2 ms·
And then we come to the most dangerous item, because you have least control over it: preloading HSTS right into the browser. I can't say specifically why, but
by userbinator 8y ago
And then we come to the most dangerous item, because you have least control over it: preloading HSTS right into the browser.
I can't say specifically why, but there's something about a browser that treats a certain list of sites specially, by default, that just doesn't sit well with me. I've had this feeling ever since I heard about the feature. Not exactly net neutrality, but somewhat reminds me of it.
- defanor 8y agoSounds similar to web browsers coming with their own CA certificates instead of using system-wide ones, leading to poor integration and inconsistencies. Though a centralized database of rules for websites sounds awkward on its own.
- tialaramex 8y ago> Sounds similar to web browsers coming with their own CA certificates instead of using system-wide ones, leading to poor integration and inconsistencies. Well, the only notable browser which does this is Mozilla's Firefox, and not coincidentally the only root trust store where you can actually see how the sausage is made is Mozilla's. All the other big trust stores (Apple, Microsoft, Google) are black boxes. Presumably they have one or more employees dedicated to this stuff, but since we're not shown their working it might equally be the product of an intern throwing darts at a list. Right now for example Mozilla is discussing Certinomis, a small CA which doesn't seem to be very good at the technical aspects of their job, issuing certificates for DNS names with spaces in them, typo'ing dates, filling parameters out incorrectly, nothing that screams "evil" but certainly more clumsy than we'd prefer. Are other trust stores thinking about Certinomis? You'll only find out if one of them announces a change.
- rocqua 8y agoReally, this solution is because the inverse would be to extreme. We cannot say "https by default" except for this list. So instead we go with a list of https only. Really though, most traffic should move to https. Moreover, this solves a real problem. We want sites like paypal, facebook, and gmail to really demand HTTPS. There should not be a race to MitM fresh browser installs.