3 ms·
Ok, I’ll try one more time. Clearly, not all infinite sequences can be summed. So e.g., 1, -1, 1, -1, … has no sum. Now suppose that Achilles takes alternate
by foldr 8y ago
Ok, I’ll try one more time.
Clearly, not all infinite sequences can be summed. So e.g., 1, -1, 1, -1, … has no sum.
Now suppose that Achilles takes alternate forward and backward steps a (countably) infinite number of times. The first step takes one second, the second step takes half a second, and so on. (Each step covers the same distance.) Where does he end up after 2 seconds?
There’s no sensible answer to that question. Does that mean that Achilles can’t in fact traverse that particular sequence of steps? But then, why should he be unable to traverse a particular infinite sequence of steps merely because its sum is undefined? After all, the result of each individual step is perfectly well defined. If it’s possible in general to traverse infinite sequences, what stops him traversing that one?
To me, this just seems like Zeno’s paradox all over again. The mathematical treatment is more sophisticated, but the underlying paradox remains.
Zeno himself probably wouldn’t have distinguished carefully between summing an infinite sequence and spatially or temporally traversing it, since both notions would have seemed equally absurd from his point of view. Modern mathematics has shown us that the former isn’t in fact absurd. But Zeno’s paradoxes are arguably about the latter.
- throwawaymath 8y ago> Clearly, not all infinite sequences can be summed. So e.g., 1, -1, 1, -1, … has no sum. Your geometric series is not a summation of the steps or positions, but rather the time required to complete each step. Therefore your example is characterized by an identical geometric series to the model I used in my previous comment. More generally, Zeno’s paradox can be succinctly resolved by citing the monotone convergence theorem. Every bounded, monotonically decreasing function converges. The time required to complete the infinite series of half steps converges, because (again, with the definition of a metric) the time required to complete each individual step decreases commensurate with the change in distance.
- foldr 8y ago>Therefore your example is characterized by an identical geometric series to the model I used in my previous comment. I am not sure what you mean here. You can calculate the sum of the time series, but you can't calculate Achilles' final position, which is the question at issue. The question remains: if it's possible in general to traverse an infinite sequence of steps in space, why is it not possible to traverse the one that I specified? "Solving" Zeno's paradox by admitting the possibility of traversing an infinite series of points in space or time seems to give rise to paradoxes just as deep as the originals. > The time required to complete the infinite series of half steps converges, because (again, with the definition of a metric) the time required to complete each individual step decreases commensurate with the change in distance. Yes, that was Aristotle's observation and a key part of his proposed solution to the paradox. The problem is that this explains why it's possible to sum the series, not why it's possible to traverse it. You seem to be taking the position that any series that cannot be summed cannot be traversed. But why should that be so?
- foldr 8y agoThinking about this a bit more, I think what I'm trying to say is that Zeno's paradox is more about supertasks than it is about the problem of computing the sum of an infinite series. There's a nice summary article that I found here: http://personal.lse.ac.uk/ROBERT49/teaching/ph103/2013-2014/pdf/EarmanNorton_InfinitePains.pdf http://personal.lse.ac.uk/ROBERT49/teaching/ph103/2013-2014/...