4 ms·
You cite a bunch of very valid criticisms, but then to say directly to the OP (as they posted their own article) that there is "nothing of value here" is excess
by kohanz 7y ago
You cite a bunch of very valid criticisms, but then to say directly to the OP (as they posted their own article) that there is "nothing of value here" is excessive, IMHO, and symptomatic of a kind of discourse that only flies online (unless you would say that to a person's face when they presented you with something they created, and perhaps some people are that direct and lacking in empathetic communication).
Is there new information here? No. But it's presented much differently from the official documentation and perhaps some beginners would find a guide like this less intimidating, more consumable, whatever - people have different learning styles. Maybe the people that would prefer this tutorial over another are a small minority, but I take issue with the sweeping statement that the work the OP put in here created no value for anyone at all.
- aw3c2 7y agoYou are right, I would not say that to a person in meatspace and I should not say things like that to people on the internet either. But: Looking at their other articles gives me the impression of a content creator that just pollutes the internet for keywords, potentially paid-for. Just look at https://heartbeat.fritz.ai/ https://heartbeat.fritz.ai/ , which this random assortment of code snippets was compiled for, it's all just keyword stuffing as promotion for fritz.ai, plain and simple. And oh look, nicely delayed submissions of article after article by OP: https://news.ycombinator.com/submitted?id=salma-ghoneim https://news.ycombinator.com/submitted?id=salma-ghoneim
- Ayeceedee 7y agoWhy not post these observations instead, then? I think what you've written here is much more constructive than what was written above.
- kohanz 7y agoKudos for admitting a misstep and your follow-up analysis is definitely noteworthy. There was a suspicious ratio of upvotes to comments for this thread.