7 ms·
This has nothing to do with communications or product development. China will not let a non-Chinese company ever gain top position in any sector. That's how the
by manigandham 8y ago
This has nothing to do with communications or product development. China will not let a non-Chinese company ever gain top position in any sector. That's how the government works. And yes the article is bullshit because this same government won't allow any negative press about their actions either. These Pandaily journalists will have a very hard time if they actually wrote about the real environment there.
- tanilama 8y agoAmazon isn't near top ever in China, it is like 1-2 percent of the market share. Not that different than Microsoft sunset their gaming business in Japan
- manigandham 8y agoAmazon will never get greater market share because China's govt won't let them. Microsoft did not leave Japan, they are in fact expanding Xbox Asia and have added an Asian team to the Global Gaming Partnership and Development (GDDP) division: https://www.google.com/search?q=xbox+asia+expanding https://www.google.com/search?q=xbox+asia+expanding
- AsyncAwait 8y agoIt seems to me that in these kinds of topics, someone always tries to pin the majority of the blame on Chinese protectionism. While that's certainly a factor, it seems Amazon has not been able to capture anywhere near the market share foreign companies operating in China are regularly allowed to capture, (before feeling the pressure). So sometimes, (like in this case, it looks like), it may just really be the case of a business not being able to adopt to the different expectations of Chinese consumers. I was just reading the other day about why U.S. car makers struggle in Japan and that for example domestic car makers there offer the ability to customize the car to an extent U.S. companies can't compete with. It's likely that Amazon faced enough competition naturally, given its low market share.
- tracker1 8y agoI think part of the problem a lot of the time, is Asia gets bundled together... I mean Indian culture by itself is varied, let alone Japan, Taiwan, Singapore, China and other Asian countries. Much more so than even intra-US variances between D and R. You need businesses that understand this, or need to stay in more localized regions and expand as one's understanding expands. Culture is varied and in many ways everything. Competition is also biased and fierce. At least that's my understanding of things (as a white guy born and remaining in the SW USA). I do find it funny that Amazon is pivoting to "high quality cross-border sales" considering that into the U.S. seems to be low quality, high markup sales (including high levels of counterfeits) with no end in sight.
- mrb 8y agoI don't think the Chinese government had any role in destroying Amazon's business. In fact we can find counter-examples to your theory as there are foreign companies very successful in China: https://www.1421.consulting/2018/06/successful-foreign-companies-in-china/ https://www.1421.consulting/2018/06/successful-foreign-compa...
- manigandham 8y agoThe Chinese govt didn't destroy anything, they just won't let them compete. This is not a secret conspiracy, it's public knowledge. Those counterexamples are just companies operating in China, of which there are many. There's no problem unless they try to become major players which will never happen. Ikea is the biggest and has recently come under pressure for simply suggesting that Taiwan is a separate country through packaging. This is tightly controlled market, you don't just wander in and do whatever you want.
- mtw 8y ago> China will not let a non-Chinese company ever gain top position in any sector. I don't know about this. Starbucks, McDonalds, KFC, Boeing, Apple and many others are ahead of their Chinese peers in China. It sounds like you're just using a blanket statement from reading various online articles without even how it's out there.
- manigandham 8y agoI've been there, worked with people there, have friends there building businesses for decades. Have you been out there? Companies are allowed to operate and grow, but they are tightly controlled. Apple has strong competition and has already trimmed prices and revenue targets. China just purchased 300 planes from Airbus instead of Boeing. McDonalds sold off 80% of its China operations to a Chinese stated-owned company years ago because it had trouble adapting its menu. KFC in China is owned by Yum China and headquartered in Shanghai. The world is not some free-market paradise. Territorial rules are everywhere. You'll encounter them just to do business in local counties within a state like New York. China's government has incredible power and control and has far more impact than you might think.
- ETHisso2017 8y ago>Apple has strong competition and has already trimmed prices and revenue targets. How is that the government's fault? >China just purchased 300 planes from Airbus instead of Boeing. Airbus is European >McDonalds sold off 80% of its China operations to a Chinese stated-owned company years ago because it had trouble adapting its menu. Again why is McDs inability to serve the Chinese palate the fault of the government? Consumer tastes in food are far more determined by culture than government. The rest of your statement is a non sequitur and strawman.
- manigandham 8y agoApple's Chinese competitors are helped by the government. China does not have an aviation manufacturer to compete directly (yet) but it ensures that neither Boeing or Airbus get a significant lead over each other in their controlling market. The parent poster claimed McDonalds was a successful example, however it only successful because it is now led by Chinese-state-owned agency so the real-estate (which is 99% of the value) is not foreign owned. Same with KFC. What is non-sequitur? That governments exist and have different rules for their businesses and citizens?
- Leary 8y ago"This has nothing to do with communications or product development. " And yet the users in this thread have repeatedly said that there are major product differences between Amazon and its Chinese competitors, where the alternatives offer much better value propositions to their customers. In addition, Amazon is having trouble in many countries other than China.
- xvector 8y ago> there are major product differences between Amazon and its Chinese competitors, Because the Chinese counterparts are government propped.
- munk-a 8y agoHonestly, what? The US props up US corporations all the time... didn't Amazon just pay -$129M (as in, received free money) in taxes to the US government?
- hartator 8y agoAssuming an average 8.00% sales tax on Amazon revenue 232.9 billion USD, Amazon still paid $18-19B in taxes. That's significant. And EU VATs are usually higher than 8.00%.
- munk-a 8y agoAmazon has severe product development issues for their goods marketplace, up here in Canada the wind is saying that Amazon's quality is always somewhat questionable with white-labeled resellers that are offering goods available through AliExpress or Wish but at a steep markup. Amazon has shifted from a company that sells highish quality goods of a wide variety to selling goods of random quality of that wide variety which simply can't compete with the markup they're placing on their products. Again, I only know Canada's market over the last few years, but Amazon doesn't really bring a lot to the table - concurrently their cloud services are pretty good... but becoming indistinguishable from their competitors and their price transparency and customer support is crap.
- empath75 8y agoAmazon is the premier marketplace for counterfeits and relabelled crap from alibaba. I don’t know why anyone buys anything from there. I’m at the point where I’d rather buy most things from Walmart.
- seemuch 8y agoI cannot believe this is the top comment. What you say is totally anecdotal. Do you have any evidence that Chinese government went out stopping Amazon from succeeding in China?
- tekkk 8y agoWhile the evidence in this case seems to be against this statement (Amazon indeed offered worse service than competitors) I think it is otherwise valid. Chinese are really driven to become the world's superpower number 1 and give no quarter to Western companies trying to establish themselves in China. So the big dilemma is, do we let them? Or more precisely, do we as the outside world let Chinese stifle all the foreign companies in their own market while their own companies operate freely in those foreign countries? It smells really a lot of mercantilism, and the Chinese culture of copy-catting freely doesn't help. It seems like the Western countries in particular have become too soft for Chinese tactics, and are too afraid to act against China. This at least has been my perception.
- CriticalCathed 8y agoAct how? What precisely could be done outside of protectionist policies that seem to be regarded as outmoded, inefficient, and taboo. Are we going to war? Isolationism? React in kind? Simply wait?
- nine_k 8y agoRethink fashions and taboos and check whether these policies have merit? A market works well when it's not distorted.
- OkGoDoIt 8y agoIt seems the parent is suggesting that we block Chinese companies from operating in the USA, basically tit-for-tat retribution. Based on "...while their own companies operate freely in those foreign countries" This might be applicable for hardware sales, but for service companies (including ecommerce, search, ride hailing, all the big USA tech company niches) it's kind of a moot point. None of the big Chinese companies put any effort into working outside of China. In fact my biggest complaint is they don't do any internationalization at all, so if you don't read Chinese you basically can't use anything. To the extend that services even work outside of China they are mainly only used by Chinese people, see for example WeChat or Taobao or Baidu. So I'm not sure this line of action would have any effect. If the parent instead meant blocking Americans from doing any business with China (as a manufacturer of smartphones, for example), that's likely to have much more downside to American companies and consumers than to China, so we'd be shooting ourselves in the foot. But all these points are debatable, see all the back-and-forth about the tariffs/trade war. Some great economic write-ups on all sides.
- oska 8y agoWhat Chinese companies have top position in any sector in the US? And do you think the US government would allow any to get there?
- nine_k 8y agoI think we can see the recent actions against Huawei partly in this light.
- macspoofing 8y ago>This has nothing to do with communications or product development. China will not let a non-Chinese company ever gain top position in any sector. Do you have any evidence that this is what happened in this situation?? > And yes the article is bullshit because this same government won't allow any negative press about their actions either. Again. Could be true, but how am I supposed to know that your interpretation is correct?
- awl130 8y ago"That's how the government works". Calm down. Huawei has been shut out of America (and many other allies) because of allegations of ties to the Chinese government. Amazon is on the cusp of winning a $10B contract for the Pentagon. So, same thing. America and China are now explicitly strategic competitors, both governments have been saying that for the past 2 years. It's about competition, not about totalitarian repression.
- dfischer 8y agoNo, not the same thing when there's evidence of lawbreaking and eavesdropping.
- manigandham 8y agoI'm perfectly calm. The US government is nowhere near as protectionist and controlling as China's. This is indisputable. The current administration is starting to change policies to at least counter some of the control China extends beyond its borders. Totalitarian control has an effect on competition. Those cannot be independent.
- djvu9 8y agoThough the end result is more or less something similar you are over simplifying the situation. IMO usually there are two major reasons that makes foreign companies hard to compete with locals: * Excessive regulations and sometimes special rules for foreign companies. But e-commerce is usually not the worst sector for this. * "Expertise" on how to deal with local laws. It is no secret local laws are usually selectively applied. Local companies have a lot more flexibility than foreign companies and they can do a lot of things that could create prohibitive legal liabilities for foreign companies if they even want to follow. For example, low wages and unhealthy work environments, unlawful marketing tactics, bribery and corruption etc. I would argue the latter is the usual competitive advantages local companies have.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]