4 ms·
It gets worse. In my days as an attorney i had contact with people who arent allowed into public libraries. Think being homeless is bad, have pitty for those
by sandworm101 8y ago
It gets worse. In my days as an attorney i had contact with people who arent allowed into public libraries. Think being homeless is bad, have pitty for those homeless also convicted of certain crimes. Many shall never again be allowed near a school, park, library or recreation center. They live under bridges without the option of visiting such friendly places.
It is easy to help the innocent. Real charity comes when asked to help someone you may hate.
- michaelvoz 8y agoMaybe they should not have committed those crimes. Or are you suggesting they are unfairly punished?
- Sharlin 8y agoYes, that sort of indefinite exclusion from public locations is certainly unfair. "Cruel and unusual", even, from a Western European perspective anyway.
- sandworm101 8y agoPeople who have commit crimes are still people. Homelessness should not be used or seen as a valid punishment.
- michaelvoz 8y agoHomelessness is not their punishment. Not being allowed in libraries, schools, etc, is.
- sandworm101 8y agoHomelessness is used as punishment: https://youtu.be/vP0gTksLU8g https://youtu.be/vP0gTksLU8g https://youtu.be/852ZyRIPdjI https://youtu.be/852ZyRIPdjI
- michaelvoz 8y agoI don't particularly feel bad for sex offenders. If you can't control yourself...
- vageli 8y agoPeople get put on sex offender lists for urinating in public. Not saying that's what happened here but it's worth considering before passing judgement.
- DanBC 8y agoIf they can't control themselves we really don't want them wandering around the streets, we want to know where they are. Constant monitoring is an important reoffending protection measure for some sex offenders.
- prepend 8y agoYou want to know where public urinators are?
- gerbilly 8y agoYeah, how else can we use big data to figure out where to build new public toilets?
- DanBC 8y ago> IF THEY CAN'T CONTROL THEMSELVES bold added. This comment about sex offender lists being full of people who had a single piss in public, but whenever I've asked for evidence people post maybe three or four examples. Feel free to show me research that these public urinators aren't people flashing to children.
- HocusLocus 8y agoBut you should try to discover the truth about them, or reserve judgement. The original dire presumed meaning of "sex offender" has been legally castrated (bad joke) in many states as shallow thinkers seize on the definition and its National implications to CHEAPLY hang any behavior THEY consider objectionable. The most egregious misapplication (in my opinion) is "public urination", that is, being caught doing it by the wrong person, or if they consider you an unperson. Used to brand the homeless and turn them into national criminals by following them around with a camera. Or human traditions under attack. A mixed group of adults and minors caught skinny dipping in the wild by the Wrong Deputy is another example. They'll nail the oldest and fill the younger with crushing guilt, if they are friends. Consensual sex between teenagers is another. It's the ultimate glass-house throw stone legal abomination. And one or both gets the Scarlet Letter into their young adult years. Talk about a suicide trigger! ___ https://www.hrw.org/report/2007/09/11/no-easy-answers/sex-offender-laws-us https://www.hrw.org/report/2007/09/11/no-easy-answers/sex-of... "Most people assume that a registered sex offender is someone who has sexually abused a child or engaged in a violent sexual assault of an adult. A review of state sex offender registration laws by Human Rights Watch reveals that states require individuals to register as sex offenders even when their conduct did not involve coercion or violence, and may have had little or no connection to sex. For example: "At least five states require registration for adult prostitution-related offenses;[108]* "At least 13 states require registration for public urination; of those, two limit registration to those who committed the act in view of a minor;[109] "At least 29 states require registration for consensual sex between teenagers;[110] and "At least 32 states require registration for exposing genitals in public;[111] of those, seven states require the victim to be a minor.[112]
- ben_w 8y agoI consider that to be a cruel and unusual punishment.
- dTal 8y agoDo you think that's an effective deterrent? Do people go "better not download that inappropriately underage video, they might not let me in the library anymore"? And, if a punishment is not an effective deterrent - what's the point of it? What are we trying to achieve? Going meta - your comments are all along the lines of crime and punishment and whether they "deserve" it etc. The replies to you are all along pragmatic lines - what we should do to make society behave the way we want. These approaches are incompatible - when the pragmatic approach disagrees with the fire-and-brimstone approach, ignoring pragmatism will by definition get a worse outcome. Your own feeling of righteous anger is not a good thing to optimize society around. The notion of justice and punishment is a subsidiary mechanism to pragmatism - one of many ways to achieve a peaceful, stable society. (One that does not appear to scale especially well beyond groups where everyone knows each other, or into deeply complicated and partially enforced rule sets. Don't kill your tribe member or the tribe will cast you out = effective. Don't exceed the speed limit or you might possibly receive a fine of some constant amount plus a proportional factor to the amount you exceeded it by = ineffective.)
- nexuist 8y agoThink of what these places offer. Schools provide structured education, parks provide nature, libraries provide knowledge, and recreation centers encourage physical fitness. Now think of being barred from all of these opportunities. Yes, they committed a crime, and yes, it may not a good idea to allow them to mingle with other people sharing these facilities (especially if these people are children) but...where else does one go to improve oneself? You'd think, especially after being charged with a heinous crime, anyone who truly wishes to reform themselves would benefit from these places. But it is those exact people who are barred from doing just that, and the cycle repeats, because there is no way out. I'm not saying there's an easy answer here, and it wouldn't be feasible to rebuild these places for criminals only. But these restrictions absolutely make it difficult to integrate and become a productive member of society again.
- DanBC 8y agoOf course they should not have committed those crimes, and their victims deserve justice. But justice isn't served by making someone homeless and then preventing them visiting a library. Importantly, that also doesn't help with rehabilitation or with preventing reoffending. If you have a sex offender at risk of re-offending you want to know where they are and what jobs they have. That's made much harder if they're homeless.
- chrisrogers 8y agoWhat are some examples of those certain crimes?
- sandworm101 8y agoMostly sex offenders. Rape, assault, and anything involving children, but also some minor things. Public urination is a sex offence in some parts of the US. The reality today is that most, think 90%+, involves purely online activity. These arent rapists. They are caught downloading stuff.
- tomjen3 8y agoThey are caught downloading images of children being raped? Yeah, I reserve my sympathy for the children.
- Carpetsmoker 8y agoYou can have sympathy for both? Besides, it's not even about "sympathy", it's about preventing crime and general nuisance (like for the librarian in this article). I don't think anyone wins by making circumstances for sex offenders so hard they're living on the street. I'd much rather have these people in a safe environment with proper counselling/therapy.
- tomjen3 8y agoI don't think you can have sympathy for both. As for the rest it isn't just about forcing them to live on the street, ideally I wouldn't let them live in society at all, far away under a bridge is the closest I can get.