3 ms·
You know, I thought music would be creative. But then I tried to do it. It was terrible! It was all about how to strike the piano keys, how to move my fingers s
by yummyfajitas 19y ago
You know, I thought music would be creative. But then I tried to do it. It was terrible! It was all about how to strike the piano keys, how to move my fingers so they don't hit each other, etc. No creativity whatsoever!
Then I tried making up my own music, but that ridiculous. I spent more time figuring out why it sounded bad than I did actually coming up with a melody. My chords didn't work, the rhythm was all off, etc. When it was done, it didn't even sound that good!
I have no idea how Reznor deals with the mind-numbing drudgery of it.
- parenthesis 19y agoIt's not like that once you've been at it for a while (i.e. years). Consider the difference between trying to write a program in a language that you don't know, having to look up every single thing in the manual as you go along; and knowing a language (+ framework(s) / library(ies) ) so well that you can decide what you want to do on a fairly abstract level, and then just bang out the code without having to think consciously about syntactic and semantic minutiae.
- yummyfajitas 19y agoI totally didn't notice the parallel until you pointed it out. I guess Reznor may be a creative person after all, rather than just a chord slinging drone.
- aaronblohowiak 19y agoOne of the big differences is that some people can sit down at / pick up a new instrument and in a few minutes be improvising a song they heard once, a week ago. with programming, the interface is not kinesthetic so at least for me, the internalization of APIs takes longer (getting down new lexicons seems to have more cognitive load for me than adjusting physical interface -- not that i can play instruments like that or learn music by ear. yet.)
- iron_ball 19y agoBad parallel. Coding up a CSS/HTML web page full of embedded PHP and Javascript and trying to get it pixel-perfect is worlds away from writing an internally consistent program for a single run target using a single sane language and APIs. You can't say "it's all music."
- yummyfajitas 19y agoOn the contrary, I'm saying that music "isn't all music" either. Whatever your craft, before you reach beauty, you need to deal with technical details.
- aaronblohowiak 19y agoIn classical approaches to beauty, the thinking was that Beauty was the result of strict adherence to rules. From wikipedia on aesthetics: <quote> Greek philosophers initially felt that aesthetically appealing objects were beautiful in and of themselves. Plato felt that beautiful objects incorporated proportion, harmony, and unity among their parts. Similarly, in the Metaphysics, Aristotle found that the universal elements of beauty were order, symmetry, and definiteness. </quote> but yea. a classical foundation in a trade and rigorous pursuit of <latin>ars</latin> enables the craftsmen to do excellent things, or failing that, at least be competent in routine.