2 ms·
> The kind of people who are giving the author PTSD aren't going to be helped by free housing, free money, or free anything other than free medical care, and in
by AnthonyMouse 8y ago
> The kind of people who are giving the author PTSD aren't going to be helped by free housing, free money, or free anything other than free medical care, and in the extreme cases, institutionalization.
That isn't really true. Even among those with mental illness, we can divide those into two groups, those whose illness isn't treatable using current methods and those who are.
For the first case, "free healthcare" doesn't work, because they're incurable. The only real option for a violent person with an incurable mental illness is prison or something so similar to prison as makes no difference in practice.
For the second case, free money does work, because when the problem is access to healthcare, money can be used to buy healthcare. (And when the problem is something else, money can be used to buy something else.) Particularly when you combine this with some kind of system for a homeless person to be evaluated by a doctor when referred by someone like this librarian. Because once they go to the doctor and get what they need in terms of medication, once they're on the medication they would have the wherewithal to use the money to continue taking the medication (and then ideally get into a state where they no longer have to live on the street).
- thatfrenchguy 8y agoFor the first case, free healthcare does work because they get institutionalised even if they don't have money. If you have a decent system, those places are a million times better than prisons.
- AnthonyMouse 8y agoWe had state institutions at one point. They were basically prisons. Moreover, any kind of forced institutionalization is always "free" -- it's not as if you can get out of it for lack of money.