4 ms·
It's not clear to me that on-premises state university education is interstate commerce. (Not that that would necessarily stop it from being tried, but we have,
by sokoloff 8y ago
It's not clear to me that on-premises state university education is interstate commerce. (Not that that would necessarily stop it from being tried, but we have, at least in theory per the Tenth Amendment, state supremacy for areas not granted the Feds by the Constitution nor reserved for the people.)
- dillonmckay 8y agoMany of these state schools operate international or online programs, and charge some students ‘out-of-state’ tuition, and take federal subsidies.
- dragonwriter 8y ago> It's not clear to me that on-premises state university education is interstate commerce. It's already heavily federally subsidized, and challenging changes to the subsidy conditions on the grounds that the feds have no right to be involved at all would be suicidal for state universities since it wouldn't just kill the new conditions if it succeeded but the subsidies themselves.
- sokoloff 8y agoSo treat it like the federal highway funding being conditioned on the states "behaving" with respect to speed limit, DUI laws, and other items. I don't love but accept the feds exerting economic power based on economic grants they decide to give or withhold. I do have a problem with them asserting regulatory power reserved to the states/people by the 10th.
- dragonwriter 8y ago> So treat it like the federal highway funding being conditioned on the states "behaving" with respect to speed limit, DUI laws, and other items. That's already the case on a per-institution basis for federal funding, all that a policy goal of eliminating tuition requires is changing the conditions.
- wang_li 8y agoAfter Wickard v Filburn, and more recently Gonzales v Raich, everything effects interstate commerce.