5 ms·
The homeless problems in America have absolutely nothing to do with “survival of the fittest” and your comment is nothing but stereotypes. US cities spend massi
by keiferski 8y ago
The homeless problems in America have absolutely nothing to do with “survival of the fittest” and your comment is nothing but stereotypes. US cities spend massive amounts of money on social issues and the US is in fact the world leader in terms of donations as a percentage of GDP.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_countries_by_charitable_donation https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_countries_by_charitabl...
The homeless problem is mostly attributable to laws in the 70s and 80s which released mentally ill patients from hospitals and prevented their future incarceration.
- frostburg 8y agoThe US also spends a lot of money on healthcare, but it doesn't really work, because the model is flawed.
- keiferski 8y agoYes well that means that the system is broken, not that Americans have some sort of “too bad, the weak should die” mentality (as the OP suggested.)
- ben_w 8y agoThe “too bad, the weak should die” mentality is, unfortunately, very much the impression I get whenever discussing healthcare with Americans. It’s easy (availability heuristic) to forget this says more about the sort of Americans who are likely to engage in discussion about healthcare than about Americans as a whole.
- war1025 8y agoThe main thing I've noticed, as someone who works at a company too small to have cheap insurance and is too well off to get subsidized insurance, is that people who work for big companies genuinely don't think health insurance is a problem in America because their employer is able to get bulk plans where they are paying something like $100 a month out of pocket for absolutely amazing coverage. Then you have the people who used to have great coverage, but it's slowly gotten less good and more expensive over time. They are mainly worried about doing something that will make the problem even worse. Then you have people like me, who are paying ridiculous money for what is basically "catastrophic" insurance, and like to complain loudly any chance we get, mostly on deaf ears because people hope the problem won't come their way if they just ignore it and carry on.
- ben_w 8y agoInteresting perspective, thank you.
- sjy 8y agoSo why hasn't the broken system been fixed (or at least brought up to the standard of the rest of the developed world) yet?
- webmaven 8y agoPolitical donations from for-profit insurance companies. A political ideology centered on market fundamentalism and individual responsibility (eg. "The free market is always more efficient than government provided services", "Why should I pay for your poor choices in life?").
- DanBC 8y ago> The homeless problem is mostly attributable to laws in the 70s and 80s which released mentally ill patients from hospitals and prevented their future incarceration. This is an over-simplification of homelessness that doesn't bear much scrutiny. Many people develop mental ill-health after, not before, becoming homeless. Many people are homeless without "severe mental illness" (schizophrenia, bipolar). https://www.bbrfoundation.org/blog/homelessness-and-mental-illness-challenge-our-society https://www.bbrfoundation.org/blog/homelessness-and-mental-i... > According to a 2015 assessment by the U.S. Department of Housing and Urban Development, 564,708 people were homeless on a given night in the United States. At a minimum, 140,000 or 25 percent of these people were seriously mentally ill, and 250,000 or 45 percent had any mental illness. By comparison, a 2016 study found that 4.2 percent of U.S. adults have been diagnosed with a serious mental illness. Looking at the common disorders we can see the causal direction could easily be "the misery of homelessness causes the mental disorder". > Affective disorders such as depression and bipolar disorder, schizophrenia, anxiety disorders and substance abuse disorders are among the most common types of mental illness in the homeless population.
- Emma_Goldman 8y agoCapitalism is a system of the survival of the fittest, materially, in that people have to subject themselves to the vagaries of the market and sell their labour to acquire they means of life, and culturally, in that people are primarily valued according to their market worth. European countries have tried to offset the marketisation of human life and society through universal healthcare, labour regulations, and (mostly) generous welfare systems. The US does not have universal healthcare, has few of Europe's labour regulations (e.g. mandated working hours, holiday time, sick and paternity leave) and spends half as much on welfare programmes. It would be astonishing if that had nothing to do with American homelessness. The fact that Americans donate a lot means nothing in particular in this context. Little of that goes toward creating a working healthcare and welfare system, or changing the basic moral fabric of American life. The largest share goes towards religions, as I understand it.
- CryptoPunk 8y agoThat's not capitalism. That's the world. You don't eliminate competition and materialism by making private property illegal. You just make competition less socially beneficial. For example your energy is diverted to gaming a welfare program, or lobbying for more benefits for the disadvantaged group you are a member of, instead of creating a company or product that raises everyone's productivity.
- Emma_Goldman 8y agoThat statement would only hold if capitalist market relations were a universal feature of every facet of human life, and if humans were driven only and voraciously by self-interest. But neither of those things are true. Economics is one sphere of human life, alongside culture, society, politics, and ethics and religion. The relative importance of these spheres is not fixed, but changes over time. One of the aims of the welfare state is to constrain capitalist market relations in order to make room for other spheres of life, for democratic control, family and community, moral values, and cultural creativity. You appear to be claiming that humans are, always and everywhere, solely moved to maximise their material interests. That has no anthropological plausibility whatsoever, and reveals a deep misanthropy on your part. Contrary to your suggestion that welfare claimants comprehensively exploit the system, official statistics in the UK state that only about 2% of claimants do.
- lostmyoldone 8y agoDonations as a percentage of GDP is a terrible metric when comparing with countries where caring for the disenfranchised is seen as the responsibility of the government and almost wholly funded by taxes. It's absolutely stunning that there is > 1.5 million non-profits in the US, and one has to question why? Looking at a bunch of them in the homeless causes, and seing that it's not unusual at all that the chief executives of tiny non-profits receives $100 000-$200 000 in compensation which in many cases is 4%-7% of the expense budget, one might be tempted to think that many of the non-profits and their donations are based more on economy than empathy.