3 ms·
Yeah, but you get into that contract voluntarily, so you sort of know what you signed up for, and regardless, you have the option to quit. This is why I do not
by johnisgood 8y ago
Yeah, but you get into that contract voluntarily, so you sort of know what you signed up for, and regardless, you have the option to quit. This is why I do not understand the complaints.
- adamsea 8y agoMmmm if you don’t work and make money in the US you’ll be in a bad way, and since the majority of employers have the conditions described, and most job seekers have little negotiating leverage on these issues, the choice to sign the employment contract is voluntary, yes, but so much behind the circumstances and conditions of that signing is beyond the power of an individual to effect or influence through their choices. Which is why the saying “strength in numbers” is a saying.
- binarymax 8y agoThis choice is an illusion for anyone not in the higher echelons of society and your comment is the result of confirmation bias. Most people need to work and will take what is available to them and suffer the reality of a lopsided contract at will and vast underpayment. Most people can't just quit if they don't like their job - they will lose their only source of meager income, healthcare, and possibly their home.
- rleigh 8y agoNo, it's not entirely voluntary. It's a necessity to live. I might be able to pick and choose between several employers, but ultimately I'm going to have to choose one of them. There's a power imbalance between employee and employer, and that will translate into a negotiating disadvantage; the future employee is at a disadvantage here.
- johnisgood 8y ago> No, it's not entirely voluntary. In this case, it is not entirely voluntary for the employers either as they need employees for their business to function. > but ultimately I'm going to have to choose one of them No, you can become your own employer, for example. > There's a power imbalance between employee and employer, and that will translate into a negotiating disadvantage It depends on the state of the market. Right now, the job market is supposedly very good for programmers (employees). Employers are offering to trade their money in exchange for other people doing some task they want done. If you do not think it is fair trade, then do not do it. You are allowed to grow your own food, or pick berries.
- orthecreedence 8y agoCapital holders have most of the power, due to the unemployment pool. > No, you can become your own employer, for example. Not without capital, and you generally get capital by already having capital (collateral). > It depends on the state of the market. Right now, the job market is supposedly very good for programmers (employees). Good for programmers! But in general, the job market is not as good for most people as it is for programmers. > Employers are offering to trade their money in exchange for other people doing some task they want done. Right, this is a "voluntary" transaction entered by both people, but the argument is that there is a power imbalance that influences this transaction and tips the scales toward the employer (in the general sense, I'm sure we can find single examples where this is not the case). Not only this, but the balance is tipped even further by a system that overwhelmingly encourages debt (yes, voluntary, I know, but socially involuntary), essentially shackling people to needing higher amounts of income (and therefor relying on their employer more). It's possible to be debt-free and have a high-paying job, but it's exceedingly difficult, and you're essentially limited to a handful of industries.
- soVeryTired 8y ago> Employers are offering to trade their money in exchange for other people doing some task they want done. If you do not think it is fair trade, then do not do it. You are allowed to grow your own food, or pick berries. You're also free to die in the gutter, don't forget that one.
- johnisgood 8y agoI am not sure what you are trying to say. I brought up perfectly reasonable alternatives. Regardless, both parties are made better off by the trade. Employers are the ones helping those unfortunate people avoid the thing that is even worse than having a job, such as: suffering and dying in the gutter. :)
- supersleepgrump 8y agoAlthough At-Will employment gives the option for an employee to quit and seek out new employment whenever they want, At-Will explicitly favors employers. Most people would simply prefer a raise at a job they love---
- aiisjustanif 8y agoSounds like it isn't the most sane option in a society where human needs are attached to a job. The job provides health care and covers housing cost, and retirement pay. The job can short you and thus you look for a side hustle. But people also look for a side hustle to move up to the higher side of where they are in the class scale, or find retirement safety.