41 ms·
There is a super-simple solution to this problem: a progressive tax on income, wealth, and most importantly, inheritance (with an exemption for private business
by lisper 8y ago
There is a super-simple solution to this problem: a progressive tax on income, wealth, and most importantly, inheritance (with an exemption for private businesses below a certain size that are both owned and administered by a single family).
Another possibility: eliminate private ownership of land. This is actually not as radical as it sounds. It's a big shift in mindset, but not that big a change in how things actually work. The mindset shift is to go back to the native american idea that all land is collectively owned by the people. The government is the "management company" that administers it, and one of the things it can do is offer long-term leases. This would essentially be the same as the status quo except that instead of owning the land and paying property tax, you'd own a lease and pay rent. The reason I think this would have a beneficial effect is that the change in mindset would change the dynamics of political debates. For example, NIMBYism would be less tenable because it's not your back yard any more. You're just a tenant.
- kev009 8y agoThere are plenty of examples of the later and none of them are pretty compared to status quo in the US. It seems unpopular to state but blindingly obvious that we live in the best time in the history of the world for humans, and if you live in a first world country you have it easier than anyone at any point in history to simply live or climb an economic ladder. Second system syndrome is en vogue right now in politics. Maybe there is some tectonic shift that will happen this century due to technological progress, but I'd counter moderate and incremental change would be much less risky (if you botch a software project maybe people lose jobs, if you botch a political sea change millions of people die) and there is plenty of small but meaningful improvements to be had for every class of person.
- Frost1x 8y agoThe problem is that the economic system as it stands today does not allow for moderate incremental change. In a country where we blindly worship capitalism from birth to our graves, any attacks against capitalism are framed as being un-American. Small iterative changes are fought tooth-and-nail by those emboldened through exploits encouraged by capitalism who, ironically, hold most the power to make such changes (not much unlike historical implementations of fuedelism). The system itself is very self-preserving in that nature. Those who have the most to lose in the system have the most power and resources to resist change because that's how the underlying system is structured. With socioeconomic mobility at an all time low due to earlier successes closing doors behind them (the "american dream"), it's no wonder people are growing more frustrated and seeking radical change over incremental changes. They've tried incremental change (and watched their parents and grandparents try it). It didn't work, so now they're pulling out the stops and who could blame them. Look at the 2016 and upcoming 2020 presidential elections, largely fueled products of this issue in various forms. People are growing very tired of being lied to and exploited. The very wealthy groups, as the article suggests, need to consider that maximizing long term profits may require them to reduce their short term profit margins a bit and keep working classes from turning this entire country upside down.
- kev009 8y agoI think everything you said could be true and you completely missed the point of my comment. If I lived in a third world country, I'd be more astounded that there are places I could never work a day in my life and be fed, sheltered, have access to incredible healthcare (yes even in the US) and probably lead an intellectually satisfying (with free access to books, entertainment, computers, Internet and FOSS etc) life. The fact that there are thousands of billionaires that have possessions and power beyond my comprehension as even a very well off American doesn't mean much. No more than the fact that there is a Pope or Presidents or professional athletes or any other demigod I will never be. It's just another modern form of feudalism that humans seem to be hardwired for.
- lifehacked 8y agoThe problem is that the changes you propose rip out the framework that allowed our country to become a leader in many respects, show me a socialist or communist country that innovates, there are none, they all come to capitalist countries to learn and compete, your missing the forest for the trees mate.
- lisper 8y ago> show me a socialist or communist country that innovates Finland? China?
- nercht12 8y ago> Finland? China? The Chinese just steal research papers and pretend they're theirs.
- squarefoot 8y agoThe Chinese invented the compass, movable type and other things long before the west. (I'm not Chinese)
- Frost1x 8y agoI'm not Chinese and not a fan of the PRC, but you can't honestly believe all research from China is stolen. Assuming proper nutrition and exposure to education, there are intelligent and innovative people everywhere. Probabilistically speaking, with those assumptions, the larger the population, the more of that innovative potential they're likely to have. Also, it's efficient to steal ideas. I assure you, given the opportunity, businesses in the US frequently steal ideas/IP as well, they're just more careful about it because there's more consequences. Why do you think so many IP lawsuits exist. Furthermore, stealing or copying a successful process is in human nature for survival, heck, it's part of the foundations of evolution. Most people are only concerned when it's their ideas being stolen but not when they "borrow" others'.
- nercht12 8y ago
- trentnix 8y agoAnother possibility: eliminate private ownership of land. This is actually not as radical as it sounds. Historically, what follows this is mass poverty. The mindset shift is to go back to the native american idea that all land is collectively owned by the people. Native Americans tended to go to war when one group infringed on another's territory. The government is the "management company" that administers it, and one of the things it can do is offer long-term leases. The government struggles administering drivers licenses. And wherever they've been the landlord, the results have almost universally been impoverished ghettos.
- lisper 8y ago> Historically, what follows this is mass poverty. Yes, but historically capitalism has worked. That's the whole point here: things are changing. Not all of the lessons of history apply in a post-scarcity world.
- nercht12 8y ago> Not all of the lessons of history apply in a post-scarcity world. "Those who do not learn from history are doomed to repeat it." I'm not sure what you mean by "post-scarcity"? Things may be "available", but that doesn't mean people have access to them. While it's nice to think of land as "unowned", in practice, someone controls it, and they almost never have the interests of the occupants in mind. Besides, I've found that people tend to treat property better when they consider it theirs and have space AWAY from people. Going along with your point though, it might be best if everyone received some designed size plot of land (large enough to build a small family residence on at least). Yes, there would be competition, but in competitive areas, the land plots could be smaller. In "unwanted" areas (Kansas, Wyoming), plots could be large enough for profitable cattle and farming industry. The good thing would be that no one would be without land to built on; they would have their own space to "be them" and live as they wished without rubbing shoulders with their neighbors (which tends to make Americans rough around the edges, regardless of age/sex/political views). Currently, many people struggle just getting an apartment, let alone a house. Notably, the mechanics of a new system would need to be worked out, and would likely be abused, manipulated, and ruined because of selfish people, but it's a nice thought.
- seieste 8y agoThis seems like it could help the problem but there are serious consequences to enacting it. Inheritance tax is making it expensive to trasnfer a family-owned farm down the generations, and as a result they are sold to corporations instead. Bigger, wealthier families avoid the tax altogether by using legal methods, which makes the inheritance tax burden mostly fall on the poorer farmers. Removing ownership of land would do nothing to combat this. In fact, if farmers didn’t own their land, things would get worse, not better: they would have no incentive to use long-term (costlier) agricultural strategies, since they wouldn’t have any guarantee they’d benefit from it. Further, they’d be less likely to invest in long term equipment. Guess who would? Larger corporations. In other words, this proposal would exactly concentrate the wealth to big corporations, perhaps the opposite of your intention.
- lisper 8y ago> Inheritance tax is making it expensive to trasnfer a family-owned farm down the generations That is why I added: "with an exemption for private businesses below a certain size that are both owned and administered by a single family". > Bigger, wealthier families avoid the tax altogether by using legal methods Yes, to make this work you'd have to eliminate those loopholes.
- jammygit 8y agoI had not thought of that before
- skybrian 8y agoIf it's fundamentally the same situation, why would NIMBYism be any different? People will still care about their neighborhoods in much the same way.
- lisper 8y agoIt's the same economically, but not the same psychologically.
- skybrian 8y agoYou're asserting that, but not really giving evidence for it. Do people with very long-term leases really think any differently from home owners? Why?
- lisper 8y agoI don't know. I don't think this experiment has ever been done before.
- code_sloth 8y ago> Another possibility: eliminate private ownership of land. Look at Hong Kong, housing prices there have grown seriously out of whack, average citizens are suffering and young adults are leaving. You'd need a very competent and uncorrupt government to accomplish this ideal.
- JumpCrisscross 8y agoCollege admissions have to be part of the discussion. Elite American schools wash our aristocracy with a whiff of merit. If Harvard and Stanford want to maintain “institutional advancement” and “legacy” admissions preferences, that’s their right. But then they should lose their non-profit status. (And the “donations” cease to be tax deductible.)
- WhoBeI 8y agoBoth options seem radical. Either penalize success or forcefully take things from people their families have, possibly, owned for generations. If you compensate the owners of the land and take your time building the government institutions that will manage it the second option seems possible. Maybe something like what Scotland did in the 90's (I think it was) when they abolished the last parts of the feudal system. I don't see how that would be possible in the US though. US politicians are typically funded by corporations and corporations own land. Besides, from what I understand, the right to own their own land is very important to quite a few Americans. Put differently: I'm pretty sure an adult American in the 80's would scream "communism" at your ideas. Some of those work as politicians today. :-)
- Frost1x 8y agoLand (and property) ownership is quite important here because many of our other rights stem from land ownership. For example, if I'm on land I don't own, I have no real right to freedom of speech because I have no right to be on the land to begin with since it's privately held. I'm there legally by permission of the property owner only and can be removed. This becomes increasingly problematic the more private entities take ownership of land. Imagine a world where a few hundred people own nearly all the non-government owned property and the vast majority of citizens have to rent/lease or utilized shared property. Those private entities begin to dictate if I can take pictures, say certain things, bring a weapon on that property, etc. If the entire industry decides "we only allow Comcast Internet service on our grounds to drill into walls," then unless new laws or enacted at a state/city level forcing landlords to allow it or the FTC steps in, I guess you're using Comcast or doing without. In theory, conventional wisdom argues competitors will enter the market with less restrictions. In practice, it's all profit driven and the most efficient market solutions get adopted resulting in shared policies across the industry. If business across an industry in general finds it's more profitable that people can't have weapons on their properties and you have no land ownership, then you can own a gun but you'll have no where to put it. Or you may want to spread an idea through speech but no one will allow it. You're then restricted to either government properties where you do have those rights or another private entity that allows it. Property ownership is very complex here.
- Yetanfou 8y ago> eliminate private ownership of land Read up on the phenomenon called "the tragedy of the commons" [1] to learn why this is a terrible idea. For even more of an idea on where this can lead you can have a look at the 'Talk' page for the same Wikipedia topic [2] which shows an editing war on the very definition of the topic. Shared ownership does not imply shared stewardship as is made clear by the actions of some of the more vociferous Wikipedians. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tragedy_of_the_commons https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tragedy_of_the_commons [2] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Talk:Tragedy_of_the_commons https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Talk:Tragedy_of_the_commons