4 ms·
There's been a lot written already on the background, which is linked to in this post. https://noamross.github.io/datacamp-sexual-assault/ https://noamross.git
by minimaxir 8y ago
There's been a lot written already on the background, which is linked to in this post.
https://noamross.github.io/datacamp-sexual-assault/ https://noamross.github.io/datacamp-sexual-assault/
- chrisseaton 8y agoSo why does this post then obfuscate these facts as 'an incident of sexual misconduct'? Why be so intentionally vague? > About two weeks ago, DataCamp published a blog post outlining an incident of sexual misconduct at the company. Could have been > About two weeks ago, DataCamp published a blog post outlining an incident where one of DataCamp’s executives danced inappropriately and made uninvited physical contact with another employee Forward-load the basic facts so we don't have to go down a rabbit hole.
- tptacek 8y agoYou're doing the same thing by using the euphemisms "danced inappropriately" and "made uninvited physical contact". Point being: it's not productive to litigate this stuff.
- chrisseaton 8y agoHmm I think "an incident of sexual misconduct" is the euphemism and "danced inappropriately" and "made uninvited physical contact" are the plain-spoken explanations so interesting to hear your opposite opinion. If someone told me "an incident of sexual misconduct" I'd then ask "ok... so what was it?" but if someone told me "made uninvited physical contact" I'd say "ah ok I understand."
- tptacek 8y agoI have had uninvited (and unwelcome) physical contact that took the form of handshakes, so obviously that language isn't shedding any real light. Those words could describe harassment, or they could describe aggravated sexual assault.
- sonnyblarney 8y ago"made uninvited physical contact" - I don't know if a whole lot can be understood by that. Someone giving the 2-cheek Euro kiss in North America could be 'uninvited' to many, surely. So could someone swinging someone around on the dance-floor. Maybe someone danced like Elvis (i.e. hips) and then put their arm around someone else and said something to them drunkenly. Or maybe someone was 'grabbed' or 'groped' in a way that would obviously be totally out of bounds in any context. There's definitely a range of possibilities here. I'm going to guess that if this is a serious incident, there was probably 'unacceptable groping' but maybe they should have phrased it as such - because 'unwanted touching' is, in and of itself possibly problematic, but there's a range of behaviours there, some of which don't rise to the level of really bad stuff like groping.
- neom 8y agoA reach into another humans space is always uninvited until it's explicitly not. Cultural norms and traditions can somewhat abstract that, but yes, even that is still a guess.
- zaroth 8y agoThis occurred on a dance floor which seems to be useful context, but is a detail which TFA and other bloggers have called “victim blaming”. There’s no amount of detail that can cast a fully revealing light onto something like this that happens out in a public space. I used to think a video of the incident might explain what happened, and then you have cases like Convington where people can see remarkably different things happening in the same sequence of frames. What amazes me is the tarnishing of the entire company and brand which stems from this kind of PR campaign being run against the company. Is this Just Another angry Internet mob going after someone, and why is a private matter between two adults at an after hours workplace sponsored event turned into an existential crisis for the entire company? If there was an assault, shouldn’t someone call the police? Everything else it seems is trial by the court of public opinion. You want to believe this entire campaign isn’t the result of two people bumping into each other on the dance floor back in 2017, but in any case I’m still left wondering why the company itself has become the target.
- staticautomatic 8y agoOnly because you've made an assumption about what uninvited physical contact means.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- droithomme 8y agoHe is directly quoting the original blogpost's description by using that terminology, and he is responding to a post with the relevant link. That is the actual original description of the incident. It's not his own personal summary. > "Specifically, in October 2017, at an informal employee gathering at a bar after a week-long company offsite, one of DataCamp’s executives danced inappropriately and made uninvited physical contact with another employee while on the dance floor."
- tptacek 8y agoI know he is. But the summary he's quoting is from the company, DataCamp, not the person who wrote this blog, and yet his criticism is direct at the blogger/instructor.
- whymauri 8y agoI feel your frustration, but you answered your own question(s) above. Sometimes people just struggle to write succinctly and clearly. If you feel particularly strongly about this, politely written feedback on the author's comment section might be useful?
- curiousgal 8y agoputs tinfoil hat on The author of post is the same person who's been heavy criticized[0] for her analysis of the StackOverflow survey dataset. Maybe she's trying to shift the attention to something else? I am not defending DataCamp or pulling an Ad Hominem, it's just a strange coincidence. 0.https://meta.stackoverflow.com/questions/382731/please-be-more-careful-when-interpreting-the-so-developer-survey https://meta.stackoverflow.com/questions/382731/please-be-mo...
- sametmax 8y agoI think it's to avoid people being dismissive about it. If you are vague, people can't comment saying you are making a big fuss out of a childish behavior and say that we all have important work to do.
- jonathankoren 8y agoBecause this is HR approved language and they are apparently firing anyone that doesn’t toe the line. https://dhavide.github.io/a-note-to-our-commuity-on-building-trust.html https://dhavide.github.io/a-note-to-our-commuity-on-building...
- pcstl 8y agoCan DataCamp fire instructors, though? My understanding was that DataCamp instructors signed a contract allowing DataCamp to use their material for a given span of time (and that this did not make them DataCamp employees) Since these people are asking others not to watch DataCamp courses, it would seem to me that their shot at actually making more courses for DataCamp has been forfeit anyway, so what can DataCamp really do against them?
- amrrs 8y agoPerhaps, it sounds vague because it's new for you and many other readers outside data science community or at least R community. There's been so much written and tweeted about this in past few weeks. So probably that's why the Author could have thought to avoid redundancy and kept it brief.
- DanBC 8y ago> So why does this post then obfuscate these facts as 'an incident of sexual misconduct'? Because she's not talking about the misconduct, but about the response to the misconduct. One of the reasons she's not talking about the misconduct is because misogynists will seek to relitigate the orginal event with the predictable victim-blaming concern-trolling.
- minimaxir 8y agoThis is extremely important. There are three elements here. 1) The actual incident. 2) The need for instructors to persuade DataCamp to make a response. 3) The response itself. (3a: the noindex tag) #1 is very bad on its own, but #2 and #3 are its own problems and the ones being highlighted in recent discussions. (and provide more context for #1)
- teddyh 8y agoWhile all this is very probably true, there’s also the possibility that it actually really is about the nail (so to speak). I can easily imagine that people have been burned before by being assured that the “nail” is not the problem, and initially believing it. This, I think, is why many people want to hear some amount of detail. Not too much, just enough to make it seem plausible to them. Which shouldn’t be too much to ask, and if someone refuses, that’s a bad sign.
- DanBC 8y agoAll the detail has already been shared, by the very many people within the org talking to senior management. This is what people always say in these threads: don't talk about it in public until you've tried to deal with it in private. Well, they did try, and they got fired.
- teddyh 8y ago> All the detail has already been shared, by the very many people within the org talking to senior management. True, but it was not adequately summarized in the article which is the topic of discussion, and this was the issue discussed in this subthread. > This is what people always say in these threads: don't talk about it in public until you've tried to deal with it in private. That’s not what I meant, or what anyone else in this subthread meant. I have no idea what you’re responding to.