4 ms·
While I like the idea, I fear the potential for abuse, conflict and community splits. It will need some sort of moderation, at least to prevent: 1. spam 2. ch
by mschuster91 8y ago
While I like the idea, I fear the potential for abuse, conflict and community splits. It will need some sort of moderation, at least to prevent:
1. spam
2. child pornography
3. content against the laws
The only thing that is easy to define as policy is #2. No one likes child porn. But even then, there are grey areas with differing legal status - lolicon on the anime side and "barely legal" on the realistic side, plus CGI.
Spam - for me I'd flag all commercial advertisings as spam, others would heasitate to block Viagra spammers.
Then the final category: illegal content. The US doesn't like nipples. Germany has no problem with nipples. Swastikas and other NS insignia? Other way around. Some post-Soviet states have banned Hammer and Sickle or the Red Star. Some countries have extremely strict libel laws, others have non-existing libel laws. In some countries (hello Germany) even linking to illegal content can get you thrown into jail, in others not.
And finally: who should pay for operational costs of such an index? Wikipedia only works out because the contributors worldwide donate enormous amounts of time to it, and Wikipedia has only a fraction of the amount of content that Youtube and Twitter create, and Facebook is orders of magnitude bigger.
- snvzz 8y ago>No one likes child porn. I hope you do realize the contradiction.
- mschuster91 8y agoAside from a couple thousand pedophiles, sorry but I'm not gonna take care of their needs...
- anigbrowl 8y agoThe point seems to be that without a specific plan to address that issue, it will be gamed by CP fans who have a very different risk calculus to regular folk. There are far more than a 'few thousand pedophiles'; that number is more reflective of the number of convictions each year. While drawing statistical inferences is difficult, the stats in the appendices to this report suggest there's perhaps ~100k tips a year to police about child sexual abuse across the US. https://www.justice.gov/psc/file/842411/download#page=118 https://www.justice.gov/psc/file/842411/download#page=118
- WaltPurvis 8y agoThe proposal is for a publicly funded index as base-level infrastructure. Filtering out spam, pornography, and other undesirable or illegal content would be done at the service level, i.e., but companies/organizations building user-facing search applications on top of the index.
- skybrian 8y agoAnd suppose someone builds a service specifically to find illegal content? There will be pressure to block them and also remove stuff from the index. So you need a policy on who gets blocked and that's just as political.
- mschuster91 8y ago> Filtering out spam, pornography, and other undesirable or illegal content would be done at the service level, No, it has to be done before, at the infrastructure level. There are jurisdictions (Germany, for one!) where even the storage or publication of links can be illegal under certain circumstances. With the new GDPR law and whatever is coming up in the US, the situation is even more unclear as it is trivial to embed protected personal data into URLs.