4 ms·
The country doesn't have a housing crisis. Certain cities do. Certain states do. And the ones with the worst housing problems have the most restrictive real est
by chrisco255 8y ago
The country doesn't have a housing crisis. Certain cities do. Certain states do. And the ones with the worst housing problems have the most restrictive real estate laws.
- spaceheretostay 8y agoI really don't understand this position. The country has a housing crisis because many of the cities in this country do. Removing the connection to the rest of America is an incorrect way of looking at it because of cause and effect: this is such a big problem in America today that it is affecting people who weren't directly in the housing-short markets themselves. A weakness in part of America is a weakness for all of America. It works this way with the outside world too - our housing shortages are part of a global problem. We are all in this together. Framing the issues that the world cities have internally as something that isn't a problem for people living elsewhere is just denying that we live in a connected society. One groups problems affect the other groups. > And the ones with the worst housing problems have the most restrictive real estate laws. Do you have a citation for that? I don't believe it's true.
- ericd 8y agoI don’t have sources on hand, but it’s pretty well established that restrictive zoning is one of the major reasons for the shortage of urban housing that doesn’t meet demand (and hence has helped prices to skyrocket).
- MR4D 8y agoIgnore the citation. Come to Houston and see for your own eyes. We don’t have zoning, and laws are pretty lax. HOAs are another story, but that’s a different issue entirely. New York has a problem - we don’t. And I’m not going to solve their problem because they created the set of choices that led to it. What makes America great is all of these cities get to make their own unique set of mistakes. Over time, we figure out as a whole what works and what doesn’t. Some cities can choose to follow that path or ignore it, but either way, it’s that city’s problem, not everyone’s problem.
- NotSammyHagar 8y agoYou don't make any sense. Cities are part of the country, and the policies of the country affect the cities. The nation has a part in figuring out how to deal with housing issues. For example, the deductability of interest and local taxes has a significant impact on the cost of housing in a city, especially in big cities.
- chrisco255 8y agoNot when it comes to real estate. There are no Federal laws that restrict real estate usage and zoning. Those are local laws at the city, county, and state level. There are some states that don't have an income tax. And mortgage interest deductions are a nice perk but they're not a fundamental factor in supply dynamics. And supply is the primary reason there's an affordability problem in certain cities. Those cities have to end the NIMBY-ism.