5 ms·
'Anomaly' is a polite way to say 'failure', no matter how fine the semantic wrapper. Failures are to be expected and OK and it's good that they happen during te
by anigbrowl 8y ago
'Anomaly' is a polite way to say 'failure', no matter how fine the semantic wrapper. Failures are to be expected and OK and it's good that they happen during testing rather than operation, but there's no value in euphemism here.
- sargun 8y agoPerhaps I’m wrong, but referring to issues in such non specific terms is not useful. It’s very similar to a cloud provider saying “increased error rates” meaning total outage or 0.001% of users experiencing off-nominal behavior. Is there nomenclature that’s better?
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- xattt 8y agoOne refers to the event as a statistic, the other captures the immediate aftermath and potential for danger relating to the event.
- jrockway 8y ago> Is there nomenclature that’s better? I prefer "rapid unplanned disassembly".
- rbanffy 8y agoIt seems nothing was disassembled here.
- azeotropic 8y agoYou must not have seen the video. Something turned the capsule into aluminum dust.
- rbanffy 8y agoThe orange cloud suggests the hydrazine was not released. I would expect a different color of the capsule was blown to pieces. What video are you referring to?
- stetrain 8y agoI think this one: https://twitter.com/Astronut099/status/1119825093742530560?s=19 https://twitter.com/Astronut099/status/1119825093742530560?s...
- rbanffy 8y agoYes. That's way too fast and too bright for comfort... I had only seen the orange oxidizer cloud when I made the comment. This looks like a very fast disassembly indeed. I hope they find the cause soon.
- 0_gravitas 8y agoSounds like the name of a Culture ship
- _Microft 8y agoIt is useful as long as they do not know what happened. NASA once had the problem that the initially suspected problem turned out to be wrong but the news was already out there and it took years to spread the correct one. That's why it these problems are now referred to as anomaly until the real cause is clear.
- rswail 8y ago"Anomaly" or anominal is the antonym (ie opposite) of "nominal". When things are going right, then everything is "nominal". An anomaly is where things aren't going according to their expected behavior. Anomalies can have differing levels of severity, depending on the impact of the anomaly on the mission plans. You can have anomalies at any time, that's different to a "defect" or a "failure". Failure implies anomalies so severe that the mission can not complete. So it's not a euphemism, it's a distinct term of the art in engineering of this sort.
- discreteevent 8y ago"it's a distinct term of the art in engineering of this sort" - I think the problem might be for people who don't work in that field, that the word anomaly in ordinary English means something that is slightly unusual. In other fields, including software, we would say that something failed even if it is only in initial development. If the term in common use for space craft is anomaly, then everyone in that field knows what it means so it is a good term because they are the only people that matter in dealing with it.