" of their neighborhood.
- davidw 8y agoBingo. The people working on this include, but are not limited to: * https://yimbyaction.org/ https://yimbyaction.org/ * https://cayimby.org/ https://cayimby.org/ * https://sd11.senate.ca.gov/ https://sd11.senate.ca.gov/ * https://sd09.senate.ca.gov/ https://sd09.senate.ca.gov/ They need all the help they can get against monied NIMBY interests.
- njepa 8y agoIt seems extremely unlikely that affordable housing will ever happen in the Bay Area, since that would essentially mean a crash of the housing market (maybe even by government intervention). This would of course be extremely unwelcome. As such any acceptable solution would have to be ineffective. And an ineffective solution have little chances of counteracting the inertia of current developments.
- jedberg 8y agoProperty values don't usually go down when you increase density. Look at NYC or Tokyo or Paris. If anything it usually makes the land value go up, especially if a developer knows they can buy it and put four units in it's place.
- nostrademons 8y agoKnowing a few NIMBYs among older generations, I suspect that the real objection to densification isn't actually property values, it's character of the neighborhood. Having the single-family home you raised your children in torn down for a luxury highrise feels like a tragedy whether you get $1M or $3M for it. That's why so many senior citizens don't sell at any price - they'll take out reverse mortgages and fritter away their retirement savings so that they can stay in the home that is familiar to them, even if they could just sell it for a few million and retire someplace cheaper with a higher quality of life.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- koboll 8y agoOn one hand, you have sentimental value. On the other hand, you have a crushing housing crisis that is causing incalculable financial strain on millions of people. I wonder which of these we should consider more important.
- akozak 8y agoI suspect most housing advocates would agree that the end goal isn't more affordable land - it's getting more affordable units on the market.
- bhupy 8y ago> Tokyo Do you have a source on that? Tokyo is famously known for having largely flat housing prices over the last 20 years[1]. In fact, in Japan, most houses are considered depreciating assets [2]. [1] https://marginalrevolution.com/marginalrevolution/2016/08/laissez-faire-in-tokyo.html https://marginalrevolution.com/marginalrevolution/2016/08/la... [2] http://freakonomics.com/podcast/why-are-japanese-homes-disposable-a-new-freakonomics-radio-podcast-3/ http://freakonomics.com/podcast/why-are-japanese-homes-dispo...
- jedberg 8y agoExactly, it's flat. The property values didn't fall.
- geebee 8y agoHard to say. SFH owners typically own the dirt beneath their house. A lot with the right to build a 3-story block of 3/2 flats might be worth considerably more than a lot with a single 3/2 SFH.
- abeppu 8y agoWould a crash of the housing market be unwelcome? The people that lose in such a crash are property developers, landlords, and home-owners that planned to sell and buy in another region. The people that benefit in such a crash include people who currently can't afford to live here, renters that currently can't afford to buy here, renters who currently have too many roommates, renters who can't afford to leave their rent-controlled unit, people who could buy a larger or nicer place, businesses where people spend the portion of their income which no longer goes to housing, businesses that can hire into the region more easily, and everyone who enjoys a community with a more diverse range of residents. You take it as a given that a crash associated with actually affordable housing would be unwelcome. I think it should only be unwelcome to those who see the housing supply as an investment vehicle, rather than as housing. To those who just want to live here, or live here more comfortably, a crash might be very welcome indeed.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- JamesLeonis 8y ago> The solution is the same as every other time this comes up. And this [1] study says it doesn't work. > Freemark reaches two startling conclusions that should at least temper our enthusiasm about the potential of zoning reform to solve the housing crisis—conclusions that, interestingly enough, he has said he did not set out to find. > First, he finds no effect from zoning changes on housing supply—that is, on the construction of newly permitted units over five years. (As he acknowledges, the process of adding supply is arduous and may take longer than five years to register.) Caveats and all, this is an important finding that is very much at odds with the conventional wisdom. > Second, instead of falling prices, as the conventional wisdom predicts, the study finds the opposite. Housing prices rose on the parcels and in projects that were upzoned, notably those where building sizes increased. [1] https://www.citylab.com/life/2019/01/zoning-reform-house-costs-urban-development-gentrification/581677/ https://www.citylab.com/life/2019/01/zoning-reform-house-cos...
- crowdpleaser 8y agoWe would expect parcel prices to increase with upzoing - land becomes more valuable if more people are permitted to enjoy using it. That's the behavior that encourages developers to make multi-family housing.
- mars4rp 8y agoand make current land owner (house owner) extremely rich, I don't understand why they are fighting it.
- njepa 8y agoBecause of volatility. You don't need a "shot at getting rich" when you already are. You much rather avoid getting poor(er).
- burfog 8y agoNot everybody wants to get rich. Some people, especially the old, just want to stay in a familiar place. If you change that place, it is no longer familiar. Older people often struggle with change. People with memory problems can often get by for much longer if nothing much changes. If you make changes all around them, they might need to go into a nursing home and then struggle every day in the unfamiliar situation.
- ed312 8y agoWhy is this fundamentally considered bad? If the majority of residents in a given area want to keep the zoning as-is, why do you (or I) have any right to force them to change? I personally don't mind living in multi-story apartment buildings but I don't get the widespread notion that a city of mostly SFH = morally bad. And frankly, if increasing density actually helped property values wouldn't you expect a place like NYC to be more affordable?
- jedberg 8y agoIt's as morally wrong as eating meat or paying minimum wage or running your water while you brush your teeth. ie. it's not really all that bad in the grand scheme of things, but it's something that we know causes harm, generally to a vulnerable population, so we should want to do something about it.
- orangecat 8y agoI don't get the widespread notion that a city of mostly SFH = morally bad Forget morality. A city with a large demand for housing that refuses to allow higher density is inevitably going to end up only being affordable to the very wealthy, with others forced to move, or out on the streets, or clinging to rent-controlled units with hostile landlords. If that's what you want, then by all means continue the current policies. And frankly, if increasing density actually helped property values wouldn't you expect a place like NYC to be more affordable? Manhattan holds a lot more people than SF, and there are reasonable cheaper options such as Queens and New Jersey.
- woah 8y agoWhat's weird is when people bemoan poor people getting forced out when it's happening due to the low-density policies they voted for.
- pcwalton 8y ago> If the majority of residents in a given area want to keep the zoning as-is, why do you (or I) have any right to force them to change? Because: (a) the "why should you be able to tell people what to do?" argument really runs the other way, as zoning is a way of telling property owners what they can and cannot do with their property; (b) rising home values cause renters to be forced out of their homes unnecessarily; (c) banning new housing in one city causes gentrification in other nearby cities (which is why for example East Palo Alto and Stockton came out in support of SB 50). > And frankly, if increasing density actually helped property values wouldn't you expect a place like NYC to be more affordable? Fortunately we have economists to study these things instead of drawing conclusions from single data points, and the economic consensus is that supply and demand does in fact apply to housing.
- chrisseaton 8y ago> Single family homes with good transit would slowly be sold to developers who would replace them with quads, bringing in increased taxes so that transit could be expanded, leading to more SFHs near transit, and so on. There's water around two-quarters of the city that means it is not possible to keep developing the extra layers of suburbia that you are describing. I mean, it should be obvious that increasing the density of a city forever, cramming more and more people in, and developing more and more, is not sustainable however you try to do it.
- function_seven 8y agoHe's talking about transit being expanded, not housing footprint. More tax revenue means more money available to fund more lines from SFHs that currently exist elsewhere.
- chrisseaton 8y agoThey're talking about a circle of multi-family homes, surrounded by single-family homes, and steadily expanding the size of the circle of multi-family homes so density increases. But it's ok because the outer circle of single-family homes becomes accessible to public transport from taxes. But as the circle of multi-family homes keeps increasing... eventually you develop the last single-family homes and hit the ocean and there's no more single-family homes. So you would lose single-family-homes.
- function_seven 8y agoNo. He's saying the opposite. That whole blocks won't convert en masse. That individual properties within the new zones will convert to multi-tenant, and that will drive an overall density increase and more taxes, benefiting all units in the area, even the SFHs that didn't convert. If you currently own a SFH, it's entirely up to you whether the house stays that way or not. You can remain as-is, and enjoy the transit benefits that accrue from the deeper tax base.
- 8y ago
- usaar333 8y ago> The solution is the same as every other time this comes up. Upzone the city. I'm all for increasing density in the Bay Area, but it is very easy to overstate as that "solving the problem". You will see more people being able to live and work in SF (which is overall good for society) and have more disposable income, but you won't by any means make SF an "affordable" city full of "children". On the affordability side: * There is enormous pent-up demand to live in SF. If you drop rents $100/month, a lot more people are now willing to live there. Even more if rents drop another $100/month. * It's more expensive to build tall buildings (per sq foot of habitable space) than single family homes or townhomes. * You end up with an equilibrium point that is cheaper, but by no means on par with Central Valley pricing. On the children side: In America, there's a very strong cultural attachment for children to grow up with a significant amount of space. Single-family homes and town homes work for most; condos and apartments do not (esp. when developers in SF build very few new condos/apartments with more than 2 bedrooms) Additionally, having lived in both SF and the south bay with kids, very dense environments [1] are more annoying to raise kids in due to the difficulty of shuttling them from place to place. Combined with higher pricing per square foot and lack of a guarantee on using neighborhood schools, the needle quickly swings to choosing to live in suburbs once you have kids. [1] As in more dense than SF residential neighborhoods, which are already quite dense by US standards.
- davidw 8y ago> There is enormous pent-up demand to live in SF While that's true, you do need to be careful with that argument. You get people arguing that eeeeeveryone wants to live in San Francisco. And others arguing that everyone wants to live in Boulder, Portland, Seattle, Los Angeles, Austin, and even right here in Bend, Oregon (really!) because they're all convinced that their town is the bestest place on the planet.
- jackmodern 8y agoAll of those places are desirable and do have pent up demand though. If I could cheaply buy a house in SF, Seattle, or Boulder... you bet I would!!! But I can't, so I rent as cheaply as possible in SF.
- geebee 8y agoI am curious - how old were the houses that were getting demolished in Minneapolis? A lot of the houses that would be torn down SF are nearing 100 years old. That probably sounds comically young to people from Europe, but SF's neighborhoods are among the oldest west of the Mississippi. You put "character" in quotes... but how far would you go with this? Would you support the right of a property owner to tear down an old building in the French Quarter of New Orleans and replace it with a modern steel and glass structure? How about an old building in the left bank of Paris? The complicated thing about NIMBYism is that not all backyards are alike. I say this with full acknowledgement that SF's housing policy has created a horrendous situation. But I actually do think it's possible to build substantially more density here, close to public transportation, without tearing down the older neighborhoods.
- davidw 8y agoSomething that is sometimes missed in these debates is that the most egregious areas are not actually SF. I mean, NIMBYism is pretty bad there, but it's way worse in, say, Marin county, Palo Alto, and other locations that want to keep playing suburb make believe instead of acknowledging they're part of a large metro region and allowing the market to add housing.
- deogeo 8y agoThere's nothing wrong with not letting The Market optimize every square meter of real-estate you care about. Not to mention the selective application of what The Market entails - aren't zoning rights just as real as property rights, that The Market respects? Why not allow The Market to respond to high property prices by redirecting development elsewhere?
- finnh 8y ago> aren't zoning rights just as real as property rights, that The Market respects? No. "zoning rights" are not rights, they are rules applying to property that people own _and are subject to change_ much more fluidly than the ownership itself.
- danieltillett 8y agoOr the solution could be to do nothing. Do we all have to live in SF? If the people living there want to spend all their money on rent or mortgage interest it is fine by me.
- davidw 8y agoEventually, yeah, there's a breaking point and industry will abandon that area. But in the meantime, excluding people from one of the most economically productive places on the planet is hugely detrimental for the 'marginal' people who end up not living and working there. The economy overall loses out a lot, too. https://www.vox.com/2014/7/15/5901041/nimbys-are-costing-the-us-economy-billions https://www.vox.com/2014/7/15/5901041/nimbys-are-costing-the... Also: there's a climate change argument to all of this. Forcing people out of a region that actually claims to care about it into places like, say, Phoenix or Las Vegas or Dallas or other sprawly places entirely dependent on cars... is not a win for the environment.
- danieltillett 8y agoI would say the breaking point has already been reached. There are heaps of better places to live with a vastly lower costs. All we need to do is convince the VCs to fund startups in these places and we can all forget about SF.
- davidw 8y ago> All we need to do is convince the VCs to fund startups in these places and we can all forget about SF And you need to make sure there's a big talent pool there, and good universities. A few places are close to that, but it's not so easy to replicate. This book talks about it some: https://amzn.to/2XAU3f0 https://amzn.to/2XAU3f0 And most of the places that are close have rampant NIMBYism problems of their own.
- fmajid 8y agoIf anything, talent is getting more concentrated. The Boston region has lost a lot of its tech companies, for instance.
- hindsightbias 8y agoOr we could upzone Stanford and Palo Alto and no transit would be needed.
- jedberg 8y agoWe could and should, but the article was about San Francisco. And let's face it, more people want to live in SF than PA or Stanford.
- newsoul2019 8y agoHow about all that green space on both sides of 280 - we don't need that any more. We should also relocate all those graves in Colma being kept there by selfish NIMBY families.
- lquist 8y ago+1 To NIMBYers: The "character" of your neighborhood is more important than cheaper housing for everyone--disproportionately helping lower income people?
- burfog 8y agoThat one change alone would make a huge difference, yes. It would ruin neighborhoods. I know a person with a SFH in the geographic center of San Francisco. It's RH1 zoning. She would suffer greatly from "zoning good for up to four units". Her street is peaceful. You could stand in it and play ball, not that she does. Free parking is plentiful. There are no loiterers or buses. Usually there are no pedestrians or moving cars. You'd take all that away from her. She is surrounded by transit, not that it matters to her. She is too vulnerable to safely use it. There are two different MUNI lines and several different bus routes within a distance that many people would consider to be short. Transit expansion would be completely useless for her. I don't think she'd mind shutting down the transit. She would be harmed if her environment were to change. Adjustment gets more difficult with age. Major change, like moving out of the area, might put an end to her independent living. It would also separate her from her community, particularly her church and some family.