4 ms·
>> They redistribute wealth from young people right now to old people right now, but they are sold to young people as though they are investing into their futur
by phkahler 8y ago
>> They redistribute wealth from young people right now to old people right now, but they are sold to young people as though they are investing into their future.
I want to say that's fiction in the US but it's worse than fiction. The social security system pays out about what a person puts in over their lifetime. It is not the young paying the old as you say. But that's not the whole story. The "fund" has been robbed by congress by "investing" the money in government bonds. In other words, other parts of the government "borrowed" the money and spent it. So it isn't spent on old retired people, it's spent on society at large. We're at a tipping point where the net flow of money into the fund should reverse - more paying out than going in - which means those bonds will have to be repaid without taking out new ones. Congress has gotten so used to treating it as a general revenue source that they act like SS is going to be insolvent, when the reality is they can't figure out how to pay it back - it's the government that's really on the edge here.
Politicians have tried to paint this many ways to avoid the truth. One even asked the federal reserve to verify that they don't really need to pay off those bonds and the response way basically "um yes you do".
- Mirioron 8y agoOf course there are exceptions, but I'm talking about social programs in aggregate in developed countries. Most of them don't work like social security does in the US. For example, I'm not aware of healthcare working like that in any country.
- vageli 8y ago> >> They redistribute wealth from young people right now to old people right now, but they are sold to young people as though they are investing into their future. > I want to say that's fiction in the US but it's worse than fiction. The social security system pays out about what a person puts in over their lifetime. Does that payout account for inflation? Why are we forced to give up a percentage of our wealth to let the government manage for us if it's a 1:1 distribution?
- Mirioron 8y agoI think the reason is that many people won't do it otherwise. Once they reach retirement age some of them will complain and others will demand that the government do something about it.
- amanaplanacanal 8y agoYour question sounds like it is about the history of Social Security, and how it got to be the way it is. Some googling will put you on the right track.