3 ms·
what about stuff like child pornography What about people that make their own kids (I hear humans can do that) and then abuse them? Clearly we should have vid
by jrockway 16y ago
what about stuff like child pornography
What about people that make their own kids (I hear humans can do that) and then abuse them? Clearly we should have video cameras in every room to ensure that this doesn't happen.
What if someone, right now, is doing something I don't approve of!? Something must me done!
- corin_ 16y agoBased on that logic we should leave any child porn that's available online up there to avoid governments over-reaching into our privacy?
- jrockway 16y agoYes, exactly. Censorship is censorship. Child porn is illegal because its creation damages the child. Its continued distribution is not the primary problem, the fact that it was created in the first place is. So the solution to child porn is to find it, use good-old-fashioned police work to find who made it, and use the legal system to remove that person's access to children. No need to break the Internet and restrict free speech for this very-special case. Let's spend the money we want to spend on censoring the Internet on more detectives, so that child abuse can be eliminated! The same goes for "counterfeit goods" or whatever the DHS used as rationale for seizing domain names. Don't break the Internet; just buy one of the fake watches, ask UPS where it was shipped from, get a warrant, and bust the guys! Right? (I fear that in the US, though, the problem with child porn is not that children were abused, but that people like something in a sexual way. Consider the person who was mailed a box of comic books that depicted "under-age" children in a sexual context. The government wanted to put him in prison for 15 years. For receiving a box of books. "Sexting" is another example. It's doubtful that one can abuse one's self, but the government still wants to put people in prison for it. What I find most amusing is that all people look pretty much alike when naked. I don't understand why naked pictures are such a hot-button political issue. It seems like the government just doesn't really want any depictions of sex [children, adults, tentacles, or otherwise] around at all. But I digress.)
- jamii 16y agoTo go even further - by driving the distribution further and further underground it becomes harder to track down the originator and prevent the actual abuse. The police/politicians attack distribution because its easier and makes them look like they're doing something.
- jrockway 16y agoExactly. Remember when file-sharing first became popular? Everyone used Napster, which had one centralized indexing server. If someone wanted content removed, they could just ask Napster and it would be gone. This wasn't good enough for the RIAA, which shut Napster down completely. This caused the programming community to come up with an un-blockable alternative, and now everyone uses un-blockable encrypted BiTorrent with DHT. If you want something gone, there is nothing you can do short of shutting down the entire Internet. (It wasn't un-blockable initially, but some greedy ISPs tried to block it, so now it's encrypted UDP instead of cleartext TCP. Now the ISPs can't block it reliably, and they waste their own bandwidth because UDP has no concept of a window size.) So oops... now it's super-easy for people to distribute child porn, all because the music industry got greedy.
- cookiecaper 16y agoI should note, and I make this comment most of the time that someone mentions encrypted BitTorrent, that "encrypted" BitTorrent is not really encrypted. As you mentioned, attempts are made to fudge the protocol and make it hard to recognize that the BitTorrent protocol is being used. It does not, however, provide any encryption or anonymity for your traffic. All packets are sent in the clear, your real IP address is still shown to all connected peers, etc.; do not rely on an "encrypted" BitTorrent connection to save you from a packet-sniffing fiend because the content you're downloading is not given any extra encryption by an encrypted BT connection, because the connection is not really encrypted in the classical sense, it's just obfuscated so that ISPs can't automatically detect BT traffic and disconnect/throttle/filter. "Encryption" was a bad thing to call BT encryption.
- ericb 16y agoLet's not put up straw men. I'm surprised you have so many upvotes for such an absurd argument--not that there aren't valid ways to disagree, but I don't follow your logic. The issue is whether there is speech that is objectionable, and whether free speech has some sort of nearly universal limit if properly considered (yeling fire in a crowded theater, for example) and whether creating a law-free zone might have unintended consequences. I don't see how a straw man implying that all laws require draconian enforcement really benefits the conversation. So we let child molesters do as they please because somehow any law enforcement would mean total and constant invasion of privacy? Not sure I follow the leap.
- jrockway 16y agoI'm saying, kids are being abused, even if there aren't pictures of it on the intarwebs. The internet is not the problem.
- deleted 16y ago[deleted]
- ericb 16y agoThe parent post talked about the distribution of child porn not stopping all child abuse which is why I think you're beating on a straw man.
- cubix 16y agoHe's not beating on a straw man. The problem is you're conflating child abuse with certain patterns of bits floating around on the Internet. I've also heard pedophiles claim that looking at child porn sates their desire to act out those fantasies, so perhaps fewer children are being harmed? That sounds plausible to me since 'normal porn' works, to some degree, as substitute for sex for many non-pedophiles.
- ericb 16y ago> The problem is you're conflating child abuse with certain patterns of bits floating around on the Internet. Please reread my posts. I am talking about the bits. The only place where I talked about actual child molesters (child abuse) was to point out a specific false-choice that jrockway put up--that we had to put cameras everywhere to enforce child abuse laws, which really was defeating an argument that no one made--ie, jrockway was the person who brought up actual child abuse, not the bits. He has articulated his position better in other posts now.