4 ms·
> adequate support in the community for people with severe and enduring mental illness, which is why so many people are trapped in a cycle of homelessness and i
by raverbashing 8y ago
> adequate support in the community for people with severe and enduring mental illness, which is why so many people are trapped in a cycle of homelessness and incarceration.
The level of "adequate support" needed for (some of) those people are much higher than what you're probably imagining
> they just need help and can't get it
And even when they get one day they just say "I'm not taking the meds anymore" and then what? It's back on the streets or homeless hostels.
Sure, they might not be aggressive per se, but that doesn't mean they are "compatible" with society.
> the fundamental questions are why do these people have nowhere else to go? and why is nobody here who actually has the training to help these people?
You're just pointing out problems without pointing up the solutions. And I'm afraid the best solution would be something much similar to what's described in your 1st paragraph.
- jdietrich 8y ago>And even when they get one day they just say "I'm not taking the meds anymore" and then what? It's back on the streets or homeless hostels. If someone goes off their meds, you don't just abandon them to the streets. You send a trained mental health nurse and/or social worker to talk to them, several times a day if necessary. If they don't want to engage, you work with them to build a relationship of trust. You work with that person to get them back on a suitable course of medication, or to help them manage their symptoms and manage their life while unmedicated. You provide supported housing and supported employment or work-related activity wherever it would prove beneficial. You keep working with them again and again and again unless you're damned certain that they're truly beyond help. Of course that's expensive, but it's also remarkably good value for money compared to the alternative. The net difference between a borderline functional person and a completely dysfunctional person can exceed a million dollars per year in policing, incarceration, ER visits and other costs. This model of community care isn't new and it's proven to work and to be cost effective. There are plenty of places in the world that don't rely on mass institutionalisation and have remarkably low rates of homelessness.
- overkill28 8y ago> You send a trained mental health nurse and/or social worker to talk to them, several times a day if necessary. If they don't want to engage, you work with them to build a relationship of trust. You work with that person to get them back on a suitable course of medication, or to help them manage their symptoms and manage their life while unmedicated. Serious question, would you be willing to do that job? For what price? For how long?
- walterstucco 8y agoIt is exactly what happens in most countries here in Europe It already exists, you don't have to invent it.
- SolaceQuantum 8y agoIf I were a trained mental health professional who had also been trained on emotional regulation capable of doing this job in a society where mental health professionals are equal to nurses and doctors I would definitely do this job for the salary equivalent to a nurse or a doctor. I’d be contributing to the greater good much more than my current position writing software that will never change/save lives.
- raverbashing 8y agoYou make it sound like those professionals have some magical training to withstand the abuse, the stress, the bad situations of the job. While they do have some training, it is not possible to shake some things off easily and it does get old quick. One of the reasons why drug abuse is so prevalent in some medical communities.
- Digory 8y agoThe median physician salary is $217,000, and the average family doctor oversees a panel of 2,300 people, who see him or her about 20 minutes, two or three times a year. There is not a sustainable system where workers pay taxes sufficient to afford a specially trained nurse or doctor for full time, personal care for everyone who could benefit from it. If we don’t have social networks that shoulder burdens at what looks like an economic loss, there’s not enough paid care to go around at the levels of empathy we want.
- mlrtime 8y agoTrue, but this shouldn't be done on the streets. At some point they need to be "taken" to a safe facility.
- webmaven 8y agoAt some point, sure. But don't dismiss the persuasive power of free food, shelter from the elements, a bed, laundry service, etc. (especially if those are being provided by the same place! ZOMG, what a concept!) to voluntarily entice most of the homeless population to a safe facility.
- vkou 8y agoWhat happens when this entices someone who is screaming at imaginary aliens between the hours of 3 am to 5 am, uses the hallway as a toilet, and is convinced that his neighbour wants to kill him in his sleep? Do you force-medicate them? Restrain them? Kick them out? Or just let them ruin it for everyone else? What exactly are you proposing the institution should do? What about someone overdosing twice a week? Do you just keep sending ambulances to drive them to the ER, until they finally die, and we can feel smug and superior that, well, at least their human rights weren't infringed?
- 0xcde4c3db 8y agoPeople don't need to be "taken" if they actually expect the facility to be helpful. Too often there are very legitimate reasons that people expect the opposite (e.g. having experienced psych hospitals that are basically just soul-sucking money farms optimized for "processing" patients).